Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Žodžio laisvės reguliavimas platformose: kaip Facebook'as grindžia savo moderavimo sprendimus? /
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe vision of platforms as intermediaries seemed feasible for a while - the first websites consisted of small, homogeneous communities. However, as platforms have grown in size, function and influence on public discourse, this role no longer reflects their position in a global world. Platforms have now become political actors that shape the global infrastructure of free speech. Unlike public political actors, platforms are neither elected nor otherwise legitimised by the state and citizens, which allows them to operate in a non-transparent, inconsistent way. This tension is best reflected in the increasingly frequent controversies surrounding the moderation of free speech. This paper seeks to examine how Facebook justifies its (non-)regulatory decisions in the context of the controversies surrounding freedom of speech 2014-2022. 10 controversies selected on the basis of the principle of maximum diversity were analysed. Based on the theoretical framework, the paragraphs of the collected Facebook statements were classified into different types of justifications. Paragraphs, that did not conform to categories identified in the theoretical framework, were used to form new sub-categories. The data analysis showed that the platform community guidelines and rules emphasised in the platform governance literature are not generally replicated in Facebook's justification of moderation decisions in practice. The justifications identified in the theory were used less frequently, with value-based justifications for community commitment being the most frequently used. Moreover, Facebook not only does not justify its practical moderation decisions on its own stated values, but also avoids justifying them altogether. In the cases examined, Facebook has taken every opportunity to disclose as little of the actual decision-making process as possible, and these opportunities are still available to them due to the prevailing principle of right, but not the obligation, to moderate. More often than justifications, Facebook has used strategic communication tools that create an image of a transparent platform. In total, four communication strategies were identified that helped to avoid justifying decisions: 1) denying the accusations; 2) admitting guilt and/or apologising; 3) emphasising corrective actions; 4) emphasising the company's normative mission. In the cases where moderation decisions were justified, the new justifications identified in this paper and not previously explored in literature, were used most frequently. Five new justifications for moderation decisions related to freedom of expression were discovered: 1) imperfect moderation mechanism; 2) complex situation; 3) reference to the terms of service; 4) Facebook's difficult position; 5) attributing responsibility to other actors. There were also combinations of two justifications, two strategies (without decision justification) or a mixture of the two. These communication elements were typically longer and combined justifications/strategies that reinforced each other, such as the mission statement and the presentation of corrective actions. The study thus showed that there is no clear and coherent, transparent decision-making logic. Platforms such as Facebook remain reluctant to share information about their actual practical decision-making process. Given the data, it can be concluded that the lack of transparency will continue for some time to come, as the tendency to moderate in a vague way persists. The refusal of platforms to be more transparent about their activities prevents further discussion on how to ensure freedom of expression in the governance of platforms and to protect against destructive arbitrariness from happening.The results of the study suggest that while platforms decide the fate of freedom of expression, they are not only not legitimised by the state and citizens, but also do not themselves use the means of legitimation that are appropriate for democracy.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Grabauskaitė, Austėja,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD192839049&prefLang=en_US