Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
I. Šimonytės bei A. Kubiliaus Vyriausybių sveikatos apsaugos reformų sprendimų priėmimo lyginamoji analizė /
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis thesis examines the reforms of A. Kubilius and I. Šimonytė's Governments health care systems, which were initiated during crisis, therefore, in the author's opinion, this provided an opportunity to assess the impact of crises on reforms, which has so far been little studied in Lithuania. Also it was found out what other contextual factors could be relevant and decisive when undertaking structural reforms in Lithuania. After conducting a literature review, a theoretical hypothesis is constructed. The assumptions were applied to empirical research and based on the advocacy coalition framework developed by P.A.Sabatier and complementary methodologies aimed to confirm or deny the hypothesis. After evaluating the reforms, analyzing the empirical reality, conducted research and studies, and theoretical material, a hypothesis is formed that the influence of different types of crises (through the intermediate variables of the state of public finances and support of coalitions) likely had a different effect on the adoption processes of both health care reforms. In the case of A. Čaplikas reform, the crisis forced to look for ways to optimize the budget of the health care system, but it did not become an impetus. After the analysis, it can be stated that the crisis had a significant impact on the prioritization of works and thus the secondary issue - the reform of the health care system - did not receive significant support. The crisis "worked" by looking for other numerous ways to adopt reforms without the approval of the Seimas since at that time the focus of the position was the control of the financial crisis etc. During the term of office of A. Dulkys, three crisis situations coincided. Despite fiscal pressure due to the Eurozone factor a more sustainable financial situation, the crisis manifested itself through increased EU funding and support which could have already been planned for the implementation of the reform. In addition, it is likely that COVID-19 had a significant impact on gaining the much-needed trust of Prime Minister I. Šimonytė regarding the minister's leadership of the Emergency Situations Commission. The change of the manager at that time could cause great damage in the management of the situation so despite the various scandals that arose, the Prime Minister supported A. Dulkys. The conducted study revealed that the variables observed by other authors and after the empirical study are no less important - the importance of communication, the influence of interest groups, which most likely did not change when comparing the reforms with each other. Although it could be assumed that crisis situations should mobilize coalitions for work, making use of the policy windows that have opened for decisive changes, but it can be observed that the opportunities were not used as expected and the impact of crises manifested itself through other aspects. In the first case (A. Čaplikas) it manifested negatively, when the coalition's support for the reform of the health care system was insufficient and other issues were prioritized, in the second case (A. Dulkys) it manifested itself not through the coalition variable, but through the relationship between the Prime Minister and A. Dulkys. The conclusion of this work, could become the basis for future research that would help determine a more accurate "combination" of decisive factors during the crisis and could have a significant impact on decision-making. As observed during the research the influence of only one factor on decision-making is often insufficient. In the case of these, health care system reforms a combination of at least several factors of a different nature always worked, so future studies should take this into account. In addition, a more precise analysis could be conducted after the decision-making processes of A. Dulkys reform were over, because this work was done before the reform was over and other variables could not be evaluated objectively.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Petniūnas, Einaras,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD192836842&prefLang=en_US