Abstract
dc:description.abstractPURPOSE AND SCOPE: Gender Equality is a human right, and typically considered a good principle when designing development programs. Water, sanitation and Hygiene (WASH) programs often publicly state the importance of gender equality measures through the use of guidelines and policy, but the effectiveness of this documentation is under-researched. This thesis demonstrates the challenges of implementing gender guidance in WASH programs, exploring perceived challenges at a global, national, and community level. Beginning at a global level, the thesis explores commonality in development program evaluations, assessing the level of gender inclusion, querying the need for a sector shift in the way ‘gender’ is written about and investigated. It then reflects on proposed challenges, and contextualises findings, investigating gender guidance incorporation in India’s Swachh Bharat Mission. Inclusion of gender guidance is documented along the chain of implementation, with perceived challenges highlighted by key informants. Finally, the thesis examines the reality for marginalised genders that are recognised by the national constitution in India, but are not recognised in gender guidance. METHODS: This thesis uses a mixed methods approach to investigate the research questions. Open-ended discursive surveys have been used in conjunction with a grey literature review of WASH development program evaluations to assess the level of gender inclusion at an implementation level. Key informant interviews were completed to gauge perceptions of government staff, academics, non-governmental organisation workers and activists in accordance with the intention and curation of gender guidance, and the potential differing implementation results. Community focus groups were also held to assess how marginalised genders not represented in gender guidance are able to access and use sanitation facilities. FINDINGS: A global analysis of international development program evaluations identified discord between industry leading organisations’ public attitudes towards gender equality, and the reality of gender inclusion. Evaluation practices were categorised between insensitive and transformative, with over 50% of the practices categorised at the lowest level of gender sensitivity due to vague language, reprioritised budgets and a lack of active involvement of multiple genders at all levels of programming. Building on the reflections, further investigation of the discord between intention and reality was carried out by examining implementation of the Swachh Bharat Mission. At a national level in India there is recognition of the need for gender guidance, and intention to create programs with an emphasis on gender equality. However, ambiguous accountability at ministerial level creates uncertainty in ownership of gender guidance. This leads to inaccessible funding, minimal organisational and personal accountability, and poor dissemination of guidance. At a community level there is need to end the homogenisation of identities; evidence showed LGBTQ+ people are often misrepresented as ‘Transgender’ due to limited understanding of gender and sexuality. Homogenisation fails to account for intersectional identities, and assumes people fit neatly into discrete categorisation, which is far from reality; even within small sample sizes, there was huge variance in answers around ‘ideal’ sanitation systems and access. The conscious exclusion of complex queer identities in sanitation planning, especially transgender persons, creates inaccessible and inappropriate facilities. Only by including diverse perspectives and prioritising inclusive design can accessible and appropriate facilities be created. IMPLICATIONS: Striving for the use of gender guidance will always encounter challenges in implementation due to prioritisation of other program attributes, poor accountability mechanisms, and minimal associated funding. Being able to separate gender from what is required as a ‘basic’ need enables separation of identity characteristics; if there is limited funding the optional and additional gender guide will be discarded. Moving towards programs with universal design principles that prioritise the needs of people, not of specific homogenised genders, will ensure more sustainable and inclusive outcomes.
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- Ph.D
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- University of Leeds
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Robinson, Hannah Jayne
- Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Evans, Barbara E.
- Hutchings, Paul
- Narayanaswamy, Lata
- Barrington, Dani J.
- ORCID person:identifier.orcid
Rights
- Language dc:language.dcterms_iso639_2
- eng
Identifiers
dc:identifier.*- Dc Identifier Grantnumber
- EP/S022066/1