Back to search

Institutional Repository of Vilnius University

J. M. Bochenskio autoriteto sąvokos analizė ir šiuolaikinės argumentavimo koncepcijos /

Abstract

dc:description

SUMMARY J. M. Bocheński's Analysis of the Concept of Authority and Contemporary Argumentation Theories Argument from authority has had, and in part continues to have, a rather poor reputation. Most logicians, philosophers, and scientists have traditionally treated it as one of the fallacies. At the same time, relying on authority, experts, the research of other authors, and the testimonies of other people is inevitable in both scientific practice and everyday life. This is especially evident now, in the heyday of knowledge and the information society. In the attempt to disentangle the conflicting situation, we face multiple questions. What is authority, what does the concept exactly mean? Is reliance on authority, arguing from authority or expert opinion appropriate? If so, what is the structure, value, validity of such reasoning? Under what conditions is the use of this type of reasoning acceptable? Polish-Swiss philosopher, logician, sovietologist, and Dominican monk Bocheński was one of the first to thoroughly investigate the problem of authority and our reliance on it. His study Was ist die Autorität? Einführung in die Logik der Autorität was published half a century ago. As the problem of authority and arguing from authority is becoming more relevant in contemporary research, it is only natural that it receives increasingly more attention in the works of today’s argumentation theorists. The paper presents a reconstruction of Bocheński's analysis of the concept of authority, an overview of the reception of the author's works on authority research in Poland, discusses possible applications of Bocheński's analysis in the context of the contemporary argumentation theories. In addition to Bocheński, five representatives of contemporary argumentation theorists are also discussed – Coleman, Cummings, van Eemeren, Wagemans, and Walton (together with the co-author of some of his papers Koszowy). The paper attempts to show, firstly, how Bocheński's research and contemporary argumentation theorists partially rehabilitate argument from authority. Secondly, we argue that many problems addressed by contemporary argumentation theorists such as the interpretation of authority as a relation, the problems of inevitability and justification of argumentation from authority, the distinction between epistemic and deontic authority as well as the analysis of the abuse of authority can be partly traced in the works of Bocheński. Keywords: Bocheński, argumentation theories, authority, argumentum ad verecundiam.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Year dc:date
2021

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Leškevičius, Vytautas,

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
Language dc:language
lit

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Vilnius University
Base URL
epublications.vu.lt/oai
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Leškevičius, Vytautas,. J. M. Bochenskio autoriteto sąvokos analizė ir šiuolaikinės argumentavimo koncepcijos /. Institutional Repository of Vilnius University, 2021. https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD193233289&prefLang=en_US