Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Universitetų jungimai Lietuvoje: 2017 metais pradėto aukštojo mokslo tinklo optimizavimo sėkmės vertinimas /
Abstract
dc:descriptionMerging universities is a common way for the state to ensure that the higher education network is working as efficiently as possible, consequently making a positive impact on the overall quality of higher education. However, consolidating 2 or more multi-layered higher education institutions into one is complicated – there are a lot of different interests, ideas, and values at play. This can be seen when analyzing the optimization of the Lithuanian university network, which was started by the 17th government of Lithuania back in 2017. There is no unanimous agreement on whether this higher education network overhaul was successful or not – those who implemented this policy see it as a win, contrary to their opponents. Therefore, the study is resolved around measuring the success of before mentioned Lithuanian higher education network reform. Although it might seem that the success of public policy is straightforward and only consists of possible binary outcomes, that is not the case according to A. McConnell, whose theoretical framework is being used in this study. The author argues, that the instances of public policy resulting in a complete success or failure are almost non-existent. Therefore, the success of public policy should be divided into 3 dimensions: public policy as a process, program, and politics, thus providing the possibility to have a wider array of potential results. Each of these dimensions has multiple criteria which should be evaluated separately, using a scale consisting of 5 different success outcomes. Therefore, the main objective of this study is to evaluate the success of Lithuanian university mergers using A. McConnell‘s theoretical framework, thus providing a holistic ex-post type analysis. Given the aim of the study, the problem of the bachelor thesis is formulated as follows: what determines the degree of success when optimizing the Lithuanian university network? Using qualitative content analysis and descriptive methods, the study further examines the abilities of policymakers during organizing and implementation processes, which include maintaining goals and instruments, building a sustainable coalition, ability to achieve desired outcomes and benefits for the target group, ability to implement the policy legitimately, fluently and effectively. The study also examines whether public policy was innovative or not and its effects on the policymakers’ popularity. The results of the study showed that all 3 dimensions fall into the “Precarious success” category, which is on the failure part of the spectrum, mainly because some of the goals set out were partly achieved. Although the findings showed that the results of the 3 evaluation dimensions were in line with each other, it did not deny the possibility of having a conflictive result when evaluating another public policy. The study concludes with recommendations on how to improve the policy implementation success in futureLithuanian higher education network reforms: 1) policymakers need to avoid rushing the merging processes between universities; 2) in addition to having enough time to plan and prepare for mergers, policymakers need to organize extensive independent expertise on potential mergers before implementation; 3) planning process should involve the academic community as much as possible. There should be sufficient incentives and guarantees from the Government side to ensure university communities’ positive attitude towards the merging process; 4) university mergers should only happen when the policymakers have a sufficient amount of political will to finish the process while maintaining the same goals, otherwise it might discredit the policy as well as the policymakers themselves.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Matjošaitis, Juozas,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD192836553&prefLang=en_US