Virginia Polytechnic Institute
Pilot recordkeeping classes vs. traditional bookkeeping classes in Virginia high schools
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThe purpose of this study was to compare recordkeeping and bookkeeping students on the basis of (1) aptitude, (2) recordkeeping achievement, (3) drop-out rate, and (4) attitude. To achieve this purpose, recordkeeping students in pilot schools were compared with bookkeeping students in control schools. A suburban school and a rural school were selected as the pilot schools. Then two schools, similar in location (one suburban and one rural) and size to the pilot schools, were selected as control schools. The suburban pilot school was paired with the suburban control school, and the rural pilot school was paired with the rural control school. Thus, all comparisons were made between two groups: (1) the suburban pilot recordkeeping classes and suburban control bookkeeping classes, and (2) the rural pilot recordkeeping classes and rural control bookkeeping classes. Age, grade level, and aptitude data for the 120 students participating in the study were obtained and analyzed statistically to determine if a variance existed between groups. The analysis of variance procedure revealed a significant difference between the pilot and control groups in age and grade level at the 1 per cent confidence level and in I.Q. at the 5 per cent confidence level. There was no significant variance in the scores of the students in either suburban or rural schools on the Clerical Speed and Accuracy part of the Differential Aptitude Test which was administered to them. A recordkeeping achievement test constructed by the investigator for the purpose of measuring the ability of recordkeeping and bookkeeping students to perform selected recordkeeping tasks was administered to the recordkeeping and bookkeeping students. It was divided into five parts: (1) Sequencing and Verifying, (2) Business Mathematics, (3) Proof of Cash, (4) Charge Accounts, and (5) Petty Cash Records. The recordkeeping achievement data included (1) total recordkeeping achievement test scores, (2) total scores for each part of the test, and (3) total number of errors made by each recordkeeping and bookkeeping student. As a result of the variance in age, grade level, and I. Q., the achievement data were adjusted to a conunon level for these factors so that comparisons could be made. The following conclusions were drawn in the study: 1. The pilot recordkeeping students scored significantly higher than the control bookkeeping students on the recordkeeping achievement test in both suburban and rural schools. In no case did the pilot recordkeeping students' performance on any part of the recordkeeping test fall significantly below that of the control bookkeeping students. 2. There was a significant difference at the 1 per cent level in scores of rural pilot and control students on Part I, Sequencing and Verifying. The pilot recordkeeping students in both suburban and rural schools made fewer errors per student in both sequencing and verifying than did the control bookkeeping students. 3. There was no significant difference in the scores of pilot and control students in Part II, Business Mathematics. 4. There was no significant difference in the scores of pilot and control students on Part III, Proof of Cash. 5. The mean score of the recordkeeping students was significantly higher than that of the bookkeeping students on Part IV, Charge Accounts. Suburban pilot recordkeeping and control bookkeeping students had mean part scores of 17.0 and 8.3 respectively; rural pilot recordkeeping and control bookkeeping students had mean part scores of 17.3 and 12.7 respectively. It was discovered that: a. Recordkeeping students made fewer errors in recording information in correct columns than did bookkeeping students. b. Recordkeeping students in the suburban schools made fewer errors involving debits and credits than did bookkeeping students. 6. The recordkeeping students scored significantly higher than the bookkeeping students on Part V, Petty Cash. 7. The drop-out rate due to failure was lower in the recordkeeping classes (5.1 per cent) than in the bookkeeping classes (12 per cent). 8. The pilot recordkeeping students were generally more satisfied with the recordkeeping course than were the control bookkeeping students with the bookkeeping course as indicated by the finding that 79 per cent of the recordkeeping students stated they liked their course very much and 48 per cent of the bookkeeping students stated they liked their course very much. Based on the findings of this study, it was recommended that schools considering the possibility of revising the traditional bookkeeping program consider the findings of this study as to the effect of a recordkeeping course on achievement, attitude, and drop-out rate of the students. Business teachers and guidance personnel should work together in determining which students should be placed in the recordkeeping course based on their ability, interest, and future plans.
Degree
thesis:*- Name thesis:degree_name
- M.S.
- Level thesis:degree_level
- masters
- Discipline thesis:degree_discipline
- Business Education
- Department dc:contributor.department
- Business Education
- Grantor dc:publisher
- Virginia Polytechnic Institute
- Year dc:date.issued
- 1967
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Fink, Evelyn Marie
- Chair dc:contributor.committeechair
-
- Bass, B. C.
- Committee members dc:contributor.committeemember
-
- Beamer, R. W.
- Shell, W. L.
Rights
dc:rights- Statement dc:rights
-
- In Copyright
- Licence dc:rights.uri
- Language dc:language.iso
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Handle dc:identifier.uri
- https://hdl.handle.net/10919/141358