University of Sheffield
Understanding the role of peer-to-peer accommodation in disrupting the neighbourhood: A new form of gentrification?
Abstract
dc:description.abstractThe development in online transaction platforms has enabled the growth of peer- to-peer (P2P) accommodation services globally. This emergent phenomenon has disrupted traditional tourism and hospitality sectors since the global economic downturn around 2010. Platforms like Airbnb have capitalised on technological advancements and shifts in consumer preferences and for some to democratise lodging choices, sparking considerable academic interest. Such interest principally focuses on how the rise of P2P accommodation fosters urban economic and tourism growth, establishing competition with hotel offerings and tourism practices. The business model has contributed to urban economies whilst also identified as a trigger for a new wave of gentrification through shifting neighbourhood dynamics and property values. The UK has a vibrant and diverse tourism sector and is a leading country in the sharing economy. It appears P2P accommodation, taking housing resources away from the housing system, has potentially aggravated the existing housing crisis in the UK due to the deregulation of short-term rentals. This phenomenon calls for scholars to develop new theoretical frameworks and empirical strategies to better understand the processes and outcomes underpinning the sharing economy in different urban contexts. This research seeks to provide an exploratory examination of the new form of gentrification prompted by P2P accommodation, via a study of three major UK cities. The thesis focuses on three key components. Initially, the spatio-temporal characteristics, rent gap opening, and neighbourhood profiles are analysed. These findings show that Airbnb in the UK revealed a rapid growth in listings since 2015, especially in Greater London, which challenges the housing and long-term rental sectors. Airbnb thrives, notably around central tourist locations and is spreading to the outskirts of major urban centres, showing varied spatial patterns depending on city size. The platform has introduced large rent gaps, with Airbnb revenue surpassing long-term rentals, particularly in central tourist districts. Urban centres such as Greater London and Greater Manchester see the largest rent gap driven by their cultural and international character, with student-heavy locales like Bristol also significantly affected. Secondly, employing repeat sales design and multi-level modelling, it is possible to look at the impact of long-term occupied Airbnb on neighbourhood housing prices at the neighbourhood scale. The approach reveals how Airbnb’s location and effect has a distinct decentralisation gradient. Central urban areas, with their stable housing markets, experience less Airbnb-induced price inflation compared to suburbs where limited housing stock makes them more vulnerable to price hikes due to Airbnb scarcity effects. The penetration of Airbnb into smaller flat properties exerts a greater impact on housing prices than house-type Airbnb, although this also fosters gentrification, eroding traditional residential communities. This intricate pattern also underscores the socio-spatial disparities, where the shock of Airbnb is particularly disruptive in central and deprived areas. Finally, the research explores Airbnb under the COVID-19 pandemic period, focusing on Greater London. Here the Airbnb market experienced a notable contraction, particularly in the central regions, as part-time hosts left and listings in high-income or tourism-reliant areas declined. Professional hosts owning multiple properties weathered the storm adeptly, repositioning their offerings to suburbs and upscale districts to mitigate revenue disruptions. The pandemic altered the dynamics of Airbnb revenue with a new preference for locations offering green spaces and retail amenities. Nonetheless, the presence of high revenues surrounding certain deprived neighbourhoods in the central and western parts of London provides compelling evidence of the perpetuation of gentrification driven by Airbnb. Through these empirical contributions, the thesis offers a new and novel understanding of the disruptions of Airbnb to neighbourhoods and local housing markets and the deepening spatial inequality induced by Airbnb before, during and after the COVID-19 period.
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- Ph.D
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- University of Sheffield
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2024
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Wang, Nan
- Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
-
- Hincks, Stephen
- Hamilton, Ruth
Rights
- Language dc:language.dcterms_iso639_2
- eng