Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Teroristinių organizacijų kaip transnacionalinių veikėjų transformacija. ISIS atvejo analizė /
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe Transformation of Terrorist Organisations as Transnational Actors. The Case Study of ISIS The thesis aims to answer the question in which form ISIS, the biggest current terrorism threat in the world, transforms. In order to answer this question a qualitative comparative analysis between three terrorist organisations, Hamas, al-Qaeda and ISIS, is carried out. As the research is based on Audrey Kurth Cronin’s theory, which predicts that terrorist organizations demise after the occurence of certain events, the main assumption is that they inherit the necessity to transform into a legitimate, local politcal actor in order to survive. Following this logic, Hamas and al-Qaeda were elected as references for comparison, as the former is a succesful and the latter an unsuccesful precedent within the frame of Kurth Cronin. In the present case a comparison was made by contrasting the five most important categories that characterize an organization: aims and mission, internal structure, methods of opeation, internal and external communication, sources of funding. By the juxtaposition of these, one was able to detect the main similarities and differences between the three entities. By systemizing the information with the aid of a table, it appeared possible to find out about the tendency of transformation for ISIS – whether it is on its way to transform into a legitimate, local political actor or towards insignificance and dissolution. The research indicates that ISIS, incongruent to its predecessor al-Qaeda, takes a very different path of transformation. While al-Qaeda was decentralized and did not try to form any political institutions, ISIS took this experience as bad example and became more centralized and transformed its internal structure to a rather institutionalized one, where separation of powers takes place. This clearly reveals the tendency of ISIS to convert into a political subject. Nevertheless, the type of it cannot be declared yet. The comparison of Hamas’ and ISIS’ dimensions exposes some similiarities between both organisations, and thereby ISIS might use some of Hamas’ best practices to ensure its transition into a political party. Nonetheless, the transformation of its internal structure or the control of territory is not sufficient for the survival of the organisation - important aspects for the full transformation are missing. Most impotrantly, it was found that Hamas’ motivation to become a legitimized political entity were economic; it simply expected enhanced possibilities to receive funding. In opposition, ISIS owns vast options of income – from ransom of systematic kidnapping to the sales of crude oil. Furthermore, the so-called Islamic State shows close to any propensity to negotiations in the international arena. Eventually, the research shows that ISIS owns more vital patterns that might enhance its path into the traditional political arena than its predecessor and rival, al-Qaeda. Yet, the qualitative comparitive analysis suggests the impossibility to follow the example of Hamas – its policies and actions need to be significantly softened, but this is rather unlikely. According to the applied theory, which assumes that terrorist organisations may become a political actor and the hostile Western agenda of large-scale counter-terrorrism, the likelihood of defeat in a conventional war aganist the West, is high.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2017
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Pagojutė, Greta,
- Contributors dc:contributor
-
- Janeliūnas, Tomas
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD35441314&prefLang=en_US