Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Lietuvos ir Latvijos įkalinimo tendencijų lyginamoji analizė /
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe criminal justice system is faced with a critical challenge of reducing the number of individuals in prisons. This issue has been recognized by international organizations such as the United Nations, which prioritize the well-being of incarcerated persons. Countries with fewer prisoners are perceived as free states that prioritize human rights, and this is highly regarded globally. Thus, every state aims to achieve the lowest possible incarceration rate. That‘s why as the main purpose of the final bachelor thesis was chosen to find out reasons that leads to a higher rate of incarceration in Lithuania compared to neighboring Latvia and to review the current trends in incarceration in these two Baltic states. Due to the imprisonment statistics of both countries, a problematic question arose - what reasons can lead to a sudden separation from Latvia when comparing the number of imprisoned persons since 2012, and why Lithuania cannot reduce the number of imprisoned persons as effectively as the Republic of Latvia. Comparative and process tracing methods of scientific literature and document analysis were used during the research. In this work, 4 main hypotheses are put forward: 1) greater social support for citizens leads to lower rates of incarceration in the state; 2) a lower unemployment rate leads to a higher incarceration rate: 3) the higher the crime rate, the higher the incarceration rate in the state; 4) a milder criminal policy leads to a lower number of imprisoned persons in the country. Due to the chosen hypotheses, the main tasks of this work have became: 1) based on theoretical material about different prison practices, to operationalize dependent and independent work variables; 2) to review the incarceration rates of Lithuania and Latvia with the selected independent variables that can influence the dependent variable; 3) after conducting an empirical study, to identify the main assumptions due to which the numbers of imprisoned persons in Lithuania differ from those in Latvia. Empirical research conducted using the available theoretical information made it possible to find out that the welfare indicators, the unemployment rate and the crime rate do not have a significant impact on the number of imprisoned persons. The softening aspect of the policy had the greatest impact. It was found out that Lithuania implements a policy of toughening penalties, while Latvia, on the contrary, implements a policy of softening penalties. The results have revealed that both implemented policies do not have negative consequences, but the policy of softening the penalties works more efficiently and faster than the policy of increasing the penalties. In this thesis, the remainder of previous work is expected to further expand the circle of scientific research and it is expected that this thesis project aims to build on previous work by incorporating new theoretical methods and adding modern case studies to the existing literature. It is worth considering whether the economic situation of the states, the culture of punishment, citizens' trust in the prison as an institution have an influence on the incarceration rates. Also, when looking for research papers, the prevailing opinion in Lithuanian political discourse is that the punishment system needs to be softened, but the adopted reforms make the punishment system tougher. It would be worthwhile to examine this paradox in further research. It is expected that in the future the subject of the imprisonment rates of Lithuania and Latvia will be further developed and each state will be able to apply the effective practices of punishment policy in its criminal punishment system. I hope that this work will create a broader dialogue comparing the incarceration trends of the two countries.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Baseckaitė, Rugilė,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD192838331&prefLang=en_US