Back to search

University of Victoria (Canada)

The hunting of the snark : an enquiry into the provenance, perplexities and persistence of the idea of virtual representation

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

When in the eighteenth century American colonists pro­tested taxation without representation or English reformers demanded popular representation, the British parliament re­fused to entertain such notions on the ground that everyone was virtually represented. In the absence of a large corpus of justificatory literature on the subject to match that of the colonists and the reformers, what was meant by virtual representation eludes definition. Why members of parliament chose this particular argument to resist demands for wider representation and whether their attitude was legitimate or merely an argument from expedience are other questions that have so far gone unanswered. Such puzzles can only be solved by searching for the source of the theory and determining whether or not it was constitutionally sound. Since the theory of virtual representation had the effect of defending the independence of the House of Commons, some of the answers can be found by examining the evolution of parliament from the reign of Henry VIII when the process of whittling away at royal authority began. Exploration of the work of the major political theorists in the two hundred years preceding the mid-eighteenth century helps further in understanding the constitutional arrangements of the eighteenth century and the basis for the assumptions that were made by the participants in the debate on representation. Finally, a study of the course, nature and outcome of that debate aids in revealing the full extent and depth of the theory of virtual representation. While there is evidence that the theory was employed to protect the interests of members of parliament, the gentry and the supremacy of the House of Commons, there is much to support the view that it had a long and respectable tradition of acceptance, and that even the political theory used to sustain the cause of the American colonists and the English reformers could equally well legitimize the claim of those who argued for virtual representation. The strength of the theory lay in its pragmatism and in the fact that it described what was rather than what ought to be. Nevertheless, virtual representation remains an elusive entity not the least because there was considerable confusion on the part of eighteenth-century controversialists concerning its nature. They failed to see that virtual representation had never worked without some measure of "directness" any more than "direct" representation up to the present day has been able to function without some degree of the "virtual." By treating direct and virtual representation as two opposing principles rather than two aspects of the same question, writers and politicians of the eighteenth century created a problem that did not exist and engaged in a debate that never came to grips with the real issue which concerned the balance between the two. The correctness of this balance could be decided only by "opinion" or, how much virtual as opposed to direct representation the governed were willing to accept.

Degree

thesis:*
Level thesis:degree_level
Master of Arts M.A.
Department thesis:degree_department
Department of History
Year dc:date.issued
1978

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Murray, Tonita

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • Available to the World Wide Web

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Handle dc:identifier.uri
https://hdl.handle.net/1828/19085

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Victoria (Canada)
Base URL
dspace.library.uvic.ca/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Murray, Tonita. The hunting of the snark : an enquiry into the provenance, perplexities and persistence of the idea of virtual representation. Master of Arts M.A. thesis, 1978. https://hdl.handle.net/1828/19085