Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Kodėl vyksta demokratijų nuosmukis: Čekijos ir Lenkijos lyginamoji analizė /
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe main object of the bachelor thesis "What causes the democratic backsliding: a comparative analysis of the Czech Republic and Poland" is the phenomenon of the democratic backsliding. As Czechia and Poland are two similar countries – neighbours, post-Soviet countries, members of the Visegrad group, NATO and the EU, which implies that states should uphold democratic attributes, the question arises why Poland's liberal democracy has been backsliding since 2015, while Czechia‘s has remained stable. Thus, the aim of this paper is to assess the factors behind the backsliding of liberal democracy: to identify the key variables that have diverged and have led to the backsliding of liberal democracy in Poland and its stability in Czechia. The objectives of the study are: 1) present the theories of democratic backsliding and the variables relevant to Czechia and Poland; 2) chronologically analyse key events relevant to each variable; 3) assess the validity of the variables and provide potential outlook for the future. The empirical analysis, with some exceptions, allowed to confirm H1 that radical right populists in power will lead to a greater democratic backsliding than centrist populist parties, as most of the sub-hypotheses were confirmed. First, while the discretion of the executive have increased under the rule of centrist populist ANO party, which has slightly undermined the quality of liberal democracy in Czechia, it has not reached a level where this form of government can be questioned. In contrast, the ambitions of the radical right PiS were illiberal, its extreme views made it easier to justify authoritarian strategies and to flout the principle of separation of powers, which confirmed H1.1 that radical right populist parties are more likely to expand executive power than centrist populist parties. Second, the more moderate ideology of the ANO, which is more oriented towards technocratism than nationalism, has led to less discriminatory rhetoric and media restrictions in Czechia than in Poland, where the elite has promoted marginalising narratives and severely restricted media freedom. This proved H1.3 that radical right populist parties are more likely to limit the culture of deliberation than centrist populist parties. Third, the level of corruption in neighbouring countries is similar, which does not support H1.2 that radical right populist parties are more likely to increase corruption than centrist populist parties. This implies that the type of populism does not affect the level of corruption. Corruption is more influenced by the extent to which pragmatic politicians are entrenched in a country. This partly explains why Czechia‘s liberal democracy has been damaged. The analysis also assessed the role of mass mobilisation as a factor in resilience to democratic backsliding. While civil resistance was strong in both cases, in Poland the entrenched power of the government, fragmented protests, repression and the impact of the pandemic made it more difficult to convert mobilisation into tangible change. In Czechia, the situation was reversed, which contributed to a more successful resistance to democratic backsliding, confirming H2 that strong social mobilisation will lead to a greater resilience to democratic backsliding. In sum, this study contributes to a better understanding about the process of the backsliding of liberal democracy. The results show that populism is detrimental to democracy, but that the nature of populism largely determines the degree of damage. In addition to the radicalism of the populist elite, the extent to which the public is willing to fight for democratic values has a major impact on the country's resilience to democratic erosion. In order to better understand the causes of democratic backsliding, more quantitative case studies should be carried out in the future, including more variables such as religion, history, institutional set-up and economics, as political processes is complex.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Bakšanskas, Aušridas,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD192838254&prefLang=en_US