Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Europos Sąjungos ir Jungtinės Karalystės prekybos ir bendradarbiavimo susitarimo bei jo pasekmių rėminimas Jungtinės Karalystės žiniasklaidoje: „BBC News“ kokybinė turinio analizė /
Abstract
dc:descriptionGiven the unquestionable impact of the media by researchers and the UK political elite to the 2016 UK “Brexit” referendum, as well as considering literature that explores the idea of “Brexit” as an empty signifier, this thesis aims to find out how the EU-UK Trade and Cooperation Agreement (tangible content that filled the idea of “Brexit”) was presented by the British public broadcaster. The aim of the research was achieved by 1) reviewing the frame theory literature and its application in media studies; 2) employing the frame analysis in crafting the methodology for the research, based both on deductive and inductive approaches; 3) conducting direct and conventional content analyses of “BBC News” articles, published during the research period; 4) presenting the salience of the identified frames. Due to a limited scope of the bachelor’s thesis, one media outlet had to be chosen. The first research in the field should act as a baseline for further inquiries in the field. Therefore, the content published on “BBC News” was chosen based on polls that indicate that most British citizens consider the “BBC” the highest quality, the most reliable and the most accurate news source in the country. The theory behind frame analysis as well as its application in media studies is provided in this thesis. Furthermore, the unique context of “Brexit” as well as the lack of studies in the field lead to a qualitative approach to the crafting of research methodology. A direct (deductive) as well as conventional (inductive) qualitative analyses of published articles are carried out. The codes for the direct content analysis – “attribution of responsibility”, “human interest”, “conflict”, “morality”, “economic consequences” frames – were deducted from relevant literature. Conventional content analysis also identified 7 other frames, confirming the unique context of “Brexit”. The research period was chosen as follows: 2020 December 24th 14:45 UTC – 2021 January 9th 23:59 UTC, and the research object – all articles published during this period. 127 articles were analyzed, out of which deducted frames were identified 176 times in 108 articles. Furthermore, 7 new frames were identified inductively – “historical experience”, “unity of the Union”, “future opportunities”, “sovereignty”, “unfinished process”, “expression of official opinion” and “preparation” frames. These frames appeared 77 times and were present in 63 articles, confirming the unique context of “Brexit”. The analysis has shown that “BBC News” presented the EU-UK agreement and the consequences of its entry into force by mostly pragmatically discussing its material consequences for various societal groups. In parallel to a pragmatic approach, supporters of the agreement established a message in the “future opportunities” frame, exclaiming that “freedom” is now in UK’s hands and the Brits ought to “rise to the challenge of freedom”. Therefore, the supporters of the Agreement managed to successfully erase the content that filled the “Brexit” signifier again. While the opposition contested the government on material shortcomings of the Agreement, it did not contest the ideational arguments of its supporters. Therefore, various discursive framing of the Agreement supporters (such as the pro-Leave view on sovereignty) established itself during the research period. An analysis on why the opposition chose the strategy of non-confrontation on ideational questions of EU integration would be useful in this regard. For further research, the methodology could be employed in research seeking to compare different or across varying time periods and would also be appropriate as a basis for a qualitative approach to frames and how various frames relate to each other and how the connection differs over time. Furthermore, the results can act as a baseline guides on which questions could be asked in further inquiries in the field of media coverage of “Brexit”.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2021
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Kriaučiūnas, Vilius,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD193229376&prefLang=en_US