Back to search

Institutional Repository of Vilnius University

BRICS šalių nacionalinių preferencijų (ne)suderinamumas ekonominio bendradarbiavimo ir saugumo klausimais /

Abstract

dc:description

In global politics, the BRICS are often seen as a bloc hostile to the United States and the West, and in the current geopolitically tense context this view has been reinforced. Additionally, this bloc is often seen as an attempt to create counterweight to the US and the West in general, while throwing challenge at the rule-based world order which has been sustained for a long time. In the academic community, research emphasise the bloc‘s continued economic growth and potential to surpass the G7, while some questions their foreign policy integrity while staying positive on future forecast on economic development. However, the problematic working question is whether the BRICS countries actually share sufficiently similar interest to be able to create such counterweight. To answer previously mentioned problematic question, this research paper focuses solely on BRICS bloc economic integrity while also assessing its ability to unify identification of foreign national threats in terms of reciprocity between members of the bloc, attitudes towards the U.S. and attitudes towards the European Union. To conduct proper research we use analytical framework combined with two main theories of international relation – liberalism (in particular commercial liberalism) and realism (in particular – structural realism). Liberalised trade and investment between the bloc‘s countries through common economic agreements (Free Trade Agreement, Bilateral trade agreements, Non-tariff agreements, etc.) at bloc level, and a clearly unified foreign policy could suggest that the BRICS indeed have the potential to gain more power or overgrow U.S. and the rest of the West powers. Conducted analysis of the intensity of the use of economic instruments by BRICS members as well as results of the uniformity of the identification of nation threats show that the bloc has difficulties in discovering common national preferences. Different intensity of intra-BRICS trade and low levels of investments between bloc countries indicates an asymmetry in the importance of these intra-bloc economic relations. It becomes apparent that while certain members, such as Brazil, South Africa, or Russia, may attach significant importance to intra-BRICS economic relations, the same may not hold true for others, such as China or India. Additionally, lack of common economic agreements and other economic initiatives between bloc indicates low levels of liberalisation of markets between countries. Also, it is important to indicate, that for China, South Africa, and India economic relations with EU and/or U.S. are equally or more important than economic relations within BRICS bloc, thus usage of economic instruments within bloc remains questionable. Next part of research paper focused on the uniformity of the BRICS members‘ national threat identification based on the U.S., the EU and each others of bloc‘s members attitudes. Given results indicates quite different foreign policy stances between member countries – Russia and China being more hostile towards U.S. and the EU while India, Brazil and South Africa see West countries as strategic partners or being more neutral than hostile. Additionally, intra-BRICS relations regarding foreign policy threats gives negative results due to India-China clash as well as India‘s closer military cooperation with U.S. and EU in order to mitigate regional risk due to China‘s rising military power. Due to current situation regarding different stances of bloc‘s members towards western-powers it may look like a more complicated situation will occur due to ongoing Russia war with Ukraine, which already puts more pressure on rest bloc members strategic partnership with these regions. In conclusion, the BRICS bloc has not achieved the projected economic growth from the beginning and the divergent foreign policy orientations on security issues call into question the bloc‘s chanced of accumulating more power than the U.S. - EU tandem.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Year dc:date
2024

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Bartnykas, Martynas,

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
Language dc:language
lit

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Vilnius University
Base URL
epublications.vu.lt/oai
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Bartnykas, Martynas,. BRICS šalių nacionalinių preferencijų (ne)suderinamumas ekonominio bendradarbiavimo ir saugumo klausimais /. Institutional Repository of Vilnius University, 2024. https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD210579614&prefLang=en_US