Back to search

Institutional Repository of Vilnius University

Tapatybių politikos įtaka politiniam dalyvavimui ir bendrajam gėriui J. Tully filosofijoje /

Abstract

dc:description

As the rate and scope of political participation in our societies is decreasing, philosophers of the 21st century try to find the reasons for these trends. One of the objects of criticism in this context is identity politics. The critics of identity politics argue that it divides people into separate identity groups, reduces the sense of community. The sphere of political participation becomes not the pursue of the common good, but a place of conflict between different identity groups seeking recognition or defending their identity. On the basis of these concerns of the negative impact of identity politics on our political participation, the goal of this work is to see if James Tully’s philosophy is capable of reconciling identity politics, political participation and the common good. The first half of the work is dedicated to overlook James Tully’s model of the politics of recognition. For Tully, social identities are multifaceted and flexible, people have different identities and attach different importance to their variety of identities. Even though those social identities are important to people, the most important identity is political identity – belonging to a certain political community. According to Tully, one becomes a citizen and part of a political community when one participates in politics, is able to contribute to the development of rules and ways in which politics and participation is conducted in. In the politics of recognition, political participation involving different identity groups is necessary to assess the identity claims and create communality. In diverse societies, common morality cannot be the common good, therefore, the political participation itself becomes what connects people. In the next half of the work the normative prerequisites of the functioning of this model is discussed with an aim to understand the limitations of identity politics and to create a solid normative basis that it could rest upon. By not focusing on the normative, Tully is not capable of solving the problem of intra-group hatred that could occur because of identity politics. Relying on the philosophy of William E. Connolly and others, I suggest that in order to reconcile identity politics, political participation and the common good, the relations between citizens must comply with the following moral imperatives: agonistic respect and critical responsiveness. In order to achieve those ends, the political elite must ensure the economic conditions for equal political participation, and civic education should be based on communication between citizens and the practice of solving problems in a community. The analysis showed that even though intra-group dialogue and active political participation is necessary for the politics of recognition to exist, it is equally important to describe what morally binds the participants in this dialogue. Ignoring the normative level of identity politics, does not let us see the limitations of identity politics and solve the problems rising from that. Therefore, for identity politics, political participation and common good to co-exist, we need to take a dialogical approach, but to also describe what values will guide this dialogue. I presented a direction that can be taken to make this dialogue fairer and more efficient, but there needs to be a deeper analysis on what this moral ground for identity politics could be and how it can be achieved. Without it, the limitations of identity politics cannot be properly addressed and solved.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Year dc:date
2021

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Balzarevičiūtė, Gabija,

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
Language dc:language
lit

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Vilnius University
Base URL
epublications.vu.lt/oai
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Balzarevičiūtė, Gabija,. Tapatybių politikos įtaka politiniam dalyvavimui ir bendrajam gėriui J. Tully filosofijoje /. Institutional Repository of Vilnius University, 2021. https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD193227651&prefLang=en_US