University of Leeds
Producing effective and achievable safety strategies from adverse event investigations in healthcare
Abstract
dc:description.abstractIt is estimated that one in ten patients will experience an ‘adverse event’; that is something going wrong in the way in which care is delivered. These events are often investigated and recommendations made, with the intention of preventing recurrence or improving safety. There are, however, increasing concerns that these recommendations and preceding investigations are not contributing to improved safety, and potentially contributing to safety clutter. The aim of this PhD was to explore how the generation of recommendations might be improved. Three studies were undertaken: 1) a scoping review; 2) an experimental scenario study; and 3) a modified Delphi study. Study 1 (scoping review) highlighted that recommendations tended to focus on individuals’ behaviour rather than latent system deficiencies, with a lack of agreement about how recommendations should be judged for effectiveness. These two findings led onto the subsequent studies. Firstly, given the scoping review findings that investigation recommendations seem to ‘blame’ the actions of individuals, and focus improvement efforts on changing their behaviour, the possibility that cognitive biases of those involved in investigations may play a role in this tendency was explored. Study 2 was an experimental scenario study, designed to examine the impact of outcome bias on judgements of staff responsibility, incident avoidability, importance of investigating and recommendation selection. Outcome bias occurs when the ultimate outcome of a past event is given excessive weight, in comparison to other information, when judging the preceding actions or decisions. The results of this study indicated that outcome bias had significant impact of judgement and responses when investigating incidents, with higher ratings of staff responsibility, importance of investigating and higher likelihood of punitive recommendations when patients came to greater harm. While expertise in safety reduced this impact it did not entirely eliminate it. Secondly, Study 1 findings suggested difficulties in judging recommendations’ quality or effectiveness, and that there was no consistent approach in the literature. Before attempting to improve recommendations, it is first necessary to define what a ‘good recommendation’ is. Study 3 was a modified Delphi study that aimed to achieve consensus on what ‘good’ looks like in investigation and recommendation generation. As recommendations are closely linked to the findings and activities of the investigation, it was decided to attempt to gain consensus on criteria to judge both the quality of an investigation and recommendations. Ninety-two evidenced-based criteria were drafted with the help of an expert steering group. Following three rounds of the Delphi process, consensus was achieved for 92 criteria, which were then ranked by their ratings and level of expert agreement. Further work is needed to understand how these criteria could be used to judge and improve the quality of investigations and recommendations. Taken together, this evidence suggests that the generation of recommendations is a complex, and that the current evidence does not sufficiently describe how this important work is achieved in everyday healthcare practice. What is evident is that despite the increasing awareness of systems factors in the incidence of adverse events, outcome bias is a significant influence on the generation of recommendations and the assignment of responsibility. With the potentially far-reaching impact of cognitive biases on investigations and recommendation generation, further work is needed to examine the impact as well as mitigation strategies. The generation of recommendations is further complicated by the lack of guidance about what best practice might be in the investigation and recommendation generation process. Indeed, cognitive bias identification and mitigation is but one of the criteria formulated from the modified Delphi study. These criteria will be useful in measuring the effectiveness of investigations and recommendations within future research but also for front-line teams in patient safety. However, further research will be needed to understand how these criteria can be operationalised for systematic application by healthcare staff, to improve their processes for learning from patient safety events.
Degree
thesis:*- Name dc:type.qualificationname
- Ph.D
- Level dc:type.qualificationlevel
- doctoral
- Grantor dc:publisher.institution
- University of Leeds
- Year dc:date.issued
- 2025
Author and committee
dc:creator, dc:contributor.*- Author dc:creator
-
- Lea, William Patrick
- Advisors dc:contributor.advisor
-
- O'Hara, Jane
- Lawton, Rebecca
- Vincent, Charles
- ORCID person:identifier.orcid
Rights
- Language dc:language.dcterms_iso639_2
- eng