Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Kokios lyderystės reikia sėkmingam suinteresuotųjų šalių įtraukimui Lietuvoje? XVII Vyriausybės švietimo ir sveikatos struktūrinių reformų atvejis /
Abstract
dc:descriptionThere is a favourable legal framework for stakeholders’ inclusion in decision-making established in Lithuania, while the Civic Empowerment Index has been growing every year since 2008. Theoretically, these conditions should pave a way for a successful citizens’ inclusion in the decision-making processes; however, the reality is different. During the implementation of the structural reforms of the 17th Government, stakeholders expressed their concerns on the integrity of inclusion and questioned the quality and legitimacy of the content of the reforms. The authors of the collaborative governance literature agree that leadership is a crucially important driver for the establishment of collaborations as well as is one of the key factors that determine the maintenance and the quality of those partnerships. Researchers argue that there is no single best type of leadership that would be universally suitable for the entire collaborative process in all contexts, but they do not single out the fact that leadership, targeted at the public sector, is inseparable from the prevailing public administration traditions in the state. This suggests that in a public sector with a dominant hierarchical culture and vertical power relations, traditional leadership could be significant for the successful inclusion of stakeholders. The goal of this research is to evaluate the expression of leadership including stakeholders in decision-making in the case of selected structural reforms and to find out what type of leadership determines more successful inclusion of stakeholders in Lithuania. The research was implemented in two stages. The aim of first stage was to select two out of six reforms, one of which was considered the most successful and the other most unsuccessful of the 17th Government’s reforms in terms of the inclusion of stakeholders. After analysis, education reform was selected as a successful example and healthcare reform as unsuccessful. The second stage of research was qualitative comparative analysis. The aim was to assess how the leadership was expressed in the process of inclusion of stakeholders in case of selected reforms projects and to find out what type of leadership determines the (un)success of inclusion of stakeholders in Lithuania. Semi-structured qualitative interviews were conducted to do this analysis: interviews with representatives of key stakeholders and employees of the ministries directly responsible for the reforms, i. e. civil servants. The results of the empirical research allowed to answer the question on what type of leadership is needed for the successful inclusion of stakeholders in decision-making process in Lithuania. As the case of the Ministry of Health of the Republic of Lithuania reveals, the traditional leadership would be sufficient if directed at ministry’s civil servants, who are responsible for specific projects. The politicians of The Ministry did not plan to involve stakeholders in the hospital network optimization project. However, civil servants also did not take the initiative to advise politicians to involve stakeholders. That broadly confirms the need for political leaders to practice traditional leadership directed at civil servants to encourage them to seek the inclusion of stakeholders. The study showed that the inclusion of stakeholders in the case of The Ministry of Education, Science and Sports of the Republic of Lithuania, is understood as an effective decision-making tool by both politicians and civil servants. In terms of the collaborative process, the work of leaders of the ministry can be evaluated as sufficient for successful inclusion of stakeholders. There was also a lack of political leadership in both cases to ensure the inclusion of stakeholders is successful in a way, that they are able to freely propose their solutions, which later will be considered as equal to the solutions of the ministry.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2021
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Rekštytė, Karolina,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD193226689&prefLang=en_US