Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Skirtingo žmogžudysčių lygio priežastys: Salvadoro ir Nikaragvos lyginamoji analizė /
Abstract
dc:descriptionThis bachelor's thesis, Causes of differences in homicide rate: A comparative analysis of El Salvador and Nicaragua, analyzes the reasons why Nicaragua, which like El Salvador, experienced civil war at a similar time (El Salvador: 1980-1992; Nicaragua: 1972-1991), which was alike in number of victims (about 75,000 in El Salvador, about 80,000 in Nicaragua), but did not experience the same high level of intentional homicide, like El Salvador did, despite the lower police to public ratios, during the period of 2003-2018. The theoretical part of the work presents an economic model of crime that allows conceptualization of homicides. According to this model, criminals decide whether or not to commit crimes, and their decision depends on whether the benefits of a potential crime outweigh the costs. Morover, judging from the insights made in the literature about the factors influencing the number of homicides, the theoretical background of independent variables of this work is also presented. The methodological part discusses the qualitative comparative multi-case method used for the analysis, applying the single difference rule. Using an economic model of crime and taking into account other research, two independent variables have been identified that may influence the number of intentional homicides: deportations of convicts from other countries, measured by their number, and more effective community policing strategy. based strategy, or a less efficient one, a “zero tolerance” strategy. Related to these factors, two hypotheses have been put forward in the work: H1: Nicaragua has received a smaller number of deported migrants with criminal convictions from other countries, resulting in lower rates of intentional homicides than El Salvador. H2: Nicaraguan police used a more effective operational strategy, resulting in lower rates of intentional homicides than in El Salvador. In the empirical part of the work, the analysis of deportations of convicted persons from other countries revealed that a significantly higher number of convicted persons were returned to El Salvador than to Nicaragua. Thus, the first hypothesis of this work that Nicaragua has received a smaller number of deported migrants from other countries with convictions, resulting in a lower rate of intentional homicides than in El Salvador, is confirmed. The analysis of police strategy showed that the Salvadoran police were almost exclusively based on a strategy of “zero tolerance”, which was considered ineffective, while the Nicaraguan police were more based on an effective, community-based strategy. Therefore, the second hypothesis of this work, that the Nicaraguan police used a more effective strategy, resulting in lower rates of intentional homicides than in El Salvador, is confirmed. In response to a question raised in the paper, it can be said that both the deportation of convicted persons from other countries and the strategy of the police operation explain why Nicaragua, which has a lower number of police officers, has a low unemployment rate in 2003-2018. homicide rates were several times lower. This work, unlike other papers on the subject, presents the causes of the high levels of homicide in Nicaragua and El Salvador over a well-defined period and identifies clear causal links and mechanisms and operationalizes the identified factors. This work can be a starting point for research of a similar nature. The analysis can be useful not only for regional policy makers in the Central American region, but also for other countries in the world. The case of El Salvador highlighted the important impact of deportations on homicide rates. Policymakers should take this into account and ensure the reintegration of deported convicts into society. Meanwhile, the analysis of policing strategies has made it clear that community-based strategies can be applied in countries that do not have significant financial resources.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2022
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Virbickas, Kęstutis,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD192976729&prefLang=en_US