Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Advokacijoje naudojamų rėmų analizė: kailinių žvėrelių fermų draudimo Lietuvoje atvejis /
Abstract
dc:descriptionIn Lithuania, advocacy to ban fur farms started in 2014 by NGO “Tušti Narvai”. Politicians joined advocacy campaign in 2016. The most active ones were L. Balsys, L. Kasčiūnas, I. Pakarklytė, A. Gedvilienė, L. Jonauskas, M. Ošmianskienė, D. Morgana, T. Tomilinas, R. Vaitkus and a few more. Named politicians and NGO “Tušti Narvai” are referred to as the main (advocacy) actors in this thesis. The puzzle of the thesis is that the advocacy for the fur farm ban in Lithuania lasted nearly 10 years. Main advocacy actors not only had to convince politicians to vote for the ban, but they also had to mobilize society’s support. This was done by framing the issue. According to the scientific literature, frame unity influences advocacy's success. The research question arises – how (and whether unanimously) do advocacy actors frame the issue of banning fur farms in Lithuania? The aim of the thesis is to analyse how (and whether unanimously) advocacy actors frame the issue of banning fur farms in Lithuania. Four objectives are established to reach the aim of the thesis. First, to conduct a literature review and present the reasons for banning fur farms in European countries. Second, to form the theoretical model based on advocacy and framing theory; define motivational, economic, personal, and moral frames; and present the influence of frame unity on successful advocacy. Third, to present qualitative content analysis and multimodal discourse analysis methods, data collection method, and analysis data. Lastly, to present the results obtained during the analysis, answer the research question, supplement the theoretical model with new frames, and discuss what influence the unity of the frames had on the success of advocacy. The bachelor thesis analyses how advocacy actors frame the ban on fur farms in Lithuania. It investigates how the question was framed by different actors - the NGO “Tušti Narvai” and politicians. Data is collected and analysed from 2014 (when “Tušti Narvai” started its activities and this issue appeared in the discourse) until September 2023 (when the ban was adopted). Advocacy is analysed using framing theory. Four frames are sought: motivational, economic, personal, and moral. This approach is based on research by Anspach and Draguljić and other researchers. Using an inductive approach, additional frames are distinguished that could not be assigned to the previously named frames. This aims to add to the existing scientific literature. The work also examines the assumption that successful advocacy is determined by unified framing. Conclusion: Using a deductive approach, it was found that the moral frame is the most common one. The least used was the economic frame. Using an inductive method, three additional frames were established: environmental/health protection, legal, and security. The chosen framing theory helped to understand how the ban on fur farms is portrayed in advocacy. The performed analysis showed that there is no complete unity of the used frames among the main actors. It has been observed that there is unanimity in framing the nature of the problem. Both groups identified this as a moral issue. The target audience noticed this - even the politicians who are against the ban said it was a moral issue. However, after analysing the collected data, it is not possible to confirm the theoretical statement that a unified framing process leads to successful advocacy since the main actors framed the issue inconsistently. Since the unity of frames cannot explain the success of the analysed case, it is argued that other things are more important. The conducted research leads to the conclusion that applying different frames to different groups, when the most relevant aspects for a particular group are emphasized, creates the conditions for successful advocacy.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Aleksejūnaitė, Akvilė,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD210584695&prefLang=en_US