Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Karlo fon Klauzevico karo teorijos aktualumas šių dienų konfliktams: Ukrainos atvejis /
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe bachelor thesis is titled "The Relevance of Carl von Clausewitz's Theory of War to Today's Conflicts: the Case of Ukraine." The thesis examines the ideas of the Prussian war theorist, who lived from 1780 to 1831. The main purpose of this study is to examine the theory of war of C. von Clausewitz and to analyse the relevance of the author's ideas on the basis of the case of the Ukrainian conflict. The study relies on a premise that with the proliferation of conflicts, the ideas of the war theorist, although still widely studied today, are considered a relic of the past. This study therefore seeks to demonstrate that the theorist's ideas are still relevant today. The first goal of this study is to construct a theoretical framework. The sections identified are the nature and character of war, war as an instrument of politics, trinity, friction, bloodshed, morality and defence and offence. The theoretical framework includes the concept of new wars, which is used to develop the Ukraine case study and to clarify the perspective of contemporary wars. The second goal is to shape a section for the methodology used. The work applies an approach of history of ideas, which forms the historical context necessary to explain the emergence of the main ideas identified. The historical context is divided into three parts: practical life, the circumstances of the writing of On War and the impact of people close to the author on the development of his thinking. Then, the significance of the case study method and its application to the case of the Ukrainian conflict is developed. The main material for the study is the literature analysed - the book "On War", letters and other writings needed to support the argument and empirical data from the Ukrainian conflict case. The third goal is the presentation of the results obtained. On the basis of these, the relevance of C. von Clausewitz's theory of war to the present day is explained. The relevance of this thesis lies in the fact that after the year 2000, C. von Clausewitz is still widely talked about, but fewer and fewer people are asking whether his theoretical ideas are relevant for today's conflicts. To establish the authenticity of the thesis and the relevance of the war theorist's ideas, the theory of the new wars, whose proponents are opposed to C. von Clausewitz, is used, and a new empirical example for the 21st century is chosen: the case of the Ukrainian conflict. The ideological cross-sections have been distinguished in the following order: to understand the concept of war, the nature and character of war must be taken into account. Next, as war is linked to politics, the aspect of war as a tool of politics was highlighted. The next idea is the trinity of war, which consists of primordial violence, hatred and hostility. Also, a war cannot be completely planned from start to finish, so it is important to include the aspect of chance, which C. von Clausewitz refers to as the 'friction' of war. Another idea is that a war is unthinkable without casualties, so the idea of bloodshed was included. Furthermore, war tasks are carried out by individuals who face not only physical challenges but also moral ones, so morality is an important idea in this work. The last idea highlighted is that of defence and offence, although battle strategies are not covered, the theory needs to be revisited in order to cover as many different aspects of war as possible. To sum up, the main conclusion of the thesis is that C. von Clausewitz's theory of war is still relevant today, which was demonstrated through the ideas highlighted, which were not rejected during the research, using both the theory of the new wars and the empirical case of the Ukrainian conflict. This research can be continued by highlighting other ideological strands of C. von Clausewitz's theory of war. Also, the different ideas highlighted can be combined with other conflicts such as the Syrian case.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2021
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Cibulskaitė, Justina,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD193228069&prefLang=en_US