Victoria University
The Impact of Corporate Social Responsibility on Spa Competitiveness: An Empirical Study of Vietnam
Abstract
dc:description.abstractSpa tourism is a rapidly expanding segment of the global tourism industry and an increasingly important sector in emerging markets. Despite its growth potential, the spa industry faces significant challenges, including intense competition, service inconsistency, workforce capability gaps, and vulnerability to external shocks. While Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) is widely recognised as a strategic mechanism to enhance competitiveness across the broader tourism and hospitality industry, its application within the spa sector remains comparatively under-researched. Research gaps remain in the existing literature regarding the relationship between CSR and competitiveness. Specifically, Gap 1 is the lack of a comprehensive conceptual framework that sufficiently explains the complex relationship between CSR and spa competitiveness. In more detail, there remains a theoretical gap regarding the specific mechanisms—such as RI, OrgR, and CSP—that translate CSR into sustained competitiveness, particularly in underexplored, non-Western contexts (e.g., Vietnam). Gap 2 is the lack of consistent findings regarding the role of Innovation, Resilience, and Sustainability Performance in the CSR-Competitiveness relationship. Gap 3 is the lack of research in comparing the efficacy of CSR-to-competitiveness pathways between SMEs and large enterprises. To address these gaps, the overall aim of this study is to develop a conceptual framework to evaluate the impact of CSR on spa competitiveness, using Vietnam as the empirical context. To achieve this aim, the study established three specific research objectives: (i) to explore characteristics of Vietnam's spa tourism including trends and strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats (SWOT) especially the role of CSR, Responsible Innovation (RI), Organisational Resilience (OrgR), Corporate Sustainability Performance (CSP) in enhancing spa competitiveness; (ii) to examine the relationship between CSR and RI, OrgR, CSP, and Spa Competitiveness; and (iii) to evaluate the differences between Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) and large spas regarding the relationship between CSR, RI, OrgR, CSP, and Spa Competitiveness. Grounded in the Resource-Based View (RBV) and Dynamic Capability Theory (DCT), this study develops a comprehensive conceptual framework to examine how CSR influences spa competitiveness through three mediating mechanisms: RI, OrgR, and CSP, with firm size acting as a moderating variable. A convergent mixed-methods approach was employed. To explore the characteristics, trends, and SWOT factors of Vietnam's spa industry, particularly the role of CSR and its mediators, qualitative data were obtained from 12 semi-structured interviews with spa managers and industry experts and analysed through thematic analysis. Quantitative data were collected from 786 spa managers and employees across major Vietnamese cities and analysed using PLS-SEM to examine the interrelationships of CSR, RI, OrgR, CSP and Spa Competitiveness and the moderating effect of firm size (SME and large spas) on these relationships. The qualitative findings identify four major themes: (1) CSR activities in spas, (2) impact and effectiveness of CSR, (3) innovation in spa operations, and (4) resilience. These findings provide contextual evidence explaining how CSR initiatives enhance innovation and resilience capabilities, thereby fostering sustainability performance and reinforcing competitiveness. The quantitative results suggest that CSR has both direct and indirect positive effects on spa competitiveness. Specifically, CSR significantly enhances RI, OrgR, and CSP, which in turn strengthen competitiveness. Mediation analyses confirm that RI, CSP, and OrgR serve as significant transmission mechanisms linking CSR to competitive outcomes. For the moderating effect of firm size, the results reveal that firm size functions as a critical boundary condition at the initial “input” stage of CSR implementation, yet it ceases to be a significant moderating factor at the “throughput” stage of capability execution. This research makes several major theoretical contributions to the strategic management and sustainable tourism literature. First, it significantly extends the Resource-Based View (RBV) and Dynamic Capability Theory (DCT) by simultaneously integrating RI, OrgR, and CSP within a single structural model. This addresses a critical knowledge gap by unpacking the “black box” of mediating mechanisms, explaining precisely how foundational ethical investments are transformed into sustained market superiority. Second, it empirically demonstrates CSR as a dynamic capability driver rather than merely a reputational mechanism, proving that social responsibility acts as a strategic asset enabling firms to proactively adapt to volatile, crisis-prone environments. Third, it identifies firm size as a critical boundary condition shaping CSR effectiveness. This challenges the monolithic assumption that large enterprises universally outperform smaller ones in sustainability, introducing dynamic capabilities as a “throughput equaliser” for SMEs. Fourth, it extends CSR–competitiveness research into the underexplored spa tourism sector in an emerging market context, providing a highly transferable blueprint for capability-building in specialised, experience-driven niche markets. Practically, this study offers actionable, capability-driven strategies for spa managers and policymakers. For spa managers, the findings recommend transitioning from generic CSR practices to targeted operational actions, such as leveraging local supplier networks to co-create responsible innovations, deploying mobile-first digital tools for immediate crisis responsiveness, and implementing peer-to-peer cross-training to ensure workforce flexibility. For small and medium-sized enterprise (SME) spas specifically, the findings suggest capitalising on their inherent structural agility and community proximity to achieve competitiveness without relying on the capital-intensive strategies of large resorts. Furthermore, for policymakers, the study advocates for 'capability-oriented' and 'size-sensitive' frameworks, including regulatory sandboxes to support sustainable innovations and targeted crisis-management training to build industry-wide resilience. The study also demonstrates generalisability. While empirically grounded in Vietnam, the theoretical framework – based on RBV and DCT – can provide transferability to other emerging tourism markets and service industries where sustainability, innovation, and resilience are central to competitiveness. Future research should adopt longitudinal designs to examine long-term causal effects, conduct cross-country comparative studies, explore additional moderators such as leadership style and digital capability, incorporate multi-stakeholder perspectives, and refine sustainability performance measurement using objective indicators. Overall, this research advances theoretical understanding of how CSR contributes to spa competitiveness and provides practical insights for spa managers and policymakers seeking to leverage CSR as a strategic resource in emerging tourism economies.
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- phd
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- Victoria University
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2026
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Ngo, Chi Tam
Subjects
dc:subject × 1Rights
- Language dc:language
- en
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- DOI dc:identifier.doi
- https://doi.org/10.26196/vuir.vu.edu.au.00050481