Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Nedemokratinių valstybių švelnioji galia: Kinijos Liaudies Respublikos atvejis Vengrijoje /
Abstract
dc:descriptionBoth Western news agencies and political scientists find China's soft power as weak. The biggest problems are that: by measuring soft power of any state, scholars tend to always use indirect power measurement methods, such as quantitative surveys or various soft power indexes, that lack objectivity as they depend on foreign publics opinion too much, which can only show the attractiveness of the country but not the ability to affect foreign governments to obtain the outcomes one wants through attraction, which is the main definition of J. Nye’s soft power concept. Also, by measuring soft power of non-democratic countries, scientists tend to skip that part of their unique soft power resources that rely on values different than we have in the Western world. Some of those contradict with Western values, e.g., liberty or democracy, so hard, that such analyses cannot even reflect the real picture of authoritarian or autocratic countries and always evaluates them as unattractive with having weak soft power. Bearing this in mind, it was worth to analyze China’s soft power based on more reliable methods that avoid the principle of subjectivity and by having in mind its unique characteristics. Direct measurement of soft power was chosen for this aim, which consisted of qualitative and quantitative methods that allowed to solve the issue. As bilateral relations are as important as multilateral, therefore the object of this work was defined: China's soft power in Hungary during 2012-2019 m. period. This study tried to address the problem by answering the question: what is China’s soft power in Hungary?; with the hypothesis thus raised: China's soft power in Hungary is strong, greatly affecting bilateral relations between these countries. The purpose of this work was: to evaluate alternative soft power measurement instruments, that avoid the problems of subjectivity and excessive orientation towards Western world value system of J. Nye’s soft power concept, and to show the principles of their operation in the evaluation of Chinese soft power in Hungary. In order to achieve the aim, the following smaller tasks were formulated and completed: 1) Conceptualization of J. Nye’s soft power concept to confirm the theoretical assumptions about the suitability and accuracy of soft power’s estimation methods. 2) Conceptualization of “Soft power with Chinese characteristics” to assess the main features of the latter and their significance for achieving the purpose of this work. 3) Comparison of “Soft power with Chinese characteristics” with J. Nye’s concept of soft power to identify the main differences that lead to different power measurements. 4) Analysis of historical relations between Hungary and China to assess the orientations of both countries and to raise additional hypotheses regarding the content of soft power. 5) Performance of a quantitative study of China’s soft power in Hungary to evaluate China’s soft power measures there and the latter’s response. 6) Performance of a qualitative study of Victor Orban’s remarks on China to consolidate the conclusions of the quantitative study and to identify the characteristics of China that are attractive to Hungary. In conclusion, after completing all of the steps above, despite the fact that China’s soft power in Hungary was not proved to be strong with the hypothesis being neither proved or rejected, the main aim of the work was achieved. It was concluded direct measurement of soft power to be effective tool for analyzing soft power by avoiding the principle of subjectivity and making unique countries’ characteristics irrelevant. Bearing this and the fact that direct soft power measurement studies have not been studied before at all or that much, this study is significant as it fills the vacuum in this area of soft power studies. However, this methodology is not perfect, so it is recommended to improve it during future researches.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2021
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Mikelevičius, Domantas,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD193230273&prefLang=en_US