University of Victoria (Canada)
Seen to be done: Credibility, performance, and legitimacy in R v McLeod et al.
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThis thesis explores how legal credibility is built and challenged in high-profile Canadian sexual-assault trials, through the single embedded case study of the R v McLeod et al. (the 2018 World Junior sexual assault proceedings, or "R v McLeod et al."). With specific attention to the court's reasons and credibility analysis, this thesis examines the acquittal of five former Canadian World Junior hockey players, followed allegations of group sexual assault after a Hockey Canada Foundation Gala and Golf event in June 2018. At the time the charges were laid, all five accused were playing professional hockey, including four in the NHL. In an era of media saturation and institutional crises, Canadian courts are increasingly expected not only to deliver justice, but to be seen to do so. I refer to this concept as "mediatized justice," a cultural-legal paradigm where courts must perform this "fairness" as much as courts may enact it procedurally. Despite legal reforms intending to curb rape myth-based reasoning within sexual assault procedures, the Canadian criminal justice system continues to struggle to accommodate the complexities of trauma testimony and fairness, particularly where powerful institutions, intense publicity, and multiple accused are involved. Drawing on feminist legal theory (in particular, Judith Butler's concept of grievability), critical legal theory, and media spectacle theory, this thesis applies critical discourse analysis to the judgment, institutional statements, and media coverage. I examine how legal actors navigate the tension between the presumption of innocence and the realities of trauma, memory, and evidentiary rules. A close reading of Justice Maria Carroccia's decision reveals that while rape myths were formally rejected, the decision still relied on credibility markers, such as affect regulation, evidentiary clarity, and timeline analysis in a manner that I argue is trauma incompatible. I also analyze Hockey Canada's efforts to manage public perception, as well as the post-trial discourse around judicial neutrality and activism. Rather than calling for retributive outcomes or symbolic reform or for the court to act in an "activist" manner, this thesis advocates for procedural and evidentiary shifts that center trauma-informed fairness. This can prompt a reconsideration of what it means for courts to adjudicate legitimacy of the complainant in high profile sexual assault trials, and in the age of media visibility.
Degree
thesis:*- Level thesis:degree_level
- Master of Laws LLM
- Department thesis:degree_department
- Faculty of Law
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Sapic, Lauren
- Advisors dc:contributor.supervisor
-
- Calder, Gillian
- O’Bonsawin, Christine
Subjects
dc:subject × 11Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- Available to the World Wide Web
- Language dc:language.iso
- en, English
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Handle dc:identifier.uri
- https://hdl.handle.net/1828/23722