No description available.

Remedial measures in criminal law are set mainly to eliminate and correct mistakes, which have occurred in the course of the trial. It acts as a review and a remedy of law and legal defects. It can be divided into regular and special ones. Amid the regular remedial measures belong appeal, complaint and protest, to a group of special remedial measures belong apart from a renewal of proceedings, a review of an appeal and a complaint for the breach of law. Renewal of proceedings is a special remedial measure, which brings with itself interference into legal power. Renewal of proceedings with which one can contest only some legitimate decisions, in which criminal prosecution has already finished, is used for a removal of shortcomings in factual findings, because at that time all the decisive facts had not been known and the evidence, which came up only after the former decision has come into legal force. New evidence or facts underlying this extraordinary breach into inalterability and binding of judgments made in criminal proceedings are only the facts that were not part of evidence or survey or were not applied by any of the parties engaged in the proceedings and the only evidence that was not designed nor made by either party during the proceedings. As new evidence can be even used evidence already...

O presente trabalho foca no cabimento do direito superveniente nos recursos excepcionais, a saber: extraordinário e especial. Contudo, reconhece-se e respeita-se os limites impostos pela necessária exigência do prequestionamento, bem como pela estabilização de demanda, determinativa de que, após específico momento processual os elementos subjetivos(partes) e o elementos objetivos(causa de pedir e pedido), restam por inalteráveis. Procura-se, assim, caracterizar os recursos excepcionais, estabelecendo o que há de mais relevante em comum, depois as peculiaridades e hipóteses de cabimento. Ato contínuo, examina-se o prequestionamento e sua vertentes. Coloca-se também o necessário estudo dos elementos que identificam a demanda, isto é, a tríplice identidade, além de, posteriormente, a estabilização da demanda, sua gênese e aplicabilidade atual. Por fim, trata-se da temática proposta, buscando sistematizá-la. Busca-se, assim, conciliar os institutos propostos, para que as partes em litígio, uma vez respeitado o princípio do contraditório, o ato jurídico e o direito adquirido sejam, efetivamente, beneficiados com o ius superveniens / This present study focus on the supervenient law in the exceptionals petitions both extraordinário and especial . However, it is known that there are imposed limits that are included in the prequestioning and also the lawsuit, determined by specific moment of the process when analyzing the subjective elements and the objective elements, that must remains unchangeable. That way, the exceptional petitions can establish, first of all what is the most relevant, then the peculiarities and hypothesis that fits. It is also important to understand the subject to find elements which identify lawsuit, that is the triple identity and also the establishment of the lawsuit, genesis e use nowadays. After all, it is a way of searching searching an ideal system for this approach. At the end, the objective is to bring up together the institute representative, so that the two different areas in a litigation, respecting even the contradictory terms, the law act and also the right acquired, which can be a benefit of the ius superveniens

Action for retrial and for nullity Abstract This diploma thesis deals with action for retrial and for nullity. The aim is to provide a systematic interpretation about both of these institutes and characterize them in a system of extraordinary remedies. Although both of them are regulated in part four chapter two of the Act No. 99/1963 Coll., Civil Procedure Code, as amended, their respective purposes are completely different. Action for retrial serves for a remedy of factual defects as a final decision could not stand due to a fundamental change of facts whereas action for nullity serves for a remedy of important procedural defects which affected court decision itself or proceeding preceding it. Both institutes can challenge a final decision and break the legal certainty brought by it. This diploma thesis contains four chapters. The first of them deals with remedial systems and remedies containing a brief characteristic of individual types of remedial systems and remedies. The second chapter addressing action for retrial and the third chapter dealing with action for nullity represent main parts of the thesis. Division into subchapters is almost identical for both of them and the subchapters cover the following topics: historical development of both institutes, conditions of and grounds for admissibility,...

Submitted by Biblioteca Central (biblioteca@unicap.br) on 2017-11-10T23:01:14Z No. of bitstreams: 1 dissertacao_antonio_goncalves_mota_silveira_neto.pdf: 776137 bytes, checksum: 300b3ebaee2726d96ddb003528c4c6f0 (MD5) / Made available in DSpace on 2017-11-10T23:01:14Z (GMT). No. of bitstreams: 1 dissertacao_antonio_goncalves_mota_silveira_neto.pdf: 776137 bytes, checksum: 300b3ebaee2726d96ddb003528c4c6f0 (MD5) Previous issue date: 2009-06-05 / This present study focus on the supervenient law in the exceptionals petitions both “ extraordinário” and “ especial” . However, it is known that there are imposed limits that are included in the prequestioning and also the lawsuit, determined by specific moment of the process when analyzing the subjective elements and the objective elements, that must remains unchangeable. That way, the exceptional petitions can establish, first of all what is the most relevant, then the peculiarities and hypothesis that fits. It is also important to understand the subject to find elements which identify lawsuit, that is the triple identity and also the establishment of the lawsuit, genesis e use nowadays. After all, it is a way of searching searching an ideal system for this approach. At the end, the objective is to bring up together the institute representative, so that the two different areas in a litigation, respecting even the contradictory terms, the law act and also the right acquired, which can be a benefit of the ius superveniens / O presente trabalho foca no cabimento do direito superveniente nos recursos excepcionais, a saber: extraordinário e especial. Contudo, reconhece-se e respeita-se os limites impostos pela necessária exigência do prequestionamento, bem como pela estabilização de demanda, determinativa de que, após específico momento processual os elementos subjetivos(partes) e o elementos objetivos(causa de pedir e pedido), restam por inalteráveis. Procura-se, assim, caracterizar os recursos excepcionais, estabelecendo o que há de mais relevante em comum, depois as peculiaridades e hipóteses de cabimento. Ato contínuo, examina-se o prequestionamento e sua vertentes. Coloca-se também o necessário estudo dos elementos que identificam a demanda, isto é, a tríplice identidade, além de, posteriormente, a estabilização da demanda, sua gênese e aplicabilidade atual. Por fim, trata-se da temática proposta, buscando sistematizá-la. Busca-se, assim, conciliar os institutos propostos, para que as partes em litígio, uma vez respeitado o princípio do contraditório, o ato jurídico e o direito adquirido sejam, efetivamente, beneficiados com o ius superveniens.

Action for retrial Abstract This diploma thesis deals with issues of action for retrial. Its aim is to describe contemporary form of this extraordinary remedy how as it is regulated in the act No. 99/1963 Coll., Civil Procedure Code., carry out its comparison with Slovakian regulation and with the substantive intent of the Civil Procedure Code and also submit solution to some aspects of possible future regulation. The thesis is divided into five chapters. The intention of the first chapter was to introduce basic terms and system, which includes action for retrial is its part. Part of this chapter is also dedicated to brief historical excursion, which tackles development of remedies since 1781 until publication of substantive intent of the Civil Procedure Code in the 2020 version. The second chapter covers the action for retrial itself. Its subchapters gradually analyse individual elements of this extraordinary remedy in the form of admissibility, the grounds for bringing the action, persons entitled to bring action, time limits, particulars of the action, proceedings and decisions on it, costs of the proceedings and court fees, as well as the issues of the status of action for retrial among other extraordinary remedies. The third chapter concentrates on comparing the Slovakian Civil Procedure Code with...

The subject of my thesis is the Action for a new trial and action for a mistrial. The purpose of this thesis is to characterize these actions from point of view of their exceptionality as the extraordinary remedies, to compare their common and different features and to suggest the possible future legislation. The thesis is composed of seven chapters. The aim of the firts and the second chapter is to briefly characterize the redress procedures, the individual repair systems and the remedies from the general point of view, from which these two actions are patterned. The following chapter briefly describes the extraordinary remedies from the point of view of their characteristic signs and their representation in the present legislation. I am also mentioning the two important amendment of civil procedure, which are responsible of creation the system of remedies as we know it in present form in this chapter. The fourth chapter is divided into nine subchapters and dealing with the analyses of the action for a new trial. The purpose of each subchapter is not only to commonly charecterize the action for a new trial, but also to explain under what circumstances is the action for a new trial unallowable, which subjects are justified to sue, which requisites the action for a new trial has to include, and...

[pt] O Judiciary Act, aprovado em 1925, tornou o writ of certiorari a principal forma de acesso à Suprema Corte dos Estados Unidos da América. Como seu exame de admissibilidade, diferentemente dos recursos ordinários, é feito discricionariamente (ou seja, não é tido como um direito da parte), os membros daquele tribunal passaram a escolher as questões constitucionais que estariam a merecer sua consideração. Esta solução foi adotada como forma de amenizar a carga de trabalho dos Justices, responsáveis pela uniformização do direito federal aplicável em todo o país, e trouxe importantes conseqüências ao papel desempenhado por eles no sistema jurídico-político estadunidense. A análise do writ of certiorari constitui o objeto da primeira parte desta dissertação, cuja relevância justifica-se pela aprovação, no final de 2004, da Emenda Constitucional nº 45, que concedeu ao Supremo Tribunal Federal poder semelhante, consistente na possibilidade de rejeição de recursos extraordinários por ausência de repercussão geral das questões constitucionais ali discutidas. A análise das conseqüências da ampliação do escopo do writ of certiorari e das modificações que acarretou na atuação da Suprema Corte norte-americana destina-se a fornecer elementos concretos para que se possa ao menos tentar prever o impacto que a repercussão geral - ainda não regulamentada pelo legislador ordinário - poderá ter sobre o Supremo Tribunal Federal e sobre o recurso extraordinário. / [en] The Judiciary Act, adopted in 1925 in the United States of America, transformed the Writ of Certiorari into the main form of appeal to the U.S. Supreme Court, as it enabled the examination of admissibility, as opposed to the mandatory appeal, to be performed discretionarily (i.e. examination is not deemed a right of the Party). Therefore, members of the U.S. Supreme Court now select which particular constitutional issues deserve their consideration. This solution, adopted as a way to minimize the workload of the Justices responsible for making uniform federal laws applicable throughout the U.S., brought significant consequences to the role played by those Justices in the American legal and political system. An analysis of the Writ of Certiorari is the object of the first part of this monograph. Its relevance is straightforwardly justified by the approval, in late 2004, of the Brazilian Constitutional Amendment no. 45, which grants our Federal Supreme Court a similar power, i.e. the chance to dismiss extraordinary legal remedies on account of the constitutional issues therein discussed lacking General Repercussion. Finally, an analysis of the writ of certiorari scope and of the relevant changes introduced in the U.S. Supreme Court´s routine attempts to put forward concrete elements toward an incipient anticipation of the impacts which General Repercussion should eventually produce on the Brazilian Supreme Court as well as on extraordinary legal remedies themselves. (Our regular legislators have not yet reviewed General Repercussion in detail, though.)

The aim of the present dissertation is to provide the fullest possible legal analysis of the complaint against a violation of law, including its historical and international context, and to endeavour to reflect critically on its current application in practice. In the author's approach, the review of criminal cases on the basis of the files prior to a possible application of this legal remedy is an indispensable object of study. Among other things, the work thoroughly analyzes the applicable grounds for the complaint against a violation of law, its purpose and role in the whole system of extraordinary remedies, and it describes the course as well as the specifics of the Supreme Court proceedings. Standard and optional methods of interpretation are complemented by an empirical examination of the sample of 80 complaints submitted to the Supreme Court, which is aimed at identifying and classifying the alleged flaws and the extent to which there might be an overlap with extraordinary appeal (dovolání). The chosen topic appears to be very timely with regard to the ongoing preparatory legislative work on the new Criminal Procedure Code. The descriptive passages are accompanied by the author's opinions on selected decisions of the Supreme Court and the deficiencies of the current legislation. Taken...

University of Macau / Faculty of Law