Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Autonominių ginklų sistemų įtaka jus in bello: Rusijos karo Ukrainoje atvejis /
Abstract
dc:descriptionAs the use of AWS increases worldwide, autonomous functions such as modular cameras or satellite navigation, which allow the system to autonomously identify, track and strike targets, are being developed at an extraordinary pace, but there is no international agreement on their use in the framework of international humanitarian law (IHL). This raises the research question: Are the autonomous weapons systems used in the Russian war in Ukraine compliant with the norms of just warfare? The case of the Russian war in Ukraine was chosen with the aim to investigate whether the autonomous weapon systems used in the Russian war in Ukraine are compliant with the norms of just warfare, based on the criteria of the jus in bello assumption of the Just War Theory and the interpretative case study approach. Just War Theory was chosen as it provides three key criteria (proportionality, discrimination, and military necessity) that allow the analysis of the autonomous functions of unmanned systems and their compatibility with just war norms. The interpretive case study approach was chosen, allowing the researcher to use the theoretical framework as an essential explanatory tool. It also allows for the development of an original research model, an analysis of the use of AWS in the Russian war in Ukraine, and an assessment of the relevance of the theory used. The goal of the thesis was achieved through the following objectives: A. Analyze which autonomous weapon systems are used in the Russian war in Ukraine and identify their autonomous functions; B. Examine the compliance of autonomous weapon system functions with jus in bello criteria under the cross-sections of (1) technical capabilities, (2) military context, and (3) intent; C. Analyze whether the use of autonomous weapon systems can be compatible with the norms of international humanitarian law and contribute to the debate on the effective regulation of these weapons highlighted in the theoretical part. The results of the analysis indicate that AWS are compatible with the norms of just warfare. Autonomous functions facilitate attacks that meet the jus in bello criteria, but human intent tends to have a decisive impact on the outcome. Nevertheless, AWS are evolving at a very fast pace and it is expected that in the future they will be able to perform more actions autonomously, without the need for an operator. Already, some of the AWS examined are capable of autonomous target identification, tracking, and striking, due to rapidly advancing autonomous functions. The ability to deploy a precise, stealthy, and effective autonomous weapon in place of a soldier is an advantage that will not be denied by Russia, Ukraine, or any of the other world powers that are keeping a close eye on the use of AWS. We can therefore expect even more advanced and innovative uses of AWS over time. Alongside this trend, we are witnessing an unprecedented breakthrough in artificial intelligence in our daily lives. This means that we are already on the path toward unmanned drones, which, through improved machine learning, will be able to carry out more complex missions on the battlefield. One of the shortcomings of AWS was the inaccurate identification of targets – an important step in order to carry out attacks that meet jus in bello constraints. Progress in AI and video capture equipment is likely to curb this shortcoming. However, much of AWS compatibility with jus in bello will depend on how and when regulation of these weapons is implemented. This study provides a basis for analyzing new AWS models, emerging autonomous functions, their performance, and applications on the battlefield that have not yet been explored in this thesis. Such research would not only allow for a critical assessment of best practices in the use of AWS in war but also help to consolidate the evidence of potential violations of IHL.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Urbonas, Nojus Arnis,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD192838309&prefLang=en_US