Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Rinkimų sistemos efektai Lietuvoje: ar Lietuvos politikus ir elektoratą veikia psichologinis efektas? /
Abstract
dc:descriptionElectoral System Effects: does Psychological Effect Affect Lithuanian Politicians and Voters? A thesis "Electoral system effects: does psychological effect affect Lithuanian politicians and voters?"researches the operation of Duverger’s law in a mixed-parallel system practiced by Lithuania. Duverger’s law states that the choice of electoral system determines the nature of state’s party system due to the mechanical and psychological effects. Mechanical effect is in operation as votes are being transferred to seats while psychological effect is defined as strategic voting and strategic non-entry. The thesis aims to reveal how big a psychological effect of mixed electoral system on politicians and voters is in Lithuania and to disclose the causes of such tendencies. It presents calculations of mechanical effect, psychological effect on politicians and voters in the majoritarian component of the electoral system, evaluates the tendencies, concludes whether contamination effect suppresses a psychological effect on parties and whether candidate supply affects the magnitude of psychological effect on voters. Duverger’s law was originally designed for “pure” electoral systems. It states that due to large mechanical and therefore, psychological effect plurality systems determine two-party systems while majority run-off and PR systems, favor multiparty systems. However, electoral system effects are evident in mixed electoral systems as well. The most significant theory in the field is contamination theory - since mixed systems employ both majoritarian and PR systems, two party competition in a majoritarian component does not occur as parties tend to nominate their candidates even in the districts where they are not viable in order to gain extra votes in the PR race. Therefore, the number of entrants is higher than in pure majoritarian systems and it is more difficult for the voters to identify possible winners, thus, the level of strategic voting is lower. Three hypotheses are formulated: • H1: Total psychological effect on politicians and voters is smaller than mechanical effect in a majoritarian component of electoral system in Lithuania. • H2: Candidate supply in single member districts (SMD) does not decrease in time. • H3: Psychological effect on voters is smaller in districts which are characterized by large candidate supply. The study finds that mechanical effect is very large – it reduces parliamentary fragmentation by 3,25 effective parliamentary parties (EPP). Despite, the number of candidates per district remains high because of a small psychological effect on parties and voters – it reduces parliamentary fragmentation only by 0,12 EPP. The first hypothesis is confirmed as the psychological effect on average is smaller by 3,13 EPP than the mechanical effect. Further, the psychological effect on politicians was evaluated researching the change in candidate supply in time. The number of candidates per district was smallest during the first parliamentary election, otherwise, the number has varied through the years and was inconsistent, but the candidate supply did not decrease in time supporting the second hypothesis, in line with contamination logic. Finally, psychological effect on voters reduces electoral fragmentation in SMDs by 1,29 EPP. Linear regression disclosed that there is a significant relation between candidate supply and psychological effect on voters. It appeared that as the psychological effect on politicians increases, the psychological effect on voters increases as well, thus, the third hypothesis is also confirmed. In summary, the thesis finds that psychological effect on both politicians and voters is small in the majoritarian component of electoral system in Lithuania due to the contamination effect as parties do not practice strategic non-entry and voters find it difficult to identify possible winners and thus, abstain from voting strategically and choose to vote sincerely instead.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2019
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Stakėnaitė, Gintarė,
- Contributors dc:contributor
-
- Jastramskis, Mažvydas
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD88374913&prefLang=en_US