Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Teritoriniai konfliktai Pietų Kinijos jūroje: tarp priešinimosi ir nusileidimo Pekinui /
Abstract
dc:descriptionThe Bachelor thesis “Territorial Disputes in the South China Sea: Between Resistance and Submission to Beijing” seeks to explain why some Southeast Asian states actively respond to China’s actions in the South China Sea while others are not actively confronting Beijing. Research problem: from 2010 China, claiming 95% of the territory, has increased the aggressiveness of its conduct in the South China Sea, it increasingly started reclaiming land from the sea in disputed territories, Beijing’s government vessels barred fishers from neighbouring countries from accessing fishing spots. Yet while some countries, namely Vietnam and, until recently, the Philippines, have actively opposed China’s actions, other parties of the disputes have kept fairly quiet. The aim of the thesis is to analyse what are the causes of this difference in response using neorealism, Stephen Walt’s balance of threat, as the theoretical basis. The objects of the analysis are the four Southeast Asian states directly involved in the territorial disputes: Vietnam, the Philippines, Malaysia and Brunei, and Indonesia, whose claims border those of China. The tasks of the paper are to introduce reader to the disputes, cases and Beijing’s actions; to analyse the actions of the Southeast Asian countries using neorealism; evaluate the degree to which neorealism explains the actions of the countries in question, and what are its flaws. The analysis is conducted following the comparative case study method. Vietnam is takes as the “ideal” case to which others are compared. The variables of the research are military strength and alliances, economy, and proximity to the aggressor and perceived threat. The thesis argues and confirms that proximity and perceived threat is the strongest cause for the difference in reaction. Vietnam and the Philippines are immediate neighbours to China and are subject to the most amount of conflicts and encounters. Indonesia, Malaysia and Brunei are far from China and are more threatened be local neighbours (namely each other), because of their own territorial disputes, although Indonesia is more active when Chinese vessels come close. Military strength and reliable alliances determine how actively the country can react – Vietnam has adequate military to resist and perceives support from third parties. The Philippines have a weaker military, yet it had a defensive partnership with the U.S. and felt able to pressure China, but that changed after Manila received no support from Washington during Beijing’s occupation of Scarborough shoal. Furthermore, lack of a diversified economy causes weaker states to be more reliant on China, although it potentially benefits both sides. China gets needed resources such as oil and gas, and support for its One Belt, One Road initiative, while second parties receive needed investment and economic development. Based on S. Walt’s implications about investments being more harmful to the donor than giving extensive influence over the recipient, closer economic ties helped boost Vietnam’s economy to such a degree that it is currently able to diversify its economic relations and is not fully dependent on China. In the same manner, Malaysia and Brunei could do the same in due time and have minimal dependence on Beijing. While S. Walt’s implications regarding when and why states choose to balance against a threat and why to align with it are thought of mostly as correct, although the thesis used a modified version of his balance of threat theory. Walt considers only the military strength of the aggressor, but the strength and perceived support of the choosing country is equally important, as shown by the analysis.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2017
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Ligeika, Gediminas,
- Contributors dc:contributor
-
- Andrijauskas, Konstantinas
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD35449355&prefLang=en_US