Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Migrantų integracijos politikos sąlygos: kas lemia darbo rinkos (ne)palankumą migrantams VRE valstybėse? /
Abstract
dc:descriptionAttracting migrants to the declining populations of Central and Eastern European (CEE) countries is one way to maintain a positive economic situation. However, based on MIPEX, only half of the CEE countries studied in this paper have rather favourable labour market integration policies (Czech Republic, Estonia, Lithuania, Bulgaria, Romania), whereas the other half - rather unfavourable (Hungary, Poland, Slovakia, Slovenia, Latvia). So, what conditions determine unfavourable labour market integration policies in CEE countries? Existing research on migrant integration policies often reveals contradictory findings, hence theoretical clarity has not yet been achieved. Moreover, most studies are unable to show the complex relationships between different conditions, making qualitative comparative analysis (QCA) useful here. This paper thus seeks to identify the conditions that determine policies for labour market integration. Therefore, the thesis aims to (1) identify the most significant conditions in the literature for migrant integration policies; (2) document the research methodology; and (3) conduct QCA and investigate the results. Based on the theory, the main hypotheses of the study are as follows: favourable labour market integration policies are determined by the political left (H1a), liberal and social democratic welfare regimes (H3a), and favourable public attitudes towards migrants (H4b); unfavourable policies are determined by the political right (H1b), strong radical-right parties (H2), conservative welfare regimes (H3b), and anti-immigrant public attitudes (H4a). The QCA allowed to confirm all these hypotheses, but it revealed that none of the conditions is sufficient on its own - a conjunction of conditions is necessary. Moreover, there is no single sufficient conjuncture, indicating multiple causality. Favourable policies are caused by (1) strong radical right parties and anti-immigrant public attitudes and (2) a right-wing government, strong radical right parties and a conservative welfare regime; unfavourable policies are determined by (3) weak radical right parties and a liberal welfare regime, and (4) left-wing government, favourable public attitudes towards migrants and a liberal welfare regime. The economic condition of the welfare regime is found to be the least significant, suggesting that the migrant integration issue is largely politicised. Moreover, although radical right parties are mostly associated only with unfavourable integration policies (H2), it is revealed that low public support for these parties contributes to favourable policies. This can be explained by the direct and indirect (in)capacities of radical right parties to influence migration policy. Overall, these findings contribute to the literature on migrant integration and, more specifically, to the gap in research on migrant labour market integration policies. It provides theoretical clarity in conflicting literature. The results of this study can also help to predict the possibilities and direction of migrant integration policy development. For example, we should not observe liberal changes in migrant labour market integration policy if the radical right enters the governing coalition. However, in order to better explain the specific cases of national policies, it would be worth undertaking more extensive country case studies based on the set of conditions found in this thesis. In addition, a more in-depth analysis of how the migrant integration policy is constructed politically in the context of labour market policy would be useful. It is also suggested to qualitatively analyse the untouched social side of migrants' integration, showing the actual inclusion of migrants, which is not only defined by laws. Finally, using the QCA approach and MIPEX as demonstrated in this paper, it would be interesting to conduct research involving other countries, time period or integration policy domain.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Bernotas, Ignas,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD192838483&prefLang=en_US