Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Europos Komisijos pirmininko politinės lyderystės įtaka politikos formavimo procesui Europos Sąjungoje: Europos ekonomikos gaivinimo plano „NextGenerationEU“ ir Europos strateginių technologijų platformos įgyvendinimas /
Abstract
dc:descriptionWhen we talk about the European Commission, we often emphasize its formal and exclusive right of initiative, but it is also a well-established practice that it does not set the agenda for big strategic initiatives. However, such a provision can be argued against by various Commission presidents engaged in political activism, such as J. Delors, under whose supervision the European monetary union was implemented. Recently, more and more publications about Ursula von der Leyen and her political leadership in the European Union have started to appear in the media. She is undoubtedly currently the most prominent politician in the EU. This study seeks to answer the question of how the political leadership of the Commission President affects the policy-making processes in the EU by selecting two strategically important initiatives: the recovery fund "NextGenerationEU" (NGEU) and the Strategic technologies for Europe platform (STEP). The NGEU marks an increase in the Commission's fiscal powers and a certain new era in European Union, when member states finance the recovery fund through a common debt mechanism. Meanwhile, STEP, previously known as the Sovereignty Fund, with which the Commission tried to implement a similar funding model as the NGEU did, was left with only a mechanism to mobilize already existing EU funds for strategic projects. Both initiatives are chosen to be contrasted with each other to understand the factors that led to success in the case of NGEU and failure in the case of STEP. The main assumption of political leadership based on the interactionist approach is that political leadership is affected by the interaction of several factors. Considering the theoretical assumptions of political leadership, the following main factors influencing the effectiveness of leadership and chosen strategies were identified: personal preferences of the leader, heterogeneity of preferences of decision makers, situational settings, and institutional conditions. The research assumes that a successfully applied leadership strategy leads to policy innovation. Using the process tracking method in interaction with the theory of leadership in international organizations, it was found that the NGEU case led to a collective action optimization strategy, and the STEP case led to an intellectual leadership strategy. The first one was based on the search for a solution through mediation in the short term, the second form of leadership sought to form provision about the problem to be solved, placing leadership’s actions in a longer timeline. By applying empirical process tracing test in both cases, the hypotheses indicating the direct relationship of each of these strategies to the result (political decision) were tested. After the analysis, it was concluded that in both cases President of European Commission directly affected decision-making process. In the case of NGEU fund, while using Commission's considerably asymmetric expertise advantage over other EU institutions, it was possible to find a solution that led to a change in the attitude of some member states that previously doubted common debt mechanism, Meanwhile, in the case of STEP, it can be seen that practiced intellectual leadership was incapable of overcoming weak member states’ preferences on the issue of the Sovereignty fund, but sufficient to adopt an alternative measure. Considering these results, it was concluded, that the leadership applied by the President of European Commission is more effective, with greater impact on decision-making while occupying the role of a mediator and finding a decision on a necessary measure, rather than taking the initiative for a new measure to form a certain provision about it in the long term. This confirms the statement that European Commission does not set the agenda for major strategic initiatives in EU, but attention is drawn to the fact that, under certain conditions, it can significantly influence the outcome of such policies.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Kulinič, Ilijas,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD210581463&prefLang=en_US