Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Liberalizmo kritika Roberto Mangabeiros Ungerio politinėje teorijoje /
Abstract
dc:descriptionCritique of Liberalism in Roberto Mangabeira Unger's Political Theory The analysis of Unger’s critique of liberalism revealed the following: 1. Liberal consciousness comes into conflict with the antinomies that reflect inadequacies of liberal theory and distort globally prevailing ideology by preventing it from forming a consistent theory of personality and maintaining an “inherent harmony” in liberal society. Therefore, the in-depth analysis of the antinomies of liberal consciousness leads to the conclusion that liberalism itself cannot resolve the antinomies of liberal values by devaluating all traditional values and dictating its own “liberal values” that are fully incompatible with and contradict each other; 2. Liberalism promoted in the legal system on a global scale encourages implementing inflation of “universal human rights” and, by doing so, manipulates inalienable human rights. The more-detailed analysis of the concept of the legal framework shows that the legal order, developed through the liberal doctrine and promoting the primacy of individual rights, strongly avoids recognition of the priority of a collective when it clearly cannot hide its inconsistency, discrepancy and manipulation. Therefore, based on Unger’s work, it can be said that the legal framework in a liberal state is conceptually neutral, outside the control of any systems and lacking commonality; 3. The economic postulate idea deeply rooted in the structure of liberal consciousness gives the best explanation of the free trade concept based on the market economy, international division of labour and development of international trade by highlighting the importance of specialization. The in-depth analysis of Unger’s works helped clarify that the liberal economic system nevertheless fails to achieve comprehensive freedom due to the existing barriers to trade issues or “distorting policies”. Fearful of especially close interdependence of states that can cause external vulnerability and absence of autonomy, actors in international trade continue to implement protectionist measures and, by doing so, do not allow the liberal economic niche to fully implement liberal ideas. On the basis of the critical analysis of the works of Rorty, Bahnsen and Richards, it can be stated that authors’ remarks on Unger’s critique of liberalism are sound and well-targeted. The ideas of Platonism, Marxism and Mysticism observed in Unger’s critique clearly show that Unger’s total critique can be defined as abstract, not well grounded and lacking necessary precision. In some aspects, R. M. Unger contradicts himself by criticizing the liberal theory imposed on the whole world by the Western political elite. On the one hand, the philosopher criticizes the widespread principle of individualism by actively offering to return to collective values and goals; however, on the other hand, he provides contradictory proposals that each individual should keep a distance from other members of society in order to retain their own autonomy and human identity. It has to be recognized that contradiction and inconsistency can also be easily seen as regards the ways of aporias of liberalism proposed by Unger – new synthesis and empowered democracy. Therefore, in answering the key question of this critical analysis, it has to be stated that R. M. Unger's critique of liberalism is not complete in all respects due to the identifiable contradictory thoughts, abstractness and utopian belief that the vision of an ideal civil society supported by an “inherent harmony” can nevertheless be implemented. It is clear that neither the new synthesis, nor the model of empowered democracy can resolve all aporias that exist in the liberal doctrine until the doctrine itself changes and builds a solid ideological foundation with the key objective of forming its consistent identity and values rather than, on the contrary, destroying traditional structures.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2017
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Šalkovskaja, Evelina,
- Contributors dc:contributor
-
- Jokubaitis, Alvydas
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD35441177&prefLang=en_US