Thesis (PhD)--Stellenbosch University, 2011. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: Pantothenate kinase (PanK) enzymes catalyze the first reaction in the five step biosynthesis of the essential cofactor coenzyme A. Enzymes representing each of the three identified PanK types have been studied and characterized and these PanK types exhibits a unique diversity between different organisms, therefore highlighting them as potential drug targets. In this study the type III PanK of specifically pathogenic bacteria were characterized with the goal of developing type-specific inhibitors. Several questions about the activity of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis enzyme was answered, which addresses the contradicting results achieved in related PanK studies performed to date. Furthermore the first inhibitors, that are competitive to the pantothenate binding site, were designed, synthesized and tested against the Pseudomonas aeruginosa enzyme. This resulted in the discovery of the most potent inhibitors of the type III PanKs to date. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Pantoteensuurkinase-ensiem (PanK) kataliseer die eerste stap in die vyf stap biosintese van die lewens belangrike en essensiële kofaktor, koënsiem A (KoA). Die meerderheid patogeniese bakterieë, waaronder die organisme wat tuberkulose veroorsaak, besit ‘n unieke vorm van die PanK-ensiem. Gevolglik word hierdie ensieme as belangrike teikens vir die ontwikkeling van antibakteriële middels beskou. In hierdie studie is die aktiwiteit van die Mycobacterium tuberculosis ensiem gekarakteriseer wat verskeie teenstrydige bevindings oor hierdie ensiem beantwoord het. Verder is nuwe inhibitore vir die Pseudomonas aeruginosa ensiem ontwerp, gesintetiseer en getoets. Die beste inhibitore van hierdie tipe ensiem tot op hede is sodoende geïdentifiseer.

Tuberculosis (TB), caused by Mycobacterium tuberculosis, has long been the scourge of humanity, claiming millions of lives. It is the most devastating infectious disease of the world in terms of mortality as well as morbidity (WHO, 2009). The lack of a uniformly effective vaccine against TB, the development of resistance in the Mycobacterium tuberculosis against the present antitubercular drugs and its synergy with AIDS has made the situation very alarming. This therefore necessitates a search for new antitubercular drugs as well as the identification of new and unexplored drug targets (Broun et aI., 1992). Coenzyme A is an essential cofactor for all organisms and is synthesized in organisms from pantothenate by a universally conserved pathway (Spry et al., 2008; Sassetti and Rubin, 2003). The first enzyme of the pathway, pantothenate kinase catalyzes the most important step of the biosynthetic process, being the first committed step of CoA biosynthesis and the one at which all the regulation takes place (Gerdes et aI., 2002) This thesis describes the successful cloning of PanK from Mycobacterium tuberculosis, its expression in E. coli, single step affinity purification, and complete biochemical and biophysical characterization. In this work, pantothenol, a widely believed inhibitor of pantothenate kinase, has been shown to act as a substrate for the mycobacterial pantothenate kinase. Further it was shown that the product, 4'phosphopantothenol, thus formed, inhibited the next step of the CoA biosynthesis pathway in vitro. The study was extended to find outthe fate of pantothenol inside the cell and it was demonstrated that the CoA biosynthetic enzymes metabolized the latter into the pantothenol derivative of CoA which then gets incorporated into acyl carrier protein. Lastly, it was decisively shown that pantothenate kinase is not only regulated by feedback inhibition by CoA but, also regulated through feed forward stimulation by Fructose 1, 6 biphosphate (FBP), a glycolytic intermediate. The binding site of FBP was determined by docking and mutational studies of MtPanK. Chapter 1 presents a brief survey of the literature related to Coenzyme A biosynthesis pathway and describes the objective of the thesis. It also presents a history of TB and briefly reviews literature describing TB as well as the life cycle, biology, survival strategy, mode of infection and the metabolic pathways operational in the TB parasite, Mycobacterium tuberculosis. The chapter details the enzymes involved in CoA biosynthesis pathway from various organims. Chapter 2 In this chapter, cloning of the ORF (Rv1092c), annotated as pantothenate kinase in the Tuberculist database (http://genolist.pasteur.frfTubercuList), its expression in E. coli and purification using affinity chromatography has been described. Protein identity was confirmed by MALDI-TOF and by its ability to complement the pantothenate kinase temperature sensitive mutant, DV70. This chapter also illustrates the oligomeric status of MtPanK in solution and describes the biochemical characterization of MtPanK by means of two different methods, spectrophotometrically by a coupled assay and calorimetrically by using Isothermal Titration Calorimetry. Feedback inhibition of MtPanK by CoA is also discussed in this chapter. Chapter 3 describes the biophysical characterization of MtPanK. It discusses the enthalpy (~H) and free energy change (~G) accompanying the binding of a non-hydrolysable analogue of ATP; CoA; acetyl CoA and malonyl-CoA to MtPanK. The chapter details the energetics observed upon ATP binding to pantothenate-saturated MtPanK further elucidating the order of the reaction. This chapter also describes the various strategies which were designed and tested to remove CoA from the enzyme as the latter is always purified from the cell in conjunction with CoA. Validation of these strategies for complete CoA removal (by studying the n value from ITC studies) is further described. Chapter 4 discusses the interaction of the well-studied inhibitor of pantothenate kinases from other sources (e.g. the malarial parasite), pantothenol, with the mycobacterial enzyme. In order to investigate the interaction of this compound with MtPanK, its effect on the kinetic reaction carried out by the enzyme was studied by several methods. Surprisingly, a new band corresponding to 4'phosphopantothenol appeared when the reaction mix of MtPanK with pantothenol and ATP was separated on TLC. The identity of the new spot was confirmed by mass spectrometry analyses of the MtPanK reaction mixture.. These findings established the fact that pantothenol is a substrate of pantothenate kinase. To delve deeper into the mechanism of interaction of this compound with the enzymes of the coenzyme A biosynthesis pathway, the ability of pantothenol to serve as a substrate for the next step of the pathway, MtCoaBC was studied. Using various approaches it was established that pantothenol is actually a substrate for the MtPanK and the inhibition observed earlier (Saliba et aI., 2005) is actually due to the inability of CoaBC to utilize 4' -phosphopantothenol as substrate. Chapter 5 takes the story from Chapter 4 further detailing the effects of pantothenol on cultures of E. coli and M. smegmatis. I observed that pantothenol does not inhibit the culture of E. coli or M. smegmatis. So, further studies were carried out to know the fate of pantothenol once it is converted into 4'phosphopantothenoi. Since, the next enzyme of the pathway does not utilize 4'phosphopantothenol, I checked the further downstream enzyme of the pathway, CoaD, and found that it converts 4'-phosphopantothenol to thepantothenol derivative of dephospho-CoA. The next enzyme of the pathway, CoaE, took up this pantothenol derivative of dephospho-CoA as a substrate and converted it to the pantothenol derivative of CoA which was then transferred to apo-ACP by holo-ACP synthase. The holo-ACP thus synthesized enters into the dedicated pathway of fatty acid synthesis. Extensive investigations have been carried out on the regulation of pantothenate kinases, by the product of the pathway, Coenzyme A and its thioesters, xx establishing the latter as the feedback regulators of these enzymes. In order to determine if the cell employs mechanisms to sense available carbon sources and consequently modulate its coenzyme A levels by regulating activity of the enzymes involvedin CoA biosynthesis, glycolytic intermediates were tested against MtPanK for their possible role in the regulation of MtPanK activity. Chapter 6 details my identification of a novel regulator of MtPanK activity, fructose-I, 6-bisphosphate (FBP), a glycolytic intermediate, which enhances the MtPanK catalyzed phosphorylation of pantothenate by three fold. Further, the possible mechanisms through which FBP mediates MtPanK activation are also discussed. This chapter also describes the experiments carried out to identify the binding site of FBP on MtPariK.Interestingly, docking of FBP on MtPanK revealed that FBP binds close to the ATP binding site on the enzyme with one of its phosphates overlapping with the 3'~phosphate of CoA thereby validating its competitive binding relative to CoA on MtPanK. Based on these observations I propose that the binding of FBP to MtPanK lowers the activation energy of pantothenate phosphorylation by PanK. Chapter 7 presents a summary of the findings of this work. Coenzyme A biosynthesis pathway harbors immense potential in the development of drug against many communicable diseases, thanks to its essentiality for the pathogens and the differences between the pathogen and host CoA biosynthetic enzymes. The work done in this thesis extensively characterizes the first committed enzyme of the CoA biosynthetic pathway, pantothenate kinase, from Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MtPanK). The thesis also deals with the fate of a known inhibitor of PanK and proves it as a substrate for MtPanK. Finally this thesis describes a new link between glycolysis and CoA biosynthesis. Biotin, like coenzyme A, is another essential cofactor required by several enzymes in critical metabolic pathways. De novo synthesis of this critical metabolite has been reported only in plants and microorganisms. Therefore targeting the synthesis of biotin in the tubercular pathogen is another effective means of handicapping the tubercle pathogen. During the course of my studies, I also investigated the mycobacterial biotin biosynthesis pathway, studying the first enzyme of the pathway, 7-keto-8-aminopelargonic acid (KAPA) synthase (bioF) in extensive detail. Appendix 1 elucidates the kinetic properties of 7-keto-8aminopelargonic acid synthase (bioF) from Mycobacterium tuberculosis and proves beyond doubt that D-alanine which has previously been reported to act as a competitive inhibitor for the B. sphaericus enzyme (Ploux et al., 1999), is actually a substrate for the mycobacterial bioF.

The current, grim world-TB scenario, with TB being the single largest infectious disease killer, warrants a more effective approach to tackle the deadly pathogen, Mycobacterium tuberculosis. The deadly synergy of this pathogen with HIV and the emergence of drugresistant strains of the organism present a challenge for disease treatment (Russell et al., 2010). Thus, there is a pressing need for newer drugs with faster killing-kinetics which can claim both the actively-multiplying and latent forms of this pathogen causing the oldest known disease to man. This thesis entitled “Mechanistic and Regulatory Aspects of the Mycobacterium tuberculosis Dephosphocoenzyme A Kinase” describes one such potential drug target, which holds promise in future drug development, in detail. The development of efficacious antimycobacterials now requires previously unexplored pathways of the pathogen and cofactor biosynthesis pathways present a good starting point. Therefore, the mycobacterial Coenzyme A (CoA) biosynthesis was chosen for investigation, with the last enzyme of this pathway, dephosphocoenzyme A kinase (CoaE) which was shown to be essential for M. tuberculosis survival, as the focus of the present study (Sassetti et al., 2003). This thesis presents a detailed biochemical and biophysical characterization of the enzymatic mechanism of mycobacterial CoaE, highlighting several hitherto-unknown, unique features of the enzyme. Mutagenic studies described herein have helped identify the critical residues of the kinase involved in substrate recognition, binding and catalysis. Further, a role has been assigned to the UPF0157 domain of unknown function found in the mycobacterial CoaE as well as in several organisms throughout the living kingdom. Detailed insights into the regulatory characteristics of this enzyme from this work further our current understanding of the regulation of the universal CoA biosynthetic pathway and call for the attribution of a greater role to the last enzyme in pathway regulation than has been previously accredited. The thesis begins with a survey of the current literature available on tuberculosis and where we stand today in our fight against this dreaded pathogen. Chapter 1 details the characteristic features of the causative organism M. tuberculosis, briefly describing its unique genome and the cellular envelope which the organism puts forward as a tough shield to its biology. This is followed by a brief description of the infection cycle in the host, the pathogen-host interplay in the lung macrophages, the deadly alliance of the disease with HIV and our current drug arsenal against tuberculosis. Further, emphasizing on the need for newer, faster-acting anti-mycobacterials, Chapter 1 presents the rationale for choosing the mycobacterial coenzyme A biosynthetic pathway as an effective target for newer drugs. A detailed description of our current understanding of the five steps constituting the pathway follows, including a comparison of all the five enzymatic steps between the human host and the pathogen. This chapter also sets the objectives of the thesis, describing the choice of the last enzyme of the mycobacterial CoA biosynthesis, dephosphocoenzyme A kinase, for detailed investigation. As described in Chapter 1, the mycobacterial CoaE is vastly different from its human counterpart in terms of its domain organization and regulatory features and is therefore a good target for future drug development. In this thesis, Rv1631, the probable mycobacterial dephosphocoenzyme A kinase annotated in the Tuberculist database (http://genolist.pasteur.fr/TubercuList), has been unequivocally established as the last enzyme of the tubercular CoA biosynthesis through several independent assays detailed in Chapter 2. The gene was cloned from the mycobacterial genomic DNA, expressed in E. coli and the corresponding recombinant protein purified via a single-step affinity purification method. The mechanistic details of the enzymatic reaction phosphorylating dephosphocoenzyme A (DCoA) to the ubiquitous cofactor, Coenzyme A, have been described in this chapter which presents a detailed biochemical and biophysical characterization of the mycobacterial enzyme, highlighting its novel features as well as unknown properties of this class of enzymes belonging to the Nucleoside Tri-Phosphate (NTP) hydrolase superfamily. The kinetics of the reaction have been biochemically elucidated via four separate assays and the energetics of the enzyme-substrate and enzymeproduct interactions have been detailed by isothermal titration Calorimetry (ITC). Further details on the phosphate donor specificity of the kinase and the order of substrate binding to the enzyme provide a complete picture of the enzymatic mechanism of the mycobacterial dephosphocoenzyme A kinase. Following on the leads generated in Chapter 2 on the unexpected strong binding of CTP to the enzyme but its inability to serve as a phosphate donor to CoaE, enzymatic assays described in Chapter 3 helped in the identification of a hitherto unknown, novel regulator of the last enzyme of CoA biosynthesis, the cellular metabolite CTP. This chapter outlines the remarkable interplay between the regulator, CTP and the leading substrate, dephosphocoenzyme A, possibly employed by the cell to modulate enzymatic activity. The interesting twist to the regulatory mechanisms of CoaE added by the involvement of various oligomeric forms of the enzyme and the influence of the regulator and the leading substrate on the dynamic equilibrium between the trimer and the monomer is further detailed. This reequilibration of the oligomeric states of the enzyme effected by the ligands and its role in activity regulation is further substantiated by the fact that CoaE oligomerization is not cysteine-mediated. Further, the effects of the cellular metabolites on the enzyme have been corroborated by limited proteolysis, CD and fluorescence studies which helped elucidate the conformational changes effected by CTP and DCoA on the enzyme. Thus, the third chapter discusses the novel regulatory features employed by the pathogen to regulate metabolite flow through a critical biosynthetic pathway. Results presented in this chapter highlight the fact that greater importance should be attributed to the last step of CoA biosynthesis in the overall pathway regulation mechanisms than has been previously accorded. The availability of only three crystal structures for a critical enzyme like dephosphocoenzyme A kinase (those from Escherichia. coli, Haemophilus influenzae and Thermus thermophilus) is indeed surprising (Obmolova et al., 2001; O’Toole et al., 2003; Seto et al., 2005). In search of a structural basis for the dynamic regulatory interplay between the leading substrate, DCoA and the regulator, CTP, a computational approach was adopted. Interestingly, the mycobacterial enzyme, unlike its other counterparts from the prokaryotic kingdom, is a bi-domain protein of which the C-terminal domain has no assigned function. Thus both the N- and C-terminal domains were independently modeled, stitched together and energy minimized to generate a three-dimensional picture of the mycobacterial dephosphocoenzyme A kinase, as described in Chapter 4. Ligand-docking analyses and a comprehensive analysis of the interactions of each ligand with the enzyme, in terms of the residues interacted with and the strength of the interaction, presented in this chapter provide interesting insights into the CTP-mediated regulation of CoaE providing a final confirmation of the enzymatic inhibition effected by CTP. These homology modeling and ligand-docking studies reveal that CTP binds the enzyme at the site overlapping with that occupied by the leading substrate, thereby potentially obscuring the active site and preventing catalysis. Further, very close structural homology of the modeled full-length enzyme to uridylmonophosphate/cytidylmonophosphate kinases, deoxycytidine kinases and cytidylate kinases from several different sources, with RMSD values in the range of 2.8-3 Å further lend credence to the strong binding of CTP detailed in Chapter 2 and the regulation of enzymatic activity described in Chapter 3. Computational analyses on the mycobacterial CoaE detailed in this chapter further threw up some interesting features of dephosphocoenzyme A kinases, such as the universal DXD motif in these enzymes, which appears to play a crucial role in catalysis as has been assessed in the next chapter. It is interesting to note that the P-loop-containing nucleoside monophosphate kinases (NMPK), with which the dephosphocoenzyme A kinases share significant homology, have three catalytic domains, the nucleotide-binding domain, the acceptor substrate-binding domain and the lid domain. Computational analyses detailed in Chapter 4 including the structural and sequential homology studies, helped in the delineation of the three domains in the mycobacterial enzyme as well as highly conserved residues potentially involved in crucial roles for substrate binding and catalysis. Therefore important residues from all three domains of the mycobacterial CoaE were chosen for mutagenesis to study their contributions to catalysis. Conservative and non-conservative replacements of these residues detailed in Chapter 5 helped in the identification of crucial residues involved in phosphate donor, ATP binding (Lys14 and Arg140); leading substrate, DCoA binding (Leu113); stabilization of the phosphoryl transfer reaction (Asp32 and Arg140) and catalysis (Asp32). Thus, the results reported here present a first attempt to identify the previously unknown functional roles of highly conserved residues in dephosphocoenzyme A kinases. Chapter 5 also delineates the dependence of this kinase on the divalent cation, magnesium, for catalysis, describing a comparison of the kinetic activity by the wild type and the mutants, in the presence and absence of Mg2+. Therefore, this chapter presents a thorough molecular dissection of the roles played by crucial amino acids of the protein and the results herein can serve as a good starting point for targeted drug development approaches. As described above, another unusual characteristic of the mycobacterial CoaE is the fact that it carries a domain of unknown function, UPF0157, C-terminal to the N-terminal dephosphocoenzyme A kinase domain. The function of this unique C-terminal domain carried by the mycobacterial CoaE has been explored in Chapter 6. The failure of the Nterminal domain (NTD) to be expressed and purified in the soluble fraction in the absence of a domain at its C-terminus (either the mycobacterial CoaE CTD or GST from the pETGEXCT vector) pointed out a possible chaperonic activity for the CTD. A universal chaperonic activity by this domain in the cell was ruled out by carrying out established chaperone assays with insulin, abrin and -crystallin. In order to delineate the CTD sequence involved in the NTD-specific chaperoning activity, deletion mutagenesis helped establish the residues 35-50 (KIACGHKALRVDHIG) of the CTD in the N-terminal domain-specific assistance in folding. Chapter 6 further details the several other potential roles of the mycobacterial CTD probed, including the 4’-phosphopantethienyl transfer, SAM-dependent methyltransferase activity, activation of the NTD via phospholipids among others. Thus the results presented in this chapter are a first attempt at investigating the role of this domain found in several unique architectures in several species across the living kingdom. Chapter 7 is an attempt to stitch together and summarize the results presented in all the preceding chapters, giving an overview of our present understanding of the mycobacterial CoaE and its novel features.

Pantothenate kinase (PanK) is an ubiquitous and essential enzyme that catalyzes the first step in the universal Coenzyme (CoA) biosynthesis pathway. In this step, pantothenate (Vitamin B5) is converted to 4′-phosphopantothenate, which subsequently forms CoA in four enzymatic steps. In bacteria, three types of PanK’s have been identified which exhibit wide variations in their distribution, mechanisms of regulation and affinity for substrates. Type I PanK is a key regulatory enzyme in the CoA biosynthesis pathway and its activity is feedback regulated by CoA and its thioesters. As part of a major programme on mycobacterial proteins in this laboratory, structural studies on type I PanK from Mycobacterium tuberculosis (MtPanK) was initiated and the structure of this enzyme in complex with a CoA derivative has been reported earlier. To further elucidate the structural basis of the enzyme action of MtPanK, several crystal structures of the enzyme in complex with different ligands have been determined in the present study. In conjunction to this, solution studies on the enzyme were also carried out. The structures were solved using the well-established techniques of protein X-ray crystallography. The hanging drop vapour diffusion method was used for crystallization in all cases. The X-ray intensity data were collected using a MAR Research imaging plate system mounted on a Rigaku RU200 and Bruker-AXS Microstar Ultra II rotating anode X-ray generator. The data were processed using the HKL and MOSFLM and SCALA from the CCP4 suite. The structures were solved by the molecular replacement method using the program AMoRe and PHASER. Structure refinements were carried out using the programs CNS and REFMAC. Model building was carried out using COOT and the refined structures were validated using PROCHECK and MOLPROBITY. Secondary structure was assigned using DSSP, structural superpositions were made using ALIGN and buried surface area was calculated using NACCESS. Solution studies on CoA binding and catalytic activity were carried out using Isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC). To start with, the crystal structures of the complexes of MtPanK were determined with (a) citrate, (b) the non-hydrolysable ATP analog AMPPCP and pantothenate (initiation complex), (c) ADP and phosphopantothenate resulting from phosphorylation of pantothenate by ATP in the crystal (end complex), (d) ATP and ADP, each with half occupancy, resulting from a quick soak of crystals in ATP (intermediate complex), (e) CoA, (f) ADP prepared by soaking and co-crystallization, which turned out to have identical structures and (g) ADP and pantothenate. Unlike in the case of the homologous E.coli enzyme (EcPanK), AMPPCP and ADP occupied different, though overlapping, locations in the respective complexes; the same was true of pantothenate in the initiation complex and phosphopantothenate in the end complex. The binding site of MtPanK was found to be substantially preformed while that of EcPanK exhibited considerable plasticity. The difference in the behavior of the E.coli and M.tuberculosis enzymes could be explained in terms of changes in local structure resulting from substitutions. It is unusual for two homologous enzymes to exhibit such striking differences in action and the changes in the locations of ligands exhibited by M.tuberculosis pantothenate kinase are remarkable and novel. The movement of ligands exhibited by MtPanK during enzyme action appeared to indicate that the binding site of the enzyme was less specific for a particular type of ligand than EcPanK. Kinetic measurements of enzyme activity showed that MtPanK had dual substrate specificity for ATP and GTP, unlike the enzyme from E.coli which showed a much higher specificity for ATP. A molecular explanation for the difference in the specificities of the two homologous enzymes was provided by the crystal structures of the complexes of the M. tuberculosis enzyme with (1) GMPPCP and pantothenate (2) GDP and phosphopantothenate (3) GDP (4) GDP and pantothenate (5) AMPPCP and (6) GMPPCP and the structures of the complexes of the two enzymes involving CoA and different adenyl nucleotides. The explanation was substantially based on two critical substitutions in the amino acid sequence and the local conformational change resulting from them. Dual specificity of the type exhibited by this enzyme is rare and so are the striking difference between two homologous enzymes in the geometry of the binding site, locations of ligands and specificity. The crystal structures of MtPanK in binary complexes with nucleoside diphosphate (NDP) and nucleoside triphosphate (NTP) provided insights about the natural location and conformation of nucleotides. In the absence of pantothenate, the NDP and the NTP bound with an extended conformation at the same site. In the presence of pantothenate, as seen in the initiation complexes, the NTP had a closed conformation and an altered location. However, the effect of the nucleotide on the conformation and the location of pantothenate were yet to be elucidated as the natural location of the ligand in MtPanK was not known. This lacuna was sought to be filled through X-ray analysis of the binary complexes of MtPanK with pantothenate and two of its derivatives, namely, pantothenol and N-nonyl pantothenamide (N9-Pan). These structures demonstrated that pantothenate, with a somewhat open conformation occupied a location similar to that occupied by phosphopantothenate in the “end” complexes, which was distinctly different from the location of pantothenate in “closed” conformation in the ternary “initiation” complexes. The conformation and the location of the nucleotide were also different in the initiation and end complexes. An invariant arginine appeared to play a critical role in the movement of ligand that took place during enzyme action. The structure analysis of the binary complexes with the vitamin and its derivatives completed the description of the locations and conformations of nucleoside di and triphosphates and pantothenate in different binary and ternary complexes. These complexes provide snapshots of the course of action of MtPanK.