Back to search

Institutional Repository of Vilnius University

Nepriklausomybę paskelbusių politinių darinių tarptautinio pripažinimo (ne)sėkmės sąlygos: keturių atvejų analizė /

Abstract

dc:description

International recognition and the emergement of new states was, is and probably always will be an constantly ungoing process. Statistics shows, that over one year period two countries steps into international community (in other words, becomes independent and sovereign and earns international recognition). Unfortunately, the ratio, which shows how many countries, or to be exact – political entities, because at first they do not have ‘a country‘ title, reaches the international recognition, is not very positive. More or less it stays about 50 percent. That means, that in about a year the other two countries are left outside the international community. At first look, this recognition process looks pretty simple – if you meet the criteria for the statehood, if you do not have any dangerous ambitions for international system, you are good to go. But actually this process is much more complex and the main author of this bachelor thesis – Bridget Coggins – says, that not enough research is being done at the moment of this topic. The main object of this work is four countries-political entities, that have been (in)successfull in the process of international recognition. Two of them – Kosovo and South Ossetia – tried to become independent through the form of war, and the other two – Catalonia and Montenegro – chose more diplomatic way. Dividing them into two different categories helps more to define the circumstances, that are necessary for political entity to join the international community – and that is actually the main goal of this work, to show which factors, circumstances or indicators are the essential ones in the international recognition. The main problem sounds pretty simple (What determines that in one case we got ‘a country’ and in the other one – ‘political entity’?), but it is nothing like that. The main tasks correlates with B.Coggins proposed ways, that are the most effective analysing state formation and their path to international community. At first, in the theoretical part, it is important to see through international relations windows and how the term ‘sovereign’ evolved in the international relations. Moreover, the second part of theory leans on international law and what it says about statehood, about ways for country-political entity to form itself and two theories – declaratory and constitutive – towards countries recognition. Second part of this work concentrates on four main objects. With the help of comparative analysis (which is also suggested by B.Coggins) and a little bit of research of their history, it allows to define more concrete factors, that determine the (in)success of self-declared independent political entities. Moreover, it helps to understand the decisions of members of international community – this sentence actually shows, that the key statement of B.Coggins (that external recognition, external legitimacy is all that matters) is completely true. Comparative analysis of four countries was made based on three the most influential categories of international-level interests, that was proposed by B.Coggins: 1) external security or geostrategic; 2) domestic politics; 3) system stability. Those three really important factors plus the new one, that was find in the work – the relationship betweeen the nation-mother and seccesionist – is the esential ones and most of the time ‘Great Powers’ (and not only them) takes them into account when deciding, if a new member to the international community will really fit and be will be useful. Everyone needs to remin, that first of all, everyone is fighting for themselves and just after that they will look for the other ones.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Year dc:date
2021

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Žukas, Vilius,

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
Language dc:language
lit

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Vilnius University
Base URL
epublications.vu.lt/oai
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Žukas, Vilius,. Nepriklausomybę paskelbusių politinių darinių tarptautinio pripažinimo (ne)sėkmės sąlygos: keturių atvejų analizė /. Institutional Repository of Vilnius University, 2021. https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD193227979&prefLang=en_US