Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
ES nuolatinis struktūrizuotas bendradarbiavimas: vokiškojo modelio pasirinkimo priežasčių aiškinimas /
Abstract
dc:descriptionIn 2016, a round of negotiations began in the Council of EU and the European Council on launching the Permanent Structured Cooperation (PESCO) within the European Union’s (EU) Common Security and Defence Policy. There was uncertainty regarding the entire framework of PESCO: what will it cover, which countries will join, will it not duplicate NATO and so on. Nevertheless, the member states of the EU faced a challenge not only in debating the basic presumptions of the future security and defence mechanism, but also they were presented with two opposing PESCO views – the so called French and German models. Paris was campaigning for an elite club of states with better defence capabilities which would focus on intensifying military and civil missions. The French model was also modeled to be an exclusively European framework with the goal of becoming more independent from decision making only within the structure of NATO. It suggested it was time for Europe to become more independent in the matters of security and defence. On the opposite side, Berlin was seeking more inclusiveness and more synchronization with already-existing NATO commitments. The agreed PESCO model appears to be more German than French, although it is officially both inclusive and ambitious – something from both the German and the French suggestions. This study seeks to identify and explain the reasons for member states choosing the German model, even though the French model appears to be closer to the text formulation in the Lisbon treaty (now Treaty of EU). Andrew Moravscik’s liberal intergovernmentalism theory was chosen to explain the decision making process for PESCO. As this theory focuses on national preferences, the international bargaining processes and institutional construction, this study consists two parts of analysis – the first one analyses the member states’ national preferences through the concept of strategic cultures, and the second one analyses the process of bargaining within the Council of EU and the European Council through six semi-structured interviews with Lithuanian government officials. Because of the length limitations and no sufficient differences between each of the models’ suggestions on institutional PESCO implementation, the third part of the theory is not applied in this study. The findings of the study demonstrate that both the national preferences and the process of international bargaining had impact on choosing the German model for PESCO. The analysis shows that those countries which have a strategic culture more similar to Germany’s strategic culture were mostly on board with Berlin’s suggestions. It is also evident that the ambitiousness within the CSDP framework 50 and foreign policy orientation of Germany is more acceptable to a higher number of member states than that of France. Even though Paris shows high ambitiousness and strong orientation towards EU, only a few other states share this kind of strategic culture. International bargaining processes, however, showed that not only were states keen on expressing their national interests which are the same or close to those of Germany, but other means led to choosing the Berlin’s proposal. Among the reasons for this were seeking to be able to control PESCO processes from within, even if a country does not fully agree on its goals or approaches. Another reason is, of course, the inclusiveness which guarantees that even the countries with low defence capacities can join the initiative and strengthen them. The inclusiveness of this model also ensures a more equal distribution of benefits amongst states, whereas within the French model, only a handful of states would have enjoyed the extra benefits of this cooperation. Finally, most of the states were keen on keeping the Transatlantic relationship intact, whether the mentioned countries are fans of NATO or they want to ensure the future cooperation through bilateral relations with the U.S.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2019
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Indrašiūtė, Emilė,
- Contributors dc:contributor
-
- Šešelgytė, Margarita
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD88150200&prefLang=en_US