Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
„Gyvieji skydai": lawfare strategija Izraelio-Palestinos konflikte /
Abstract
dc:descriptionHuman Shielding: a Form of Lawfare in the Israeli-Palestinian Conflict The use of human shield is usually understood as a lawfare of the weaker actor seeking to gain a strategic advantage in an asymmetrical warfare. However as a response to the accusations over Israel‘s excessive use of force against Palestinian civilians during the Operation Protective Edge, Israel started using a legal category of human shield. This calls a question whether human shielding could also become a discursive tool manipulatively used by a state. The thesis aims to assess whether human shielding can be considered as a form of Israel‘s lawfare in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Therefore the research objects of this thesis are 59 speeches on Operation Protective Edge made by Israel‘s foreign policy representatives. To achieve the aim 5 tasks were set: identification of the criteria that would allow the recognition of lawfare in Israel’s discourse; introduction of a framework for the language of legitimation analysis; selection of the adequate speeches by Israel‘s foreign policy representatives; organisation of the speeches based on the advocated aims and identification of the most important group; evaluation whether the Israel’s use of a legal category of human shield fits the concept of lawfare. The study confirms that in some cases the use of a legal category of human shield describes an indeterminacy-based lawfare. The deployment of a legal argument of human shield in order to legitimise the excessive use of force against civilians defies the IHL‘s object and purpose and it meets the definition of this lawfare. Secondly, three ways in which Israel uses the argument of human shield were recognized: to show the difference between the actions taken by Israel and those taken by Hamas; to question the possibility of supporting Hamas; to legitimise criticised actions (discourse of legitimation). Thirdly, according to the CDA Israel’s discourse of legitimation is impacted by context – the alternative discourse criticising actions of Israel. The resolution adopted by the UNHRC on 23 July 2014 which condemns Israel over the excessive use of force against Palestinian civilians made a basis for Israel to discursively show the difference between “legitimate“ Israel’s action and “illegitimate“ Hamas’s action and UNHRC’s discourse. Fourthly, Israel‘s deployment of a legal category of human shield describes the use of the indeterminacy-based lawfare. The findings show that the use of a category of human shield is recognised in the following forms of legitimation. The authorisation form uses a legal argument of human shield to legitimise questionable Israel‘s actions during the operation based on legal ground and example from other states. The moral evaluation form uses a category of human shield to legitimise Israel‘s actions based on showing moral distinction between Israel‘s actions and Hamas‘s actions, providing negative abstract description to Hamas action and morally comparing Israel’s case with other cases. The rationalisation form uses an argument of human shield to legitimise Israel‘s actions based on theoretical and instrumental rationalisation. Mythopoesis form uses a category of human shield to legitimise Israel‘s actions based on creating a moral tale that normalises harm to civilians. The results confirm that a legal argument of human shield is used to legitimise actions during the operation that are criticised for causing an excessive harm to Palestinian civilians and the use of this legal argument defies the IHL‘s object and purpose. This thesis provides framework for further research on discursive lawfare which could be employed to assess Israel’s other discourses, confrontations in Israeli-Palestinian conflict and other cases of human shielding, for example Russo-Ukrainian War. The results do not try to appeal to absolute objectivity: the author understands that applying another perspective of analysis could alter findings.
Degree
thesis:*- Grantor dc:publisher
- Institutional Repository of Vilnius University
- Year dc:date
- 2020
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Drūteikaitė, Gabija,
- Contributors dc:contributor
-
- Leonaitė, Erika
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- info:eu-repo/semantics/openAccess
- Language dc:language
- lit
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Repository record dc:identifier
- https://repository.vu.lt/VU:ELABAETD88376201&prefLang=en_US