Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
NATO atgrasymo strategija rytiniame aljanso sparne po Velso viršūnių susitikimo /
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis bachelor’s thesis focuses on NATO’s deterrence strategy in the eastern part of the alliance after the decisions to deter Russia were passed on in Wales summit. Following the beginning of the Ukraine-Russia war in 2014, the alliance assured that needed decisions were taken to deter Russia from causing security issues in the eastern NATO’s flank. Wales, Warsaw, and Brussel summits resulted in a strengthened NATO’s joint deterrence strategy, whereas a few of the resolutions even boosted the deterrent position of the eastern NATO flank. Enhanced forward presence battalions are emerging in frontier NATO countries, NATO Force Integration Units and other forces are also established. Researchers have different approaches regarding the benefits of these solutions, in most cases evaluation is performed by measuring effectiveness. On the contrary, rather than evaluating effectiveness, this thesis attempts to grasp the main characteristics of deterrence, which could help to determine the deterrent concept pursued by the alliance in the eastern flank following the decisions taken at the Wales Summit. The aim is to identify, based on the theory, the advantages, and gaps of the ongoing deterrence strategy. To achieve this goal, Russia’s threat to the Eastern flank alongside the evaluation of the issues of defence system are initially assessed. In addition, an analysis of the decisions taken at the Wales, Warsaw, Brussels summits is based on the assumptions of a successful deterrence theory. Moreover, thesis will attempt to answer the question of what kind of deterrence concept NATO implements in in both, conventional and nuclear, deterrence strategies. Lastly, the strengths and weaknesses of the ongoing deterrence strategy are evaluated. The study is based on the assumptions of the third deterrence theory wave: sufficient capacity, reliability to execute threats, and communication. The main question of the theory is “what is the right relationship between nuclear and conventional deterrence?” The theory argues that too much emphasis is placed on nuclear capabilities in the deterrence strategy, and therefore examines the concepts of conventional deterrence, which in practice fall into two parts in deterrence by denial and by punishment. A qualitative case study has shown that, despite the deterrent decisions taken at the Wales and subsequent summits, the alliance still implements the concept of punishment to the conventional deterrence same as in the nuclear deterrence. However, the resolutions adopted during the summits have signs of deterrence by denial but are not fulfilled due to insufficient credibility. The disadvantages of the ongoing strategy include the lack of credibility that the Baltic States would be able to avoid a fait accompli scenario, which is critical to the risk of escalation of the conflict, to which the Alliance is vulnerable due to the lack of solidarity. All decisions taken since the Wales Summit have been based on the principle of non-escalation, which from Russia's point of view can be seen as a weakness, as also proven by the theory of deterrence. Investigation revealed that Russia understands only the language of force. To reduce the likelihood of Russia's possible attack, it is necessary to introduce a deterrence by denial. This kind of implementation of the concept would solve many of the security problems that is worrying the eastern flank. In summary, this work is important because it evaluates the concepts of deterrence at a theoretical level and applies them to the practical examination of NATO's deterrence strategy in eastern flank. The results of the study are valuable in assessing NATO's deterrence concept given the timing of the Madrid Summit. Therefore, the offered need to change NATO's deterrence concept from punishment to cost-based deterrence will be a compelling source for the assessment of the benefits of decisions taken in Madrid from the perspective of NATO's eastern flank deterrence.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2022
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Monstavičius, Džiugas Kazimieras,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD192974763&prefLang=en_US