Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Demokratijos problema tradicionalistinės katalikybės perspektyvoje /
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe Problem of Democracy from the Perspective of Traditionalist Catholicism The paper deals with controversial development of contemporary Western democracies as seen from the perspective of traditionalist Catholicism. Nowadays there are many visible problems of democratic regimes, such as little involvement of ordinary citizens into democratic processes, increasing power of unelected bureaucrats as well as growing importance of expert examination to the governance. The aim of this study is to discuss these tendencies from the perspective of traditionalist catholic political philosophy that has always been critical to the modern metaphysical and anthropological assumptions and therefore helps to understand the main theoretical roots of today’s democratic crisis. It is an attempt to show that antidemocratic processes present in contemporary democracies are a natural consequence of modern philosophical premises, based on immanent metaphysics and anthropology. The work discusses two different conceptions of politics and democracy: traditionalist Catholic, considered as the successor of pre-modern philosophy, and modern philosophy that sought to create a radically new interpretation of politics and metaphysics. The main element of the modern theory is an immanent view of the world built on the Thomas Hobbes’s idea that humans can only understand reality created by their own, which means that existence of transcendence as well as Christian God becomes no longer valid. It is argued that this move is crucial to the rise of subjective morality since without objective source of reality there cannot be objective and supra-human truth about the supreme good as well. Furthermore, rejection of supra-human truth and criterion suggests that there are no ways to justify objectively ideal type of man, which was present in ancient and Christian philosophy, and makes clear why modern political philosophy started actually treating all men equally. Strongly tied with the premise of subjective morality, this egalitarian anthropology supposed a different kind of politics and state. Unlike pre-modern political theory that assumed that the aim of a political community is to represent an ideal type of man, modern political philosophy, essentially based on contract theories, started treating a state and a political community as means to attain personal ends and desires that are also considered equal. The paper argues that egalitarianism was at first successfully realized in two fields – modern economics and law. Both of them are based on the idea that all personal desires should be enabled to realization if they are not harmful to other citizens‘ personal objectives. However, an attempt to create similar political order signifies harsh difficulties. When treating everybody absolutely equally, there can be no hierarchies, and without accepting them political rule is hardly possible. As it is shown in the study, this means that political rule is replaced by mere administration aimed at helping citizens to attain their personal ends. This in turn requires establishing an administrative mechanism based on specific knowledge, mainly in the fields of economics and law. The purpose to ensure effective administrative system arouses a need of professional knowledge and expert examination that is not shared by ordinary citizens. This means that such type of administration gradually transforms into elitist governance, independent from the people as a whole. A conclusion is drawn that expert individuals, businessmen, banks, tribunals, nongovernmental organizations and other similar subjects reflect the move from democratic rule to the elitist rule that can be considered the main symbol of today‘s democratic crisis.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2018
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Morkūnaitė, Monika,
- Contributors dc:contributor
-
- Radžvilas, Vytautas
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD29810234&prefLang=en_US