University of Leeds
Agenda Setting and its Positioning Strategies: a study of asymmetries, tensions, frames and organising choices shaping development interventions in Cali, Colombia.
Abstract
dc:description.abstractModernising the global south is not a new project. Yet, the persistent redefinition of existing and new development challenges – from inequalities to climate-change crises – shapes the agreement on the causes of problems, their solutions, and the organisation of concerted action to ensure successful interventions. Simply put, if the definitions of conditions change, some kind of response to that change might be required or demanded. That could happen by pushing for adjustments to the agenda for development – its problems and goals – and also by pressing for reconsidering how those supposed to implement the agenda, such as not-for-profit organisations (NPOs), do so. So, to shed light on this matter, this investigation studied two interconnected phenomena: agenda- setting and organising development interventions in Colombia. This investigation establishes how partner NPOs, in two long-lasting programmes, make sense of the global agenda for development and its re-framing. And how that sense- making interacts with the institutional logics and discourses within the field, leading to choices, compromises and the formulation of tactics, all of which impacted how these partner organisations agreed to tackle social problems in Cali, Colombia. The study of this complex causal relationship – between agenda-setting mechanisms, logics and discourses, and the micro-level organising of interventions – was found to lead to several outcomes, such as a municipal hybrid agenda for modernisation and two micro-level tactics (i.e., flexible problematisation and contribution goals); all these underpinning the rise of two paradoxes (i.e., dislocation and disneyfication). These findings resulted from the analysis of three case studies and 35 interviews with academics and professionals with expertise in designing and implementing interventions, municipal planning and public policy formulation. The analysis of the information gathered was contrasted against 4 development goals and other expectations found in documents generated by UN agencies, Colombian governmental authorities, and accounts presented to international and national funding organisations. The main contributions of this investigation, relevant to the fields of development and public relations, are as follows: a) the identification of the routes through which macro and meso-level agendas reach the micro-level of development intervention, b) establishing the tensions and asymmetries, which are exploited by funding organisations to ensure institutional agendas are adopted regardless of how those agendas relate to local conditions and hence the problems faced by communities in Colombia, c) establishing the marginalisation of local NPOs and, by extension, the communities these organisations represent and d) revealing the agenda-positioning strategies implemented by NPOs operating in the country.
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- Ph.D
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- University of Leeds
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2023
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Hernández Toro, Manuel Eduardo
- Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Meier, Leslie
- Guantai, Kendi
- ORCID person:identifier.orcid
Rights
- Language dc:language.dcterms_iso639_2
- eng