Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Kodėl (ne)susidaro spaudimas politikos impulsui? Translyčių asmenų politikos kaitos Lietuvoje atvejis /
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe rights of transgender people are not protected in practice to the same extent as heterosexual and cisgender rights. Many countries, including Lithuania, which have signed international treaties binding them to protect human rights, are implementing and adopting legislation that singles out and discriminates against persons on the basis of their gender identity. There has been an increasing number of discussions on LGBT+ issues in Lithuania, but the ongoing discussions are only related to the rights of homosexual persons. While this is certainly very significant, it is important to note that the situation of transgender people belonging to the LGBT+ community is left largely unaddressed in Lithuanian society. This is also reflected in the statistics: the protection of transgender rights in Lithuania is one of the least protected in the European Union (EU). Lithuania scores only 4 out of 30 on the Transgender Rights Index. Although the protection of transgender people is a crucial issue in terms of international and EU law, there is a lack of transgender policy change in Lithuania. In order to understand why transgender policy change is (not) taking place in Lithuania, it is important to outline the existing concepts in the academic literature and identify the main factors that may influence transgender policy change. The bachelor thesis is based on the policy momentum framework developed by Nicole McMahon in 2022. This framework reveals how multilevel and multidirectional global and domestic policy diffusion processes together can produce national policy change. This thesis aimed to find out why there is no pressure for transgender policy change in Lithuania. This theoretical framework was used to confirm or reject the hypotheses by analyzing the internal factors of the policy momentum: a) the media, public opinion and the influence of interest groups which can internally influence the policy momentum, and b) the mechanisms of diffusion such as learning, imitation, competition and coercion that can externally influence policy momentum by creating pressure for policy change. The qualitative case study method and semi-structured in-depth interviews were used to achieve the objectives. The hypothesis that the diffusion mechanisms of learning, imitation, competition and coercion externally influence the policy momentum of transgender people in Lithuania and foster policy change is rejected. The existing influence of some diffusion mechanisms, such as coercion, does not create significant pressure on the policy momentum. Therefore, diffusion mechanisms do not contribute to policy change for transgender people in Lithuania. The second hypothesis of the bachelor’s thesis that media, public opinion and the influence of interest groups internally influence the policy momentum and foster policy change is rejected as well. The variables do not create relevant pressure on the policy momentum nor does it stimulate the policy change. Research on transgender policy change is almost non-existent in Lithuanian academia. Therefore, this paper can serve as a starting point for expanding academic research on transgender policy change. Important to mention, that the original theoretical framework is not only based on internal factors but also on the role of international organisations, peer countries and the judiciary. Further research on policy change for transgender people in Lithuania, improving the theoretical framework of the policy momentum analysis applied in this paper. This would require to analyse the influence of international organisations, the judiciary and peer countries. Applying the entire framework would be of significant benefit not only to Lithuania, but also to the academic community more broadly, as it would contribute to the research on transgender policy change, which is severely lacking. Lastly, the entire theoretical framework would provide deeper insights into the state of transgender policy change in Lithuania.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Stonkutė, Roberta,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD210584657&prefLang=en_US