Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Aukštas įkalinimo lygis – likimas ar pasirinkimas? Lietuvos sprendimų priėmėjų politinės valios mažinti įkalinimo lygį analizė /
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe incarceration of convicted individuals is a complex and debated process, linking the complex issues of the justice system, human rights and public safety. However, recently there has been a consensus that balancing the sentencing system is one of the key conditions for ensuring fairness and the effectiveness of the objectives of imprisonment. A review of Lithuania's incarceration rate in the context of the European Union and Lithuania's commitment to the standards set by the European Union and other international institutions raises a problematic issue: although Lithuania's political orientation is considered to be Western, which implies a particular focus on justice and human rights, Lithuania remains one of the leading EU countries in terms of incarceration rate in 2023. Moreover, since 2000, Lithuania has been the subject of international criticism regarding its penal system and prison conditions, but so far no significant progress has been made. This raises the question - why? More precisely, what are the factors behind the high rate of incarceration? Although academics disagree on this issue, there is a general consensus that the influence of decision-makers on the penal system is of major importance. Therefore, this thesis aims to better understand the contribution of decision-makers in regulating the penal system. In other words, the aim of this study is to assess the factors contributing to the political will of decision-makers to reduce the incarceration rate in Lithuania. The study is carried out by assessing three independent variables: internally-derived incentives of Lithuanian decision-makers, external pressure from international institutions/organisations and economic logic. Process tracing method was used during the research to systematically evaluate amendments to the Criminal Code of the Republic of Lithuania and the Penal Enforcement Code, the rhetoric of decision-makers and statistical data. Analysis showed that economic logic has no significant impact on decision-makers political will, while external pressure from international institutions/organisations led to significant law amendments, yet the implementation mechanism chosen has made translating the changes into practice extremely complex, suggesting limited political will for real change. Internally-derived incentives of Lithuanian decision-makers contributed to increased political will to lower incarceration rates the most. Although during the period from 2013 to 2020 efforts to balance the penal system were erratic and often opposing the said purpose, the changes of the Penal Enforcement Code in 2022 essentially switched the direction of efforts to lower incarceration rate. The new Penal Enforcement Code focuses on prisoners’ resocialisation and reintegration into the society, which is expected to lower recidivism, as well as incarceration. The radical change in policy and the vast human and financial resources directed at it suggest high political will to reform Lithuanian penal system and to reduce the number of people serving prison sentences. In conclusion, the research showed that high incarceration rate in Lithuania is not fate conditioned by external factors, but rather the choice of the decision-makers. Based on the existing input, this paper combines and develops a model of political will, which is expected to contribute to a more concrete and broader understanding of the concept of political will and to the practical application of this term in public policy research.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Dubovskytė, Rugilė,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD210580377&prefLang=en_US