Back to search

University of Washington

The guise of deliberation: a rhetorical criticism of arguments in the Yucca Mountain site authorization controversy

Abstract

dc:description.abstract

A contemporary controversy in the United States over nuclear waste concerns the 2001 decision to site a national high-level nuclear waste repository in Yucca Mountain in Nevada. This dissertation is a rhetorical criticism, specifically and argument evaluation, of the arguments of three important stakeholders: American Indian tribes, Nevadans, and the federal government. Through a close reading of DOE public hearing comments and the federal government's official site authorization documents, this dissertation finds that the process of the Yucca Mountain site authorization is a guise of deliberation in which American Indian arguments are ignored, Nevadan scientific arguments are disregarded, and the federal government employs rhetorical strategies which create a guise of reasonableness and deliberation to cover a primarily justificatory process. In particular, this case study finds that (1) American Indian arguers appeal to differing loci of values, use different forms of argument, and evaluate arguments using different standards than the federal government; (2) scientific argumentation from the public is constrained by conceptions of the relationship between science and the public, which demonstrates the need for a theory of public science that comes from below; and (3) the federal government rhetorically constructs an opposition to the site with American Indians as a third persona which is negated in the text. In addition to evaluating the arguments made by each of the stakeholders, this dissertation also informs our understanding of the process of public participation in the decision-making and the rhetorical manifestations and perpetuation of the phenomenon of radioactive colonization, offers implications for theories of American Indian argument forms and evaluation, offers a theory of public science, and provides suggestions for those involved in the controversy.

Author and committee

dc:creator, dc:contributor.*
Author dc:creator
  • Endres, Danielle

Subjects

dc:subject × 1

Rights

dc:rights
Statement dc:rights
  • Copyright is held by the individual authors.
Language dc:language.iso
en_US

Identifiers

dc:identifier.*
Dc Identifier Other
b54002758
62355980
Thesis 54782

Chain of custody

source
Harvested from
University of Washington
Base URL
digital.lib.washington.edu/server/oai/request
Last updated
2026-11-18
Source record
OAI-PMH GetRecord
citation

Endres, Danielle. The guise of deliberation: a rhetorical criticism of arguments in the Yucca Mountain site authorization controversy. 2005. http://hdl.handle.net/1773/6181