Back to search

Virginia Tech

Winter Bale Grazing versus Sacrifice Paddocks in the Southeastern United States: Impacts on Animal Performance, Economic Viability, and Soil Health

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Traditional winter-feeding methods for beef cattle present significant operational and environmental challenges, including high labor demands, intensive machinery use, concentrated nutrient deposition, and elevated risk of nutrient runoff. Sacrifice Paddocks (designated areas where cow-calf pairs are confined during winter to protect surrounding pastures) represent the conventional approach in the Southeastern United States. While effective at limiting overgrazing, the concentrated nature of Sacrifice Paddocks raises concerns about long-term soil health, nutrient cycling efficiency, and economic sustainability. Rotational Bale Grazing offers an alternative, in which large round hay bales are pre-placed on pasture in a grid pattern prior to the onset of winter feeding, and cattle are given controlled access to successive bales via strip grazing with a moveable electric fence. Studies conducted in the Canadian Prairies and Northern Great Plains have documented agronomic and economic advantages of Rotational Bale Grazing, but its feasibility in the temperate, humid climate of the Southeastern United States had not been evaluated. This dissertation, conducted over three consecutive winter-feeding seasons (2021–2024) at the Shenandoah Valley Agricultural Research and Extension Center (SVAREC) in Raphine, Virginia, assessed the impacts of Rotational Bale Grazing versus Sacrifice Paddocks on soil health, animal performance, and economic viability. Three pre-established Sacrifice Paddock replicates and three Rotational Bale Grazing replicates were utilized, each stocked with eight Angus-cross cow-calf pairs grazing Novel Endophyte Tall Fescue (Schedonorus arundinaceus) pastures for approximately 60 days each winter. The soil health chapter evaluated permanganate oxidizable carbon (POXC), total soil carbon and nitrogen, particulate organic matter (POM) and mineral-associated organic matter (MAOM) fractions, and intra-aggregate stability (IAS). Sacrifice Paddocks consistently exhibited higher POXC and total soil carbon and nitrogen than Rotational Bale Grazing paddocks, with significant Year × Treatment interactions observed for POXC (p = 0.0055) and total carbon (p < 0.0001). These differences were attributed to legacy effects of over 20 years of concentrated feeding at the Sacrifice Paddock locations, rather than to short-term treatment responses. Within Rotational Bale Grazing paddocks in 2024, bale placement locations exhibited significantly higher POXC than non-bale locations (Treatment × Bale Location interaction, p = 0.0007), suggesting that the targeted nutrient deposition characteristic of Rotational Bale Grazing has the potential to elevate soil biological activity at the local scale over time. The animal performance chapter found no significant differences in cow body weight change or average daily gain between Rotational Bale Grazing and Sacrifice Paddock treatments in any of the three years. Sacrifice Paddock cows maintained numerically higher body condition scores (BCS) across all years, with statistically significant differences detected in 2021–2022 and 2022–2023; however, a pre-existing BCS advantage among Sacrifice Paddock cows in 2021–2022 complicates interpretation of that year's result. Rotational Bale Grazing calves were numerically heavier than Sacrifice Paddock calves at the end of the winter-feeding season in all three years, with a statistically significant body weight advantage of approximately 28 kg observed in 2022–2023. Feed use efficiency (FUE) was significantly higher for Rotational Bale Grazing in all three years, and estimated hay dry matter intake was lower for Rotational Bale Grazing in two of three years, reflecting reduced hay wastage under the distributed, on-field feeding system. The economic analysis constructed enterprise budgets for each system, standardized to a 24-cow-calf design herd, and evaluated results through sensitivity analyses on hay price, feeder calf price, and labor wage rate. Rotational Bale Grazing consumed 43% less hay per cow than Sacrifice Paddocks (0.800 vs. 1.149 short tons DM cow⁻¹), resulting in $1,148 lower total variable costs. Fixed equipment costs were $2,048 lower for Rotational Bale Grazing, driven by two Sacrifice Paddock-exclusive capital items (a dedicated tractor and manure spreader). Heavier calves under Rotational Bale Grazing generated $2,372 more in gross receipts. Combined, these differences yielded a Return Above Total Costs of −$5,345 for Rotational Bale Grazing versus −$9,832 for Sacrifice Paddocks, a $4,487 advantage favoring Rotational Bale Grazing. This advantage held across all sensitivity scenarios tested, including hay prices ranging from $80 to $160 per ton DM, feeder calf prices ranging ±20% from the 10-year Virginia average, and labor wage rates from $15 to $35 per hour. Collectively, these findings indicate that Rotational Bale Grazing is a financially viable, operationally practical, and agronomically sound alternative to Sacrifice Paddocks for winter-feeding beef cow-calf pairs in Virginia and the broader Southeastern United States.

Degree

thesis:*
Name thesis:degree_name
Doctor of Philosophy
Level thesis:degree_level
doctoral
Discipline thesis:degree_discipline
Crop and Soil Environmental Sciences
Department dc:contributor.department
Crop and Soil Environmental Sciences
Grantor dc:publisher
Virginia Tech
Year dc:date.issued
2026

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Hays, Katherine Nicole
Chair dc:contributor.committeechair
  • Maguire, Rory Owen
Committee members dc:contributor.committeemember
  • Pent, Gabriel J.
  • White, William A.
  • Possinger, Angela Ruth

Subjects

dc:subject × 7

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • In Copyright
Language dc:language.iso
en

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Dc Identifier Other
vt_gsexam:46914

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
Virginia Tech
Base URL
vtechworks.lib.vt.edu/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Hays, Katherine Nicole. Winter Bale Grazing versus Sacrifice Paddocks in the Southeastern United States: Impacts on Animal Performance, Economic Viability, and Soil Health. doctoral thesis, Virginia Tech, 2026. https://hdl.handle.net/10919/143147