Back to search

Institutional Repository of Vilnius University

ES ekonominių sankcijų Rusijai paskirtis: efektyvumas prieš išraišką /

Abstract

dc:description

The Purpose of EU Economic Sanctions against Russia: Effectiveness vs. Expression The paper explores a paradox occurring from the inability of dominant sanctions theories to explain why the EU imposed harsh economic sanctions on Russia in the wake of the Ukraine Crisis in the summer of 2014. The main purpose of the study is to explain how the EU Member States managed to reach a common position regarding economic sanctions against Russia. In the first section of the paper the theoretical starting point is chosen to be the flawed yet dominant academic narrative on the effectiveness of international sanctions. Building on the dominant narrative an alternative theoretical explanation based on the concept of purpose of international sanctions is developed. Two models of theoretical premises are developed for two main purposes of international sanctions. The instrumental purpose, deeply rooted in the studies of sanctions’ effectiveness, is based on the logic of economic rationalism which perceives sanctions as tools used by states to coerce other states (sanction targets) into changing their behaviour according to sender’s wishes. Sanctions are also imposed with regard to safeguarding the economic interests of the sender as the chosen target tends to be the more vulnerable actor in the mutually dependent economic and/or trade relationship between the sender and the target. The instrumental purpose is premised on the assumed direct relationship between economic pain inflicted on the target and political gain for the sender. The expressive purpose of international sanctions functions according to a constructivist (normative) logic which perceives sanctions to may be serving any goal relevant to the sender and not limited to be perceived only as a tool for behaviour modification. Sanctions work through the diffusion of norms and are used as a measure to “do something” to re-establish sender’s authority in certain events. Expressive sanctions tend to display a disregard for costs as the act of sanctioning serves as an important signal of resolve, moral disapproval or so, and the act itself is more relevant to the sender than the costs it inflicts on both parties. In further sections of the paper the validity of both models of theoretical premises is tested in the case of EU sanctions against Russia through the method of systematic process tracing. The key findings support the main argument of the paper that the expressive purpose of sanctions explains the case better than the instrumental purpose. The EU acted as a normative actor fulfilling its self-proclaimed duty to safeguard peace and stability in Europe. Despite heavy disagreements and strong trade, financial and political elite ties to Russia, individual member states came to a consensus after the build-up of Russia’s illegal actions that spiralled out of control, ending in the downing of the MH17 flight by the pro-Russian separatists in Eastern Ukraine that killed almost 300 innocent civilians that were mostly EU citizens. The moment of outrage was turned into a moment of action to signal strong resolve and moral disapproval of Russia’s actions. The relevance of the paper is both theoretical and practical. On the one hand, it serves as a starting point for a more well-rounded conceptual debate about the imposition of international sanctions, rather than continuing to fixate on their effectiveness only. On the other hand, as the dominant theories usually dismiss the cases that contradict their premises as “merely symbolic” or somehow less important, this paper bridges the gap between theory and practice by explaining a paradoxical case of sanctions imposition. The case of EU economic sanctions against Russia marks a significant change in EU sanctions policy – it demonstrates that the EU, a union traditionally based on economically beneficial decisions and framed as a “soft power”, is willing to use tools that require economic sacrifice to tame big powers that have gone rogue.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Year dc:date
2016

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Sadauskaitė, Audronė,
Contributors dc:contributor
  • Janeliūnas, Tomas

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
Language dc:language
lit

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Vilnius University
Base URL
epublications.vu.lt/oai
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Sadauskaitė, Audronė,. ES ekonominių sankcijų Rusijai paskirtis: efektyvumas prieš išraišką /. Institutional Repository of Vilnius University, 2016. https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD23346395&prefLang=en_US