Back to search

Institutional Repository of Vilnius University

Konstitucijų keitimo poveikis demokratijos kokybei Lotynų Amerikoje /

Abstract

dc:description

Thesis “The impact of replacing constitutions on the quality of democracy in Latin America” seeks to answer the question whether the constitutional replacements have an impact on the quality of democracy in Latin America. New constitutions in nine Latin American countries were analysed. Additionally, as a control measure, nine other Latin American countries, where constitutional replacements did not take place, were included in the research. More specifically, the analysed constitutions are characterised by three features of new constitutionalism period. Firstly, they aimed to enhance vertical and horizontal accountability. Secondly, new documents ensured wide political, economic and social rights provision. Finally, constitutions created new mechanisms to enhance citizens participation in decision making. Overall, all constitutions entailed an aim to increase the quality of democracy in the country. Yet, some doubt the promise to enhance the quality of democracy by the means of constitutional engineering. It is thought, that the content of the new constitutions is contradictory. Thus, the lack of academic consensus constitutes the foundational problem of this thesis: it is not clear whether replacing the constitution can improve the quality of democracy. Considering the complexity of the quality of democracy concept, additional variables (income equality, educational attainment level, the institutionalisation of the party system and ethnic homogeneity) were included in the analysis. A political regime can be classified qualitative democracy if it meets the basics criteria of minimal, electoral democracy and additional conditions of process, content and results. Furthermore, it is expected that only the net-effect of constitutional replacements is not enough to explain the outcome. Thus, a multi-causal relation will be analysed as well. Specifically, the objectives of this thesis are to find out whether: a) Constitutional replacement is necessary and/or sufficient condition of the quality of democracy; b) Constitutional replacement together with other causes constitutes a sufficient condition of the quality of democracy; Additionally, in the thesis inverse evaluation of the impact of constitutional replacements on the quality of democracy will be carried out. In other words, it will be analysed whether the condition (changing the constitution, alone or together with other variables) explains the poor quality of democracy. Seeking to evaluate causal relations, fuzzy-set qualitative comparative analysis method was used. The results of the analysis reveal that replacing the constitutions alone cannot explain neither quality nor the poor quality of democracy. On the contrary, poor quality of democracy is explained by two configurations of conditions. Solutions consisting of either replacing the constitution together with income inequality, not institutionalised party system and heterogeneous society variables, or replacing the constitution together with income inequality, low levels of educational attainment and heterogeneous society are sufficient conditions of poor quality of democracy. Nevertheless, these conclusions have to be evaluated with caution. The results can only be interpreted and applied while analysing similar cases. Additionally, introducing different variables into the analysis might produce different results. This analysis also reveals that further research is needed in other to grasp the broader impact of constitutional replacements on the quality of democracy in Latin America. Firstly, constitutional amendments could be included in the analysis. This would allow to compare the results and to evaluate whether the way of changing the constitution is essential for the quality of democracy. Secondly, different forms of democracy (egalitarian, deliberative or participatory) could be analysed.

Degree

thesis:*
Grantor dc:publisher
Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Year dc:date
2019

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Strauka, Orestas,
Contributors dc:contributor
  • Gudžinskas, Liutauras

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
Language dc:language
lit

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Vilnius University
Base URL
epublications.vu.lt/oai
Last updated
2026-11-19
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
related terms
citation

Strauka, Orestas,. Konstitucijų keitimo poveikis demokratijos kokybei Lotynų Amerikoje /. Institutional Repository of Vilnius University, 2019. https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD88374952&prefLang=en_US