Back to search

University of Washington

Variation in perceptions of the stormwater social-ecological system in Puget Sound: insights for management across the land-sea interface.

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

Managing social-ecological systems that benefit both people and nature is the central challenge of natural resource management. Integrating multiple perspectives into decision-making is considered to add flexibility to social-ecological systems because diversity reduces rigidity, represents multiple perspectives, and promotes adaptability. Our objective was to assess expert perceptions of the structure, content, and function of the Puget Sound stormwater social-ecological system. To evaluate these differences, we interviewed Puget Sound stormwater experts to collect Fuzzy Cognitive Maps. Using graph theory indices to characterize the structure of expert maps, we compared experts among demographic or employment attributes. To analyze whether experts varied in the maps' content, we characterized the maps using an SES framework: resource system, resource units, actors, and governance system (Ostrom, 2009). We then combined expert maps to run scenarios on how differences of experts maps' structure and content could impact the outcomes of different management options. Results showed that there were similarities and differences in expert maps' content and structure, which impacted future management scenarios' outcomes. These differing outcomes in scenarios could be a conflict of interest due to focusing on different parts of the Ostrom framework. This paper can contribute to the literature while yielding valuable information immediately for policymakers, stormwater directors, and other stakeholders interested in stormwater management while we continue research to gain a better understanding of this complex social-ecological system. Calling on experts to aid decision-makers in conservation is widely used and often successful in evaluating recovery actions to ensure the effective and efficient use of resources. In the absence of quantitative data, expert elicitation has been used to describe qualitatively, the relationships between threats and management objectives. In this study, we interviewed Puget Sound stormwater experts about ‘how much stormwater needs to be treated to ensure a healthy Puget Sound?’ The goal is to understand the amount of management intervention required to make significant progress toward an improved social-ecological-system. Results showed that there was not a consensus on how much stormwater reduction was needed. We then conducted a content analysis that identified three broad themes of different barriers across experts’ inability to answer the ‘how much’ question: 1) the existence of multiple management objectives; 2) varying spatial scales of objectives; and, 3) uncertainty about what components of stormwater threaten management objectives. While we did not find a consensus, our work clarifies the current extent of scientific uncertainty that can guide management action and scientific research. Facing these hard truths and finding a clear direction will need to occur for the stormwater implementation plan to secure a healthy Puget Sound future.

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • O'Connor, Caitlyn Bay
Advisor dc:contributor.advisor
  • Levin, Phillip

Subjects

dc:subject × 8

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • none
Language dc:language.iso
en_US

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Handle dc:identifier.uri
http://hdl.handle.net/1773/46013

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Washington
Base URL
digital.lib.washington.edu/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

O'Connor, Caitlyn Bay. Variation in perceptions of the stormwater social-ecological system in Puget Sound: insights for management across the land-sea interface.. 2020. http://hdl.handle.net/1773/46013