Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
I. Williamo Zartmano pribrendusio momento koncepcijos tinkamumas Pereinamojo laikotarpio teisingumo studijoms. Bosnijos ir Hercegovinos atvejo analizė /
Abstract
dc:descriptionTransitional Justice (TJ) is an interdisciplinary field of study that aims to address the challenges faced by societies transitioning from periods of conflict, repression, and crimes against humanity to stability and peace. One of the newest areas in TJ research is the study of the temporal dimension: the academic literature has started to ask not only what mechanisms should be applied, but also when they should be applied. This thesis aimed to contribute to that debate. Although the importance of timing in TJ processes has already been proven, this branch of research is still nascent, the findings lack certain tools that would help to identify situations in which TJ mechanisms would be more effective. Thus, an attempt has been made to enrich the field of TJ with the concept of the ripe moment, developed by I. William Zartman. This thesis aimed to test whether Zartman's concept of the ripe moment can be applied to TJ, in an attempt to better understand why TJ mechanisms are stagnant in Bosnia and Herzegovina (BaH). To achieve this, the thesis aimed to fulfill the following objectives: a) to explain I. W. Zartman's theory of ripeness and to define its key concept - the ripe moment; b) to identify the indicators of the ripe moment described in the theory and to adapt them to the context of TJ; c) to apply the adapted indicators in the analysis of the TJ processes in BaH; d) to assess to what extent the concept of the ripe moment contributes to the better understanding of the success or failure of the TJ mechanisms of BaH. The adaptation and application of the ripe moment in a qualitative case study of the BaH TJ process have shown that the concept of the ripe moment can be applied to TJ. The search for the ripe moment indicators (Mutually Hurting Stalemate (MHS) and a Way Out) in Bosnia between 2008 and 2012 also helped to explain, at least in part, the failure to establish the promising RECOM commission. It was found that the situation defining the MHS existed in BaH between 2008 and 2012, as the damage to the welfare of the state caused by the lack of reconciliation between ethnic groups was significant at that time. However, when investigating whether this situation was realized by the public, it was found that the high level of dissatisfaction with the living conditions at the time was attributed to the lack of economic reforms rather than to the damage caused by ethnic tensions. The lack of awareness of the MHS at the time was fostered by BaH politicians and religious leaders and the lack of media freedom. It was also found that a TJ mechanism representing the Way Out also existed during the period analyzed because the RECOM initiative was of high quality and addressed one of the country's biggest problems - the lack of a unified historical truth. However, the prevailing public discourse of ethnic fear in the country has also affected the criticism of RECOM, creating narratives of mistrust of the mechanism. According to I. W. Zartman's theory, without public perception, the indicators for a ripe moment could not exist. It was therefore concluded that a ripe moment did not exist in 2008-2012 BaH, when RECOM was being developed. The analysis has shown that the search for the ripe moment in the TJ process provides useful insights. While it is not accurate to say that the non-existence of a ripe moment at the time was the main reason for the failure of RECOM, this study has found that the emergence of a ripe moment was deliberately obstructed, with legitimate leaders and the media creating a counter-image that fostered mutual hostility, rather than a search for reconciliation. It was therefore concluded that if it is possible to eradicate, it is equally possible to create, or at least foster, conditions that would increase the efficiency of the TJ mechanism. The ripe moment, while not in itself a guarantee of success, can help to define the indicators of a situation in which society will be more receptive to TJ measures.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Turauskaitė, Barbora,
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD210584837&prefLang=en_US