Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Europos žmogaus teisų teismas diskusijose ir argumentuose apie partnerystės įstatymą /
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe topic of this thesis is "The European Court of Human Rights in the debates and arguments on the Partnership Law". The aim of the thesis is to analyse, on the basis of critical discourse analysis, the ongoing debate on the legal recognition of same-sex relationships in Lithuania. Objectives: 1. To provide an overview of the theory of "radiating effects of courts" and its analytical framework. 2. Based on a critical discourse analysis, to develop a methodological instrument suitable for uncovering actors' references to the ECtHR. 3. To collect and analyse arguments that refer to the Strasbourg Court in the context of the law. 4. Formulate conclusions on the indirect impact of the ECtHR on the debate about the legalisation of same-sex partnerships and provide insights into the implications for other controversial issues. The analysis reveals that actors involved in the debate on the partnership law refer to the ECtHR for a variety of reasons: to strengthen their arguments, to refute their opponents' claims and to influence public opinion. Marc Galanter's theory provides a good basis for understanding the influence of the ECtHR on debates about controversial issues. The idea that information about the Court's decisions and potential decisions has an undeniable influence on the participation of actors in the debate and on the way actors view the legal recognition of same-sex couples' relationships has been confirmed. All these effects are not due to the direct control imposed by the Court, but due to the information about its decisions. This is a crucial distinction because, as Galanter suggests, the information that influences actors does not have to be accurate: in particular, the Court's case law is very often misrepresented by actors who oppose the partnership law. The impact of the ECtHR is therefore felt most through the dissemination of information: the 'messages' generated by the Court, as Ms Galanter argues, become resources in the hands of the actors, which are used to strengthen their arguments, to deny the opponents' claims and, in general, to frame the whole debate. Moreover, the Court's judgments clearly give a new shape to the debate on this law and influence the discursive frames of its participants. The analysis also confirms that international human rights judgments can also trigger the mobilisation of reactionary actors who seek to restrict minority rights or deny their claims. The idea that various actors draw from the case law of the ECtHR norms relating to respect for private and family life is also confirmed. In the author's view, this work contributes to the literature on the indirect influence of international courts. What helps provide additional insights is that, while most political science researchers seek to uncover this influence through interviews with mobilised actors, this study analyses discourse. In this way, it is possible to grasp the indirect influence of the ECtHR in the words of the actors without them consciously reflecting on the influence of the Court on their engagement in the debate. For future research, it could be recommended to focus more on Galanter's idea of how the messages created by court decisions are misunderstood or deliberately distorted by actors during their transmission. The research carried out does not reveal how or why the distortion of court-generated messages occurs. Interviews with involved actors may provide insight into whether the Court's decisions are deliberately distorted or whether this is due to other circumstances such as ignorance of the law. The fact that this question was not answered can also be seen as a weakness of the work.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Ramanauskas, Rokas,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD192839282&prefLang=en_US