Virginia Commonwealth University
Motivations and Conflicts in Prison Medical Contracting
Abstract
dc:description.abstractState correctional departments are responsible for all medical care incarcerated individuals require. Many systems outsource their medical State correctional departments are responsible for all medical care incarcerated individuals require. Many systems outsource their medical program. Literature indicates that many of these contracts experience significant issues that negatively impact state resources, including both personnel and money. This dissertation explores the relationship between prison administrators' motivations and the structure, outcomes, efficiencies, and partner conflicts that arise in the contractual process. Using a framework developed from Incomplete Contract Theory, Contracts as Reference Points Theory and the concept of “essential tension,” this dissertation hypothesizes that the administrator’s motivation will impact the likelihood of success, contract efficiencies and partnership conflicts in case of prison medical contracts. The mixed-method study employs both quantitative and qualitative research methods. Study results indicate a preliminary finding that public administrators’ motivation does correlates with predictable differences in contract design and contract outcomes. States motivated to improve cost control, are more likely to allow the vendor space to manage financial resources but restrict the ability to determine efficient ways to achieve quality, which seems associated with problems in outputs, efficiencies and conflicts. These findings have implications for contracting and the use of contracts by public administrators. The results suggest that contract completeness is more nuanced than a contract being complete or not complete on the whole. Additionally, the application of completeness and incompleteness in different sections can be an intentional and strategic action on the part of the public administrator that could be used to enhance the usefulness of a complex contract. . Literature indicates that many of these contracts experience significant issues that negatively impact state resources, including both personnel and money. This dissertation explores the relationship between prison administrators' motivations and the structure, outcomes, efficiencies, and partner conflicts that arise in the contractual process. Using a framework developed from Incomplete Contract Theory, Contracts as Reference Points Theory and the concept of “essential tension,” this dissertation hypothesizes that the administrator’s motivation will impact the likelihood of success, contract efficiencies and partnership conflicts in case of prison medical contracts. The mixed-method study employs both quantitative and qualitative research methods. Study results indicate a preliminary finding that public administrators’ motivation does correlates with predictable differences in contract design and contract outcomes. States motivated to improve cost control, are more likely to allow the vendor space to manage financial resources but restrict the ability to determine efficient ways to achieve quality, which seems associated with problems in outputs, efficiencies and conflicts. These findings have implications for contracting and the use of contracts by public administrators. The results suggest that contract completeness is more nuanced than a contract being complete or not complete on the whole. Additionally, the application of completeness and incompleteness in different sections can be an intentional and strategic action on the part of the public administrator that could be used to enhance the usefulness of a complex contract.
Degree
thesis:*- Name thesis:degree_name
- Doctor of Philosophy
- Level thesis:degree_level
- Dissertation
- Discipline thesis:degree_discipline
- Public Policy & Administration
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Authors dc:creator
-
- Sok, Meagan D
- https://orcid.org/0009-0004-1911-0637
- Contributors dc:contributor
-
- Niraj Verma
- Carolyn Watts
- Sarah Jane Brubaker
- I-Shian Suen
Subjects
dc:subject × 11- public contracting
- motivation to contract
- prison medical contracts
- incomplete contract theory
- contracts as reference points theory
- essential tension
- Health Policy
- Other Public Affairs, Public Policy and Public Administration
- Policy Design, Analysis, and Evaluation
- Public Administration
- Public Affairs
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- © The Author
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Identifier
- https://scholarscompass.vcu.edu/etd/7542