Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Privalomosios karo tarnybos Lietuvoje karinio efektyvumo analizė /
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe problem of the thesis "Analysis of military effectiveness of Lithuanian mandatory military service" is that there is no constructive discussion in Lithuania in terms of improving the military effectiveness of the permanent compulsory initial military service (PCIMS), and therefore there is no concrete decision either at the societal level or at the academic level on how this form of military service should function effectively. It is also important to emphasise that no research related to military effectiveness in conscript-type armies can be found in Lithuanian academia, which means that military effectiveness is undeservedly neglected at the academic level. It is from this problem that the aim of this bachelor thesis arises - to find out what is the relationship between military effectiveness and the PCIMS in the Lithuanian case. The object of the research can be identified as the current model of PCIMS in Lithuania. The thesis aims to prove the following defensive statement: the fundamental point of research of the PCIMSin academics' research and politicians' works should be military effectiveness, and not the social and economic consequences of this type of service. The bachelor thesis is based on the theory of military effectiveness developed by US academics Alan R. Millet and Williamson Murray. The underlying assumption of this theory is that military effectiveness occurs at four different levels: political, strategic, operational and tactical. Each of the four levels identified in the theory also has its own elements, which help to assess the level of military effectiveness more precisely. Bachelor thesis uses case study, document analysis and semi-structured interviews (10 of them were carried out in order to find out the attitudes of the most important institutions towards the military effectiveness of the PCIMS). This Bachelor's thesis has three main objectives. Firstly, to introduce and apply the military effectiveness theory of A. R. Millet and W. Murray and to develop a research model. Then, using a mixed social science research methodology, to collect the empirical material needed for the study. Finally, based on the military effectiveness theory used in the paper, the aim will be to analyse the collected empirical material and to assess the validity and relevance of the theory in the Lithuanian case. Conclusions: the empirical material collected and the analysis carried out has revealed that there are significant problems related to the military effectiveness of Lithuanian PCIMS. The analysis has confirmed the problems of the thesis - both the material collected during the interviews and the analysis of documents prove that too little attention is paid to the military effectiveness of the PCIMS in Lithuania, there is no formed understanding of what military effectiveness is and how it should be increased. The research allowed to partially confirm the thesis defensive statement - military effectiveness should have a much more important place in the discussions of reforms and supervision of the PCIMS, but military effectiveness is not the only important aspect in the research and improvement of the PCIMS service. The study also highlighted the problem of imbalance in the relationship between PCIMS and military effectiveness: reforms related to PCIMS fail to effectively balance the quantitative and qualitative dimensions. Finally, the data collected allow us to identify a clear perspective for the future of the PCIMS - both at the military and political level, there is an aspiration to move towards the greatest possible universality, which paves the way for the future introduction of universal military service in Lithuania. The two main ways of continuation of this bachelor's thesis are the further development of Murray and Millet's military effectiveness model for the study of the PCIMS model or the use of this theoretical model for the study of the entire Lithuanian Armed Forces.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Stunžinas, Matas,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD192838016&prefLang=en_US