Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
Ekologinės migracijos rėminimas: IPCC atvejis /
Abstract
dc:descriptionFraming Environmental Migration: the Case of IPCC The definition of environmental migration (EM) is yet to be agreed upon, still some information about it is issued by IPCC in their Assessment Reports, which provide policy makers with information on climate change, therefore creating a form of understanding about EM. Considering the impacts of mentioned information it is thus crucial to recognize IPCC’s framing of enviromental migration. Existing studies on IPCC’s framing of EM cover the topic only partially, hence this thesis seeks to supplement existing studies by asking how the IPCC Assessment Reports frame EM in the period of 1990-2019? The purpose of this thesis is to examine the framing of EM throughout IPCC Assessment Reports. The research objects of this thesis are five Assessment Reports and 1992 Supplementary Reports. To achieve the aim of this thesis 5 tasks will be carried out: 1) main criteria to recognize frames will be identified based on framing theory and existing research; 2) qualitative content analysis (conventional and direct) will be presented as main tools for the analysis; 3) Assessment Reports will be analyzed through direct content analysis to sort out text parts that fit under the existing EM frames; 4) The remaining parts will be analysed with conventional content analysis; 5) The framing of EM in IPCC will be assesed; 8 frames have been found to prevail in the reports: victims, security threaths, adaptive agents, political subjects, health hazards, economic burdens, city overloads and complex migrants. The main findings are the following. First, the research has provided an insight that the framing of EM has never been homogeneous. Each report applies at least three types of frames. The greatest amount of types of framings can be found in the latest report (6 out of 8). That has made clear that IPCC is lacking a sense of unity considering their position on discussed topic and calls for a ponder whether the variety of frames appears due to the lack of an official definition. Second, it is obvious that security threat and health hazard framings are of utmost importance. Said framings suggest that environmental migrants could be the cause of conflicts (raising from lack of resources or ethnic disagreements) or a burden for medical institutions and a source of infectious diseases. Therefore an assumption can be made that in such a way it is aimed to localise the problem of EM and to prevent it from spreading. Third, it is clear that the last Assessment Report differs from the others, since the dominant frames in it are adaptive agent and complex migrant. The frame of adaptive agent can be undertoned as an aim to identify environmental migrantion as a positive migration strategy. Meanwhile the framing of complex migrant could be interpreted as an intention to dismantle the concept by pointing out that climate change cannot be identified as a single reason to migrate, therefore EM can not be differentiated from other types of migration. Thus, EM can be interpreted to be a positive outcome and to not exist at all in the same raport. Hence this type of framing can provide an explanation on why the international law lacks a legal definition of EM, because agreeing on it would position EM as a problem that ought to be identified on an international level. The study leads to a wider understanding on EM. The conclusions that are drawn encourage to continue the research on understanding the concept of EM in the future, considering that the research conducted will include the refugee crisis of 2015 and the unprecedented situation caused by COVID-19. Additional research can be done on evaluating how the framing of environmental migration reflects on policy making.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2020
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Butkevičiūtė, Gintautė,
- Contributors dc:contributor
-
- Mačkinis, Vilius
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD88376063&prefLang=en_US