Spelling suggestions: "subject:"dissertations -- coperations research"" "subject:"dissertations -- cooperations research""
1 |
Minimising the total travel distance to pick orders on a unidirectional picking lineDe Villiers, Anton Pierre 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MSc)--Stellenbosch University, 2012. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: Order picking is the most important activity in distribution centres. It involves the process of
retrieving products from storage in response to a speci c customer request. The order picking
system in a distribution centre used by Pep Stores Ltd. (Pep), located in Durban, South Africa,
is considered. The order picking system in Pep utilises picking lines. The system requires that
the pickers move in a clockwise direction around the picking line. The planning of picking
lines may be divided into three tiers of decisions. The rst tier determines which Stock Keeping
Units (SKUs) should be allocated to which picking line and is known as the SKU to Picking Line
Assignment Problem (SPLAP). The second tier, the SKU Location Problem (SLP), considers
the positioning of the various SKUs in a picking line. The nal tier considers the sequencing of
the orders for pickers within a picking line and is referred to as the Order Sequencing Problem
(OSP). Collectively, these three tiers aim to achieve the objective of picking all the SKUs
for all the orders in the shortest possible time. The decisions associated with each tier are
made sequentially during the planning of a picking line. Each problem therefore relies on the
information generated by its predecessing tier(s).
Initially the OSP is addressed. A number of heuristic and metaheuristic approaches are presented,
together with an exact formulation to solve this tier. The size of the problem is reduced
by using a relaxation of the problem that may be solved exactly. A number of greedy tour
construction heuristics, a scope and ranking algorithm, methods based on awarding starting
locations with respect to preference ratios and a modi ed assignment approach was used to
solve the OSP. Furthermore, a tabu search, simulated annealing, genetic algorithm and a generalised
extremal optimisation approach are used to solve the OSP. The solution quality and
computational times of all the approaches are compared for the data provided by Pep, with the
generalised extremal optimisation approach delivering the best solution quality.
Two methods from the literature was used to model the SLP, whereafter an ant colony system
was used to maximise the number of orders in common between adjacent SKUs. A number of
agglomerative clustering algorithms were used from which dendrograms could be constructed.
Two novel heuristic clustering algorithms were considered. The rst heuristic calculates a distance
between two clusters as the set of orders that have to collect all the SKUs in both clusters,
whereas the second method is based upon the frequency of SKUs within a cluster. Little or no
improvement was achieved in most cases.
The SPLAP was introduced by means of a number of possibilities of how to formulate objectives.
A possible exact formulation is presented, followed by a nearest neighbour search, which was
initially used to construct new picking lines based on all data sets. A di erent approach was
then taken by means of a tabu search where the waves of two or three picking lines were altered.
Signi cant savings may be incurred for large data sets. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die opmaak van bestellings is die belangrikste aktiwiteit in 'n distribusiesentrum. Dit behels
dat geskikte hoeveelhede produkte uit stoorplekke opgespoor en herpak moet word om aan
kleinhandeltakke gestuur te word. Die bedrywighede binne een van Pep Stores Ltd. (Pep) se
distribusiesentrums in Durban, Suid-Afrika, word beskou. Die sisteem vereis dat die werkers in
'n kloksgewyse rigting om 'n uitsoeklyn beweeg. Die beplanning van die uitsoeklyne kan verdeel
word in drie besluite/probleme. Die eerste besluit is watter voorraadeenhede (VEs) toegewys
moet word aan watter uitsoeklyn. Die tweede besluit is in watter vakkies in die uitsoeklyn die
VEs geplaas moet word, en word die VE-plasings probleem (VLP) genoem. Die nale besluit
is in watter volgorde bestellings opgemaak moet word in 'n uitsoeklyn, en staan bekend as
die volgorde-van-bestellings-probleem (VBP). Die doel van al drie hierdie probleme is om al
die bestellings in 'n uitsoeklyn in die kortste moontlike tyd af te handel. Die besluite wat
verband hou met elke vlak van besluit word opeenvolgend gedoen tydens die beplanning van
'n uitsoeklyn. Die oplossing van elke subprobleem berus op die inligting van die voorafgaande
probleme.
Aanvanlik word die VBP beskou. 'n Aantal heuristiese en metaheuristiese benaderings word
aangebied saam met 'n eksakte formulering om die derde vlak op te los. Die grootte van
die probleem is verminder deur die gebruik van 'n verslapping van 'n eksakte formulering. 'n
Aantal toerkonstruksie heuristieke, 'n omvang en rangorde algoritme, metodes wat gebaseer is
op die toekenning van beginpunte met betrekking tot voorkeurverhoudings en 'n veralgemeende
toewysingsprobleem is gebruik om die VBP op te los. 'n Tabu-soektog, gesimuleerde tempering,
genetiese algoritme en 'n veralgemeende-ekstreme-optimering-benadering word ook gebruik om
die VBP op te los. Die oplossingsgehalte en berekeningstye van al die benaderings word vergelyk
vir werklike data wat verskaf is deur Pep. Die veralgemeende-ekstreme-optimering-benadering
lewer die beste oplossingsgehalte.
Twee metodes uit die literatuur is gebruik om die VLP te modelleer, waarna 'n mier kolonie
stelsel gebruik word om die aantal bestellings wat aangrensende VEs in gemeen het te maksimeer.
'n Aantal groeperingsalgoritmes word gebruik wat dendrogramme kan lewer. Twee heuristiese
groeperingsalgoritmes word oorweeg. Die eerste heuristiek bereken die afstand tussen twee
groepe as die aantal bestellings wat al die VEs in beide groepe moet versamel, terwyl die
tweede metode gebaseer is op die frekwensie van VEs binne 'n groep. Min of geen verbeterings
is in die meeste gevalle gevind.
Die eerste besluit word bekend gestel na aanleiding van 'n aantal moontlike maniere om die
doelwitte te formuleer. 'n Moontlike eksakte formulering word aangebied. 'n Alternatiewe benadering
is geneem deur middel van 'n tabu-soektog waar die golwe van twee of drie uitsoeklyne
gewysig word. Beduidende besparings word gerealiseer vir groot datastelle.
|
2 |
SKU duplication on a unidirectional picking lineFivaz, Desima 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MComm)--Stellenbosch University, 2013. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: PEP is a devision of Pepkor Retail Limited and is the biggest single brand store network in Southern
Africa and also owns and runs the largest clothing factory in Southern Africa. It was founded in 1965
and has since grown to more than 1 400 stores in 9 African countries (there is a PEP store in almost
every town and village in South Africa).
Currently the warehouse management system (WMS) implemented by PEP only allows for a stock
keeping unit (SKU) to be placed on one picking line in one location when the distribution list (DBN) is
released. Because pickers are only allowed to walk clockwise around the conveyor belt, they are forced
to pass a location at least the same number of times as the number of branches to which the SKU is to
be distributed to. Therefore if the SKUs with the highest pick frequency can be assigned to 2 locations
(it is duplicating the SKU), the number of times each of these locations must be passed may be reduced.
In this study 4 questions are considered when 15 algorithms are constructed that will determine how an
algorithm assign the SKUs to picking lines. Question 1 determines whether the original picking lines are
to be treated separately (PS) or to combine them rst (PC). The second question is to decide if the SKUs
are rst to be duplicated and then assigned to picking lines (DA) or if they are rst assigned to picking
lines and then duplicated (AD). Question 3 determines whether the non-duplicate and duplicate SKUs
are treated separately (ND) or simultaneously (S) when they are assigned to the picking lines. The nal
question is to specify how the SKUs are assigned to the picking lines. Three assignment methods (cyclical,
set length subset sequential assignment, remaining high, low cyclical assignment) and 6 clustering
algorithms are introduced.
The conclusion is made that the SKUs with the highest pick frequency is duplicated rst to yield the
biggest saving in the number of cycles. Between 40{70% of the SKUs should be duplicated, dependant
on the algorithm used. The only decision that has a major in
uence on the number of cycles is the
assignment method used. Algorithm 5 and 8 yielded the greatest saving in the number of cycles (40.7%
and 39.8% respectively), both implementing set length subset sequential assignment, followed by the
clustering algorithms. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: PEP is 'n afdeling van Pepkor Retail Limited en is die grootste enkel-handelsmerk winkelnetwerk in
Suidelike Afrika. PEP besit en bestuur ook die grootste klerefabriek in Suidelike Afrika. PEP is gestig
in 1965 en het sedertien gegroei tot meer as 1 400 winkels in 9 Afrika lande (daar is 'n PEP winkel in
amper elke dorp in Suid-Afrika).
Op die oomblik laat die pakhuisbestuurstelsel, wat deur PEP in sy distribusie sentrum ge mplementeer
word, slegs toe dat voorraadeenhede (VEs) in 'n enkele vakkie langs 'n enkele uitsoeklyn geplaas word.
Aangesien werkers slegs toegelaat word om kloksgewys om die vervoerband te beweeg, word hulle gedwing
om ten minste soveel keer verby elke vakkie in die uitsoeklyn te loop as wat die aantal winkels is waarna
die VEs in daardie vakkie versprei moet word. Dus indien die vakkies wat die VEs bevat wat na die
meeste winkels versprei moet word, tussen 2 vakkies verdeel word (die VE word gedupliseer), verminder
die aantal kere wat beide vakkies besoek moet word.
In hierdie studie word 4 vrae beskou wat geantwoord moet word wanneer die 15 algoritmes opgestel
word, wat sal bepaal hoe die algoritme die VEs hanteer. Vraag 1 bepaal of die oorspronklike uitsoeklyne
wat deur PEP verskaf is apart hanteer word en of hulle eers gekombineer moet word. Die tweede
vraag bepaal of die VEs eers gedupliseer word en dan aan die onderskeie uitsoeklyne toegedeel word
en of die VEs eers aan die uitsoeklyne toegedeel word en dan gedupliseer word. Vraag 3 is slegs van
toepassing wanneer die VEs eers gedupliseer word en dan toegedeel word aan die uitsoeklyne, en bepaal
of die nie-gedupliseerde en gedupliseerde VEs apart of gelyktydig hanteer word. Die laaste vraag spesi
seer met behulp van watter metode die VEs toegedeel word aan die onderskeie uitsoeklyne. Drie
toedelingsmetodes (sikliese toedeling, vaste lengte subversameling opeenvolgende toedeling, oorblywende
hoogste/laagste sikliese toedeling) en 6 bondelalgoritmes word voorgestel.
Die gevolgtrekking word gemaak dat die VEs met die hoogste uitsoek frekwensie eerste gedupliseer moet
word om die grootste besparing mee te bring in die aantal siklusse om al die VEs uit te soek. Tussen
40{70% van die VEs moet gedupliseer word afhangende van die algoritme wat gebruik word. Die enigste
besluit wat 'n noemenswaardige invloed op die aantal siklusse het is die toedelingsmetode. Algoritme 5 en
8 lewer die grootste besparing in die aantal siklusse (40.7% en 39.8% onderskeidelik), beide implementeer
die vaste lengte subversameling opeenvolgende toedeling, gevolg deur die bondelalgoritmes.
|
3 |
Tactical sugarcane harvest schedulingStray, Bjorn Jonas 12 1900 (has links)
Thesis (PhD (Logistics))--University of Stellenbosch, 2010. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: Computerised sugarcane harvest scheduling decision support is an active fi eld of research which
ties in closely with the broader problem of automating and streamlining the various activities
in the sugar supply chain. In this dissertation, the problem of providing decision support with
respect to sugarcane harvesting decisions is defined within a number of contexts, each representing
a typical kind of organisation of sugarcane farmers into a cohesive decision making unit with
its speci fic requirements and limitations that exist in practice. A number of variations relevant
to these contexts of an overarching tactical sugarcane harvest scheduling problem (THSP) are
considered and solved in this dissertation. The THSP is the problem of providing objective,
responsible decision support to persons charged with the task of determining optimal harvesting
dates for a set of sugarcane fields across an entire season.
Sugarcane fields typically diff er in terms of the age, variety, life-cycle stage and in many other
properties of the cane grown on them. The growth of sugarcane crops may also be a ffected
by environmental conditions such as accidental fires, frosts or storms which have a detrimental
e ffect on crop-value. Since sugarcane is a living organism, its properties change over time,
an so does the potential pro t associated with it. The practicalities of farming cause further
complication of the problem (for example, seasonal changes alter the conditions under which
the crop is harvested and transported). The rainy season carries with it the added cost of
disallowing long-range vehicles to drive into the fields, forcing the unloading and reloading of
cane at so-called loading zones. Other considerations, such as the early ploughing out of fields to
allow them to fallow before being replanted, compounds the THSP into a multi-faceted difficult
problem requiring efficient data management, mathematical modelling expertise and efficient
computational work.
In the literature the THSP has been viewed from many different standpoints and within many
contexts, and a variety of operations research methodologies have been employed in solving
the problem in part. There is, however, no description in the literature of a solution to the
THSP that takes the negative e ffects of extreme environmental conditions on the quality of
a harvesting schedule into account in a scienti fically justifi able manner; most models in the
literature are based on optimising sucrose yield alone under normal conditions, rendering weak
schedules in practice. The scope of the modelling and solution methodologies employed in this
dissertation towards solving the THSP is restricted to integer programming formulations and
approximate solution methods. The parameters associated with these models were determined
empirically using historical data, as well as previous work on deterioration of sugarcane following
environmental and other events.
The THSP is solved in this dissertation by designing a generic architecture for a conceptual
decision support system (DSS) for the THSP in the various contexts referred to above, which
is capable of accommodating the e ects of extra-ordinary environmental conditions, as well as
the introduction of a computer-implemented version of a real DSS for the THSP conforming to the framework of this generic architecture. The DSS building blocks include prediction
models for sugarcane yield, sugarcane recoverable value under normal circumstances, the costs
associated with a harvesting schedule and the negative e ects on sugarcane recoverable value of
extraordinary environmental conditions. The working of the DSS is based on a combinatorial
optimisation model resembling the well-known asymmetric traveling salesman problem with
time-dependent costs which is solved approximately by means of an attribute-based tabu search
in which both local and global moves have been incorporated. The DSS is also validated by
experienced sugarcane industry experts in terms of the practicality and quality of the schedules
that it produces. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Gerekenariseerde besluitsteun vir die skedulering van suikerriet-oeste is 'n aktiewe navorsingsveld
wat nou verwant is aan die bre ër probleem van die outomatisering en vaartbelyning van 'n
verskeidenheid aktiwiteite in die suikervoorsieningsketting. Die probleem van die daarstelling
van steun rakende suikkerriet oestingsbesluite word in hierdie proefskrif in 'n aantal kontekste
oorweeg, elk met betrekking tot 'n tipiese soort organisasie van suikerrietboere in 'n samehorige
besluitnemingseenheid met sy spesi eke vereistes en beperkings in die praktyk. Verskeie variasies
van 'n oorkoepelende taktiese suikerriet-oesskeduleringsprobleem (TSOSP) wat in hierde kontekste
relevant is, naamlik die probleem om objektiewe, verantwoordbare steun aan besluitnemers
te bied wat verantwoordelik is vir die bepaling van optimale oesdatums vir 'n versameling
suikerrietplantasies oor die bestek van 'n hele seisoen, word in hierdie proefskrif bestudeer en
opgelos.
Suikerrietplantasies verskil tipies in terme van ouderdom, gewastipe, posisie in die lewensiklus,
en vele ander eienskappe van die suikerriet wat daar groei. Omgewingstoestande, soos onbeplande
brande, ryp of storms, het verder ook 'n negatiewe impak op die waarde van suikerriet op
sulke plantasies. Omdat suikerriet 'n lewende organisme is, verander die eienskappe daarvan oor
tyd, en so ook die potensi ele wins wat daarmee geassosieer word. Boerderypraktyke bemoeilik
verder die skeduleringsprobleem onder beskouing (seisoenale veranderings beïnvloed byvoorbeeld
die wyse waarop suikerriet ge-oes en vervoer word). Addisionele koste gaan voorts met die
re ënseisoen gepaard, omdat die plantasies dan nie toeganklik is vir langafstand transportvoertuie
nie en suikerriet gevolglik na spesiale laaisones gekarwei moet word voordat dit op hierdie
voertuie gelaai kan word. Ander oorwegings, soos die vroe ë uitploeg van plantasies sodat die
grond kan rus voordat nuwe suikerriet aangeplant word, veroorsaak dat die TSOSP 'n moeilike
multi-faset probleem is, wat goeie databestuur, wiskundige modelleringsvernuf en doeltreff ende
rekenaarwerk vereis.
Die TSOSP word in die literatuur vanuit verskillende standpunte en in verskeie kontekste oorweeg,
en 'n aantal uiteenlopende operasionele navorsingsmetodologie ë is al ingespan om hierdie
probleem ten dele op te los. Daar is egter geen poging in die literatuur om 'n oplossing
vir die TSOSP daar te stel waarin daar op 'n wetenskaplik-verantwoordbare wyse voorsiening
gemaak word vir die negatiewe e ffekte wat uitsonderlike omgewingstoestande op die kwaliteit
van oesskedules het nie; die meeste modelle in die literatuure is op slegs sukrose-opbrengs onder
normale omstandighede gebaseer, wat lei na swak skedules in die praktyk. Die bestek van die
wiskundige modellerings- en gepaardgaande oplossings-metodologie ë word in hierdie proefskrif
vir die TSOSP beperk tot onderskeidelik heeltallige programmeringsformulerings en die bepaling
van benaderde oplossings deur lokale soekprosedures. Die parameters wat met hierdie modelle
en soekmetodes geassosieer word, word empiries bepaal deur gebruikmaking van historiese data
asook bestaande werk oor die degradering van suikerriet as gevolg van omgewings- en ander
eksterne faktore. Die TSOSP word in hierdie proefskrif opgelos deur die ontwerp van 'n generiese argitektuur
vir 'n konseptuele besluitsteunstelsel (BSS) vir die TSOSP in die onderskeie kontekste waarna
hierbo verwys word en wat die e ekte van uitsonderlike omgewingsfaktore in ag neem, asook
die daarstelling van 'n rekenaar-ge ïmplementeerde weergawe van 'n daadwerklike BSS vir die
TSOSP wat in die raamwerk van hierdie generiese argitektuur pas. Die boustene van hierdie
BSS sluit modelle in vir die voorspelling van suikerrietopbrengs, die herwinbare waarde van
suikerriet onder normale omstandighede, die verwagte koste geassosieer met 'n oesskedule en die
negatiewe e ekte van omgewingsfaktore op die herwinbare waarde van suikerriet. Die werking
van die BSS is gebaseer op 'n kombinatoriese optimeringsprobleem wat aan die welbekende
asimmetriese handelreisigersprobleem met tyd-afhanklike kostes herinner, en hierdie model word
benaderd opgelos deur middel van 'n eienskap-gebaseerde tabu-soektog waarin beide lokale en
globale skuiwe ge ïnkorporeer is. Die BSS word ook gevalideer in terme van die haalbaarheid
en kwaliteit van die skedules wat dit oplewer, soos geassesseer deur ervare kundiges in die
suikerrietbedryf.
|
4 |
Multi-objective optimisation of water distribution systems design using metaheuristicsRaad, Darian Nicholas 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (PhD (Logistics))--University of Stellenbosch, 2011. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: The design of a water distribution system (WDS) involves finding an acceptable trade-off between cost minimisation and the maximisation of numerous system benefits, such as hydraulic
reliability and surplus capacity. The primary design problem involves cost-effective specifica-
tion of a pipe network layout and pipe sizes (which are typically available in a discrete set
of commercial diameters) in order to satisfy expected consumer water demands within required
pressure limits. The problem may be extended to consider the design of additional WDS com-
ponents, such as reservoirs, tanks, pumps and valves. Practical designs must also cater for the
uncertainty of demand, the requirement of surplus capacity for future growth, and the hydraulic
reliability of the system under different demand and potential failure conditions.
A detailed literature review of exact and approximate approaches towards single-objective (minimum cost) WDS design optimisation is provided. Essential topics which have to be included in
any modern WDS design paradigm (such as demand estimation, reliability quantification, tank
design and pipe layout) are discussed. A number of formative concepts in multi-objective evo-
lutionary optimisation are also reviewed (including a generic problem formulation, performance
evaluation measures, comparative testing strategies, and suitable classes of metaheuristics).
The two central themes of this dissertation are conducting multi-objective WDS design optimi-
sation using metaheuristics, and a critical examination of surrogate measures used to quantify
WDS reliability. The aim in the first theme is to compare numerous modern metaheuristics, in-
cluding several multi-objective evolutionary algorithms, an estimation of distribution algorithm
and a recent hyperheuristic named AMALGAM (an evolutionary framework for the simulta-
neous incorporation of multiple metaheuristics applied here for the first time to a real-world
problem), in order to determine which approach is most capable with respect to WDS design
optimisation. Several novel metaheuristics are developed, as well as a number of new variants
of existing algorithms, so that a total of twenty-three algorithms were compared.
Testing with respect to eight small-to-large-sized WDS benchmarks from the literature reveals
that the four top-performing algorithms are mutually non-dominated with respect to the vari-
ous performance metrics. These algorithms are NSGA-II, TAMALGAMJndu, TAMALGAMndu
and AMALGAMSndp (the last three being novel variants of AMALGAM). However, when these
four algorithms are applied to the design of a very large real-world benchmark, the AMALGAM
paradigm outperforms NSGA-II convincingly, with AMALGAMSndp exhibiting the best perfor-
mance overall. As part of this study, a novel multi-objective greedy algorithm is developed by
combining several heuristic design methods from the literature in order to mimic the design
strategy of a human engineer. This algorithm functions as a powerful local search. However,
it is shown that such an algorithm cannot compete with modern metaheuristics, which employ
advanced strategies in order to uncover better solutions with less computational effort.
The second central theme involves the comparison of several popular WDS reliability surro-
gate measures (namely the Resilience Index, Network Resilience, Flow Entropy, and a novel
mixed surrogate measure) in terms of their ability to produce designs that are robust against
pipe failure and water demand variation. This is the first systematic study on a number of
WDS benchmarks in which regression analysis is used to compare reliability surrogate measures
with probabilistic reliability typically derived via simulation, and failure reliability calculated
by considering all single-pipe failure events, with both reliability types quantified by means of
average demand satisfaction. Although no single measure consistently outperforms the others,
it is shown that using the Resilience Index and Network Resilience yields designs that achieve
a better positive correlation with both probabilistic and failure reliability, and while the Mixed
Surrogate measure shows some promise, using Flow Entropy on its own as a quantifier of re-
liability should be avoided. Network Resilience is identified as being a superior predictor of
failure reliability, and also having the desirable property of supplying designs with fewer and
less severe size discontinuities between adjacent pipes. For this reason, it is recommended as
the surrogate measure of choice for practical application towards design in the WDS industry.
AMALGAMSndp is also applied to the design of a real South African WDS design case study
in Gauteng Province, achieving savings of millions of Rands as well as significant reliability
improvements on a preliminary engineered design by a consulting engineering firm. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Die ontwerp van waterverspreidingsnetwerke (WVNe) behels die soeke na ’n aanvaarbare afruiling tussen koste-minimering en die maksimering van ’n aantal netwerkvoordele, soos hidroliese
betroubaarheid en surpluskapasiteit. Die primere ontwerpsprobleem behels ’n koste-doeltreffende spesifikasie van ’n netwerkuitleg en pypgroottes (wat tipies in ’n diskrete aantal kommersiele
deursnedes beskikbaar is) wat aan gebruikersaanvraag binne sekere drukspesifikasies voldoen.
Die probleem kan uitgebrei word om die ontwerp van verdere WVN-komponente, soos op-
gaardamme, opgaartenks, pompe en kleppe in ag te neem. Praktiese WVN-ontwerpe moet
ook voorsiening maak vir onsekerheid van aanvraag, genoegsame surpluskapsiteit vir toekom-
stige netwerkuitbreidings en die hidroliese betroubaarheid van die netwerk onder verskillende
aanvraag- en potensiele falingsvoorwaardes.
’n Omvattende literatuurstudie word oor eksakte en benaderde oplossingsbenaderings tot enkel-
doelwit (minimum koste) WVN-ontwerpsoptimering gedoen. Sentrale temas wat by heden-
daagse WVN-ontwerpsparadigmas ingesluit behoort te word (soos aanvraagvooruitskatting, die
kwantifisering van betroubaarheid, tenkontwerp en netwerkuitleg), word uitgelig. ’n Aantal
basiese konsepte in meerdoelige evolusionˆere optimering (soos ’n generiese probleemformulering,
werkverrigtingsmaatstawwe, vergelykende toetsingstrategie¨e, en sinvolle klasse metaheuristieke
vir WVN-ontwerp) word ook aangeraak.
Die twee sentrale temas in hierdie proefskrif is meerdoelige WVN-ontwerpsoptimering deur mid-
del van metaheuristieke, en ’n kritiese evaluering van verskeie surrogaatmaatstawwe vir die
kwantifisering van netwerkbetroubaarheid. Die doel in die eerste tema is om ’n aantal moderne
metaheuristieke, insluitend verskeie meerdoelige evolusionere algoritmes en die onlangse hiper-
heuristiek AMALGAM (’n evolusionere raamwerk vir die gelyktydige insluiting van ’n aantal
metaheuristieke wat hier vir die eerste keer op ’n praktiese probleem toegepas word), met
mekaar te vergelyk om sodoende ’n ideale benadering tot WVN-ontwerpoptimering te identi-
fiseer. Verskeie nuwe metaheuristieke sowel as ’n aantal nuwe variasies op bestaande algoritmes
word ontwikkel, sodat drie en twintig algoritmes in totaal met mekaar vergelyk word.
Toetse aan die hand van agt klein- tot mediumgrootteWVN-toetsprobleme uit die literatuur dui
daarop dat die vier top algoritmes mekaar onderling ten opsigte van verskeie werkverrigtings-
maatstawwe domineer. Hierdie algoritmes is NSGA-II, TAMALGAMJndu, TAMALGAMndu
en AMALGAMSndp, waarvan laasgenoemde drie nuwe variasies op AMALGAM is. Wanneer
hierdie vier algoritmes egter vir die ontwerp van ’n groot WVN-toetsprobleem ingespan word,
oortref die AMALGAM-paradigma die NSGA-II oortui-gend, en lewer AMALGAMSndp die
beste resultate. As deel van hierdie studie is ’n nuwe meerdoelige gulsige algoritme ontwerp
wat verskeie heuristiese ontwerpsmetodologiee uit die literatuur kombineer om sodoende die on-
twerpstrategie van ’n ingenieur na te boots. Hierdie algoritme funksioneer as ’n kragtige lokale
soekprosedure, maar daar word aangetoon dat die algoritme nie met moderne metaheuristieke,
wat gevorderde soekstrategie¨e inspan om beter oplossings met minder berekeningsmoeite daar
te stel, kan meeding nie.
Die tweede sentrale tema behels die vergelyking van ’n aantal gewilde surrogaatmaatstawwe vir
die kwantifisering van WVN-betroubaarheid (naamlik die elastisiteitsindeks, netwerkelastisiteit,
vloei-entropie en ’n gemengde surrogaatmaatstaf ) in terme van die mate waartoe hul gebruik kan
word om WVNe te identifiseer wat robuust is ten opsigte van pypfaling en variasie in aanvraag.
Hierdie proefskrif bevat die eerste sistematiese vergelyking deur middel van regressie-analise van
’n aantal surrogaatmaatstawwe vir die kwantifisering van WVN-betroubaarheid en stogastiese
betroubaarheid (wat tipies via simulasie bepaal word) in terme van ’n aantal toetsprobleme in
die literatuur. Alhoewel geen enkele maatstaf as die beste na vore tree nie, word daar getoon
dat gebruik van die elastisiteitsindeks en netwerkelastisiteit lei na WNV-ontwerpe met ’n groter
positiewe korrelasie ten opsigte van beide stogastiese betroubaarheid en falingsbetroubaarheid.
Verder toon die gebruik van die gemengde surrogaatmaatstaf potensiaal, maar die gebruik
van vloei-entropie op sy eie as kwantifiseerder van betroubaarheid behoort vermy te word.
Netwerkelastisiteit word as ’n hoe-gehalte indikator van falingsbetroubaarheid geidentifiseer en
het ook die eienskap dat dit daartoe instaat is om ontwerpe met ’n kleiner aantal diskontinuiteite
sowel as van ’n minder ekstreme graad van diskontinuiteite tussen deursnedes van aangrensende
pype daar te stel. Om hierdie rede word netwerkelastisiteit as die surogaatmaatstaf van voorkeur
aanbeveel vir toepassings van WVN-ontwerpe in die praktyk.
AMALGAM word ook ten opsigte van ’n werklike Suid-Afrikaanse WVN-ontwerp gevallestudie
in Gauteng toegepas. Hierdie toepassing lei na die besparing van miljoene rande asook noe-
menswaardige verbeterings in terme van netwerkbetroubaarheid in vergeleke met ’n aanvanklike
ingenieursontwerp deur ’n konsultasiefirma.
|
5 |
An evaluation of the efficiency of self-organising versus fixed traffic signalling paradigmsEinhorn, Mark David 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MSc)--Stellenbosch University, 2012. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: see item for full text / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: sien item vir volteks
|
6 |
On two combinatorial optimisation problems involving lotteriesDu Plessis, Andre 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MComm (Logistics))--University of Stellenbosch, 2010. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: Suppose a lottery draw consists of forming a winning ticket by randomly choosing t m distinct
numbers from a universal set Um = f1; : : : ;mg. Each lottery participant forms a set of tickets
prior to the draw, each ticket consisting of n m distinct numbers from Um, and is awarded a
prize if k minfn; tg or more numbers in at least one of his/her tickets matches those of the
winning ticket. A lottery of this form is denoted by the quadruple hm; n; t; ki, and the prize is
known as a k-prize. The participant's set of tickets is also known as a playing set.
The participant may wish to form a playing set in such a way that the probability of winning
a k-prize is at least 0 < 1. Naturally, the participant will want to minimise the cost
of forming such a playing set, which means that the cardinality of the playing set should be
as small as possible. This combinatorial minimisation problem is known as the incomplete
lottery problem and was introduced by Gr undlingh [16], who also formulated a related problem
called the resource utilisation problem. In this problem one attempts to select a playing set of
pre-speci ed cardinality ` in such a way that the probability of winning a k-prize is maximised.
Gr undlingh [16] studied the incomplete lottery problem and the resource utilisation problem in
the special case where n = t. In this thesis both problems are considered in the general case
where n 6= t. Exact and approximate solution methods are presented and compared to each other
in terms of solution quality achieved, execution time and practical feasibility. The rst solution
method involves a mathematical programming formulation of both problems. Using this solution
method, both problems are solved for small lottery instances. An exhaustive enumeration
solution method, which uses the concept of overlapping playing set structures [5, 16], is reviewed
and used to solve both combinatorial optimisation problems for the same small lottery instances.
The concept of an overlapping playing set structure is further explored and incorporated in an
attempt to solve both combinatorial optimisation problems approximately by means of various
metaheuristic solution approaches, including a simulated annealing algorithm, a tabu search
and a genetic algorithm.
The focus of the thesis nally shifts to a di erent problem involving lotteries. An investigation
is conducted into the probability, P(N; ), of participants sharing a k-prize if a total of N
tickets are purchased by participants of the lottery hm; n; t; ki. Special attention is a orded in
this problem to the jackpot prize of the South African national lottery, Lotto, represented by
the quadruple h49; 6; 6; 6i and how the value of P(N; ) is a ected by the way that participants
select their playing sets. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Gestel 'n lotery-trekking bestaan uit die ewekansige seleksie van 'n wenkaartjie bestaande uit
t m verskillende getalle uit 'n universele versameling Um = f1; : : : ;mg. Elke lotery-deelnemer
vorm 'n versameling kaartjies voor die trekking, wat elk uit n m verskillende getalle in Um
bestaan, en wen 'n prys indien k minfn; tg of meer getalle in minstens een van sy/haar
kaartjies ooreenstem met di e in die wenkaartjie. 'n Lotery van hierdie vorm word deur die
viertal hm; n; t; ki aangedui, en die prys staan as 'n k-prys bekend. 'n Deelnemer se kaartjies
staan ook as a spelversameling bekend.
'n Lotery-deelnemer mag poog om sy spelversameling s o te selekteer dat die waarskynlikheid
om 'n k-prys te wen, minstens 0 < 1 is. Die deelnemer sal natuurlik die koste wat met
so 'n spelversameling gepaard gaan, wil minimeer, wat beteken dat die kardinaliteit van sy
spelversameling so klein as moontlik moet wees. Hierdie kombinatoriese minimeringsprobleem
staan as die onvolledige lottery-probleem bekend en is vir die eerste keer deur Gr undlingh [16]
bestudeer, wat ook die verwante hulpbronbenuttingsprobleem geformuleer het. In laasgenoemde
probleem word daar gesoek na 'n spelversameling van vooraf-gespesi seerde kardinaliteit wat
die waarskynlikheid om 'n k-prys te wen, maksimeer.
Gr undlingh [16] het die onvolledige lottery-probleem en die hulpbronbenuttingsprobleem in die
spesiale geval oorweeg waar n = t. In hierdie tesis word beide probleme in die algemeen oorweeg
waar n 6= t. Eksakte en heuristiese oplossingstegnieke word vir beide probleme daargestel
en met mekaar in terme van oplossingskwaliteit, oplossingstyd en praktiese haalbaarheid
vergelyk. Die eerste oplossingstegniek behels 'n wiskundige programmeringsformulering van
beide probleme. Die probleme word deur middel van hierdie benadering vir klein loterye opgelos.
'n Uitputtende enumerasietegniek, wat gebruik maak van die konsep van spelversameling
oorvleuelingstrukture [5, 16], word daarna in o enskou geneem en beide kombinatoriese optimeringsprobleme
word vir dieselfde klein loterye met behulp van hierdie tegniek opgelos. Die
konsep van 'n spelversameling oorvleuelingstruktuur word verder ondersoek en in 'n benaderde
oplossingstegniek vir beide kombinatoriese optimeringsprobleme ge nkorporeer deur gebruik te
maak van verskeie metaheuristiese oplossingsbenaderings, insluitende 'n gesimuleerde
afkoelingsalgoritme, 'n tabu-soektog en 'n genetiese algoritme.
Die fokus in die tesis verskuif laastens na 'n ander probleem oor loterye. 'n Ondersoek word
geloots na die waarskynlikheid, P(N; ), dat lottery-deelnemers 'n k-prys sal deel indien 'n
totaal van N kaartjies in die lotery hm; n; t; ki gekoop word. Spesiale aandag word aan hierdie
probleem geskenk in die geval van die boerpot-prys in die Suid-Afrikaanse nasionale lotery, Lotto,
wat deur die viertal h49; 6; 6; 6i voorgestel word, en hoe die waarde van P(N; ) be nvloed word
deur die manier waarop deelnmers hul spelversamelings selekteer.
|
7 |
Estimating the effectiveness of a mobile phone network's deferred revenue calculated through the use of a business automation and support systemSmuts, Francois 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MComm (Logistics))--University of Stellenbosch, 2011. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: Mobile phone networks form an integral part of economic and social development globally. Mobile phones have become an everyday part of life and it is hard to imagine a competitive economy without the availability of mobile communications. Emerging markets benefit most from the implementation of mobile technology and growth trends are outperforming earlier predictions. The most popular and sustainable payment model used by mobile phone networks in emerging markets is the pre paid mechanism used for the distribution of airtime. This mechanism brings about unique challenges for networks in emerging markets. In this thesis the importance of the mobile phone network pre paid value channel is introduced through an analysis of pre paid revenue. A brief introduction is given to the systems and products that contribute to the functioning of the pre paid value channel. The revenue generation process is described with regards to the pre paid sector of the market and an in-depth explanation of the importance of deferred revenue is given, how it is recorded and what role it fulfils in the generation of revenue. The complexity of the network environment, both technical and operational makes the use of a business automation and support system (BSS) a necessary tool for effective execution of tasks and processes within the network environment. These systems record information from a wide spectrum of available technical network resources and use this information to automate the flow of network products. The use of such a system for the calculation of deferred revenue is suggested. Saaty‟s Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP) algorithm and the Elimination and Choice Expressing Reality (ELECTRE) method are used to compare the newly proposed method for the calculation of deferred revenue using a BSS.
Using Saaty's algorithm to estimate the effectiveness of deferred revenue as reported through the use of a BSS yields favourable results for the proposed method. This helps to bridge the gap in the poorly researched mobile telecommunications industry. ELECTRE is used to substantiate the findings of the model using AHP and meaningful tests are done to motivate correctness and accuracy of the results obtained throughout. Most importantly, the findings
were shared with academic and industry experts, adding meaningful resemblance to the goals set out to achieve. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Mobiele foon netwerke is wêreldwyd 'n onlosmaakbare deel van ekonomiese en sosiale ontwikkeling. Mobiele fone is deel van ons alledaagse lewe en dit is moeilik om 'n kompeterende ekonomie te bedink sonder die beskikbaarheid van mobiele kommunikasie. Ontluikende markte trek die meeste voordeel uit die implementering van mobiele tegnologie en groeitendense vertoon beter as wat vroeër voorspel is. Die mees gewilde en volhoubare betaalmetode wat deur mobiele foon netwerke in ontluikende markte gebruik word, is die voorafbetalingsmeganisme wat vir die verspreiding van lugtyd gebruik word. Hierdie meganisme bring unieke uitdagings vorendag in ontluikende markte. Die tesis beskryf die belangrikheid van die mobiele foon netwerk voorafbetalingswaardekanaal deur 'n analise te maak van vooruitbetalingsinkomste. 'n Kort oorsig oor die sisteme en produkte wat bydra tot die funksionering van die vooruitbetalingswaardekanaal word verskaf. 'n Beskrywing van die inkomste-genereringsproses vir die vooruitbetaling-sektor van die mark word verskaf en 'n in-diepte verduideliking van die belangrikheid van uitgestelde inkomste, hoe dit vasgelê word en watter rol dit speel in die generering van inkomste word verduidelik. Die kompleksiteit van die netwerkomgewing, beide op 'n tegniese en operasionele vlak, maak die gebruik van 'n besigheidsoutomatisering en ondersteuningsisteem (BSS) 'n noodsaaklike instrument vir die effektiewe uitvoer van take en prosesse binne die netwerkomgewing. Hierdie sisteme stoor informasie vanuit 'n wye spektrum van beskikbare tegniese netwerkbronne en gebruik die inligting om die vloei van netwerkprodukte te outomatiseer. Die gebruik van sodanige sisteem word voorgestel vir die berekening van uitgestelde inkomste. Saaty se Analitiese Hierargie Proses-algoritme (AHP) en die Eliminasie en Realiteit-Deur-Keuse Uitdrukkingsmetode (ELECTRE) word gebruik vir die vergelyking van die voorgestelde metode vir die berekening van uitgestelde inkomste deur middel van 'n BSS.
Die gebruik van Saaty se algoritme om die effektiwiteit te bereken van uitgestelde inkomste soos gemeld deur die gebruik van 'n BSS, lewer gunstige resultate vir die voorgestelde
metode. Dit vul 'n leemte in die swak nagevorsde mobiele telekommunikasie industrie. ELECTRE word gebruik om die bevindinge van die AHP-model te substansieer en betekenisvolle toetse word deurentyd gedoen om die korrektheid en akkuraatheid van die resultate te motiveer. Die belangrikste aspek van die navorsing is dat die bevindinge gedeel is met kenners binne die akademie sowel as die industrie, wat nou aansluit by die doelstellings wat aanvanklik beoog is.
|
8 |
Non-cooperative games on networksVan der Merwe, Martijn 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MSc)--Stellenbosch University, 2013. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: There are many examples of cooperation in action in society and in nature. In some cases
cooperation leads to the increase of the overall welfare of those involved, and in other cases
cooperation may be to the detriment of the larger society. The presence of cooperation seems
natural if there is a direct bene t to individuals who choose to cooperate. However, in examples
of cooperation this bene t is not always immediately obvious. The so called prisoner's
dilemma is often used as an analogy to study cooperation and tease out the factors that lead
to cooperation.
In classical game theory, each player is assumed to be rational and hence typically seeks to
select his strategy in such a way as to maximise his own expected pay-o . In the case of the
classical prisoner's dilemma, this causes both players to defect. In evolutionary game theory,
on the other hand, it is assumed that players have limited knowledge of the game and only
bounded rationality. Games in evolutionary game theory are repeated in rounds and players are
a orded the opportunity to adapt and learn as this repetition occurs. Past studies have revealed
that cooperation may be a viable strategy if the prisoner's dilemma is placed in an evolutionary
context, where the evolutionary tness of a strategy is directly related to the pay-o achieved
by the player adopting the strategy. One of the mechanisms that promote the persistence of
cooperation in the evolutionary prisoner's dilemma is structured interaction between players.
A mathematical framework for representing the evolutionary prisoner's dilemma (ESPD) is developed
in this thesis. The mathematical framework is used to undertake an analytical approach
(i.e. avoiding the use of simulation) towards investigating the dynamics of the ESPD with a
path, cycle, plane grid or toroidal grid as underlying graph. The objective of this investigation
is to determine the likelihood of the emergence of persistent cooperation between players. The
ESPD on a path or a cycle admits two fundamentally di erent parameter regions; large values
of the temptation-to-defect parameter are not capable of inducing persistent cooperation, while
small values of this parameter allow for the possibility of persistent cooperation. It is found that
the likelihood of cooperation increases towards certainty as the order of the underlying graph
increases if the underlying graph is a path or cycle.
The state space of the ESPD with a plane or toroidal grid graph as underlying graph grows
very quickly as a function of the graph order. The automorphism classes of game states are
enumerated to determine exactly how fast the size of the state space of the game grows as a
function of the order of the underlying graph. Finally, the dynamics of the ESPD is investigated
for a grid graph as underlying graph (in cases where the state space is small enough) by means
of constructing the corresponding state graphs of the ESPD. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: Daar is baie voorbeelde van samewerking in the gemeenskap en in die natuur. In sommige
gevalle lei samewerking tot 'n toename in die algehele welvaart van die betrokkenes, terwyl
samewerking in ander gevalle tot nadeel van die bre er gemeenskap mag wees. Die voorkoms van
samewerking blyk natuurlik te wees indien daar 'n direkte voordeel vir die individue is wat kies
om saam te werk. In voorbeelde van samewerking is s o 'n voordeel egter nie altyd voor-diehand-
liggend nie. Die sogenaamde prisoniersdilemma word dikwels as voorbeeld in die studie
van samewerking gebruik om die faktore wat na samewerking lei, te ontbloot.
In klassieke speleteorie word daar aangeneem dat elke speler rasioneel is en dus poog om sy
spelstrategie op s o 'n manier te kies dat sy eie verwagte uitbetaling gemaksimeer word. In die
geval van die klassieke prisoniersdilemma veroorsaak dit dat beide spelers mekaar verraai. In
evolusion^ere speleteorie, daarenteen, word daar slegs aangeneem dat elke speler oor beperkte
kennis van die spel en begrensde rasionaliteit beskik. Spele in evolusion^ere speleteorie word in
rondtes herhaal en spelers word die geleentheid gebied om gedurende hierdie herhalingsproses
aan te pas en te leer. Vorige studies het getoon dat samewerking 'n lewensvatbare strategie
is indien die prisoniersdilemma in 'n evolusion^ere konteks gespeel word, waar die evolusion^ere
ksheid van 'n strategie direk afhang van die uitbetaling van 'n speler wat die strategie volg.
Een van die meganismes wat volhoubare samewerking in die evolusion^ere prisoniersdilemma
voortbring, is gestruktureerde interaksie tussen spelers.
'n Wiskundige raamwerk word vir die voorstelling van die evolusion^ere prisoniersdilemma in
hierdie tesis ontwikkel. Hierdie wiskundige raamwerk word gebruik om 'n analitiese studie (met
ander woorde sonder die gebruik van simulasie) van die dinamika van die prisoniersdilemma op
'n pad, siklus, rooster in die vlak, of rooster op die torus as onderliggende gra ek van stapel te
stuur. Die doel van hierdie studie is om die waarskynlikheid vir die ontstaan van volhoubare
samewerking tussen spelers te bepaal. Die prisoniersdilemma op 'n pad of siklus as onderliggende
gra ek het twee fundamenteel verskillende parametergebiede tot gevolg; groot waardes van die
versoeking-om-te-verraai parameter lei nie tot volhoubare samewerking nie, terwyl volhoubare
samewerking wel vir klein waardes van hierdie parameter moontlik is. Daar word gevind dat die
kans vir volhoubare samewerking toeneem tot sekerheid namate die orde van die onderliggende
gra ek groei.
Die toestandsruimte van die prisoniersdilemma met 'n rooster in die vlak of 'n rooster op die
torus as onderliggende gra ek groei baie vinnig as 'n funksie van die orde van die gra ek. Die
outomor smeklasse van die speltoestande word getel met die doel om te bepaal presies hoe vinnig
die toestandsruimte van die spel as 'n funksie van die orde van die onderliggende gra ek groei.
Die dinamika van die prisoniersdilemma met 'n rooster in die vlak of 'n rooster op die torus
as onderliggende gra ek word laastens deur middel van konstruksies van die ooreenstemmende
toestandsgra eke ondersoek (in gevalle waar die toestandsruimte klein genoeg is).
|
9 |
Order sequencing and SKU arrangement on a unidirectional picking lineMatthews, Jason 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MSc)--Stellenbosch University, 2012. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: An order picking operation in a distribution centre (DC) owned by Pep Stores Ltd, located in
Durban, South Africa was considered. The order picking operation utilises picking lines and the
concept of wave picking. A picking line is a central area with storage locations for pallet loads
of stock keeping units (SKUs) around a conveyor belt. The system shows many similarities to
unidirectional carousel systems found in literature, however, the unidirectional carousel system
is not common. Sets of SKUs must be assigned to pick waves. The SKUs associated with a
single wave are then arranged on a picking line after which pickers move in a clockwise direction
around the conveyor belt to pick the orders.
The entire order picking operation was broken into three tiers of decision making and three
corresponding subproblems were identi ed. The rst two subproblems were investigated which
focused on a single picking line. The rst subproblem called the order sequencing problem (OSP)
considered the sequencing of orders for pickers and the second called the SKU location problem
(SLP) the assignment of SKUs to locations in the picking line for a given wave.
A tight lower bound was established for the OSP using the concept of a maximal cut. This
lower bound was transformed into a feasible solution within 1 pick cycle of the lower bound.
The solution was also shown to be robust and dynamic for use in practice. Faster solution times,
however, were required for use in solution techniques for the SLP. Four variations of a greedy
heuristic as well as two metaheuristic methods were therefore developed to solve the problem in
shorter times.
An ant colony approach was developed to solve the SLP. Furthermore, four variations of a
hierarchical clustering algorithm were developed to cluster SKUs together on a picking line
and three metaheuristic methods were developed to sequence these clusters. All the proposed
approaches outperformed known methods for assigning locations to SKUs on a carousel.
To test the validity of assumptions and assess the practicality of the proposed solutions an agent
based simulation model was built. All proposed solutions were shown to be applicable in practice
and the proposed solutions to both subporblems outperformed the current approaches by Pep.
Furthermore, it was established that the OSP is a more important problem, in comparison to
the SLP, for Pep to solve as limited savings can be achieved when solving the SLP. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: 'n Stelsel vir die opmaak van bestellings in 'n distribusiesentrum van Pep Stores Bpk. in Durban,
Suid-Afrika word beskou. Hierdie stelsel gebruik uitsoeklyne waarop bestellings in golwe opgemaak
word. 'n Uitsoeklyn is 'n area met vakkies waarop pallette met voorraadeenhede gestoor
kan word. Hierdie vakkies is rondom 'n voerband gerangskik. Die stelsel het ooreenkomste met
die eenrigting carrousselstelsels wat in die literatuur voorkom, maar hierdie eenrigtingstelsels
is nie algemeen nie. Voorraadeenhede moet aan 'n golf toegewys word wat in 'n uitsoeklyn
gerangskik word, waarna werkers dan die bestellings in die betrokke golf opmaak.
Die hele operasie van bestellings opmaak kan opgebreek word in drie vlakke van besluite met
gepaardgaande subprobleme. Die eerste twee subprobleme wat 'n enkele uitsoeklyn beskou, word
aangespreek. Die eerste subprobleem, naamlik die volgorde-van-bestellings-probleem (VBP)
beskou die volgorde waarin bestellings opgemaak word. Die tweede probeem is die voorraadeenheidaan-
vakkie-toewysingsprobleem (VVTP) en beskou die toewysings van voorraadeenhede aan
vakkies in 'n uitsoeklyn vir 'n gegewe golf.
'n Sterk ondergrens vir die VBP is bepaal met behulp van die konsep van 'n maksimum snit.
Hierdie ondergrens kan gebruik word om 'n toelaatbare oplossing te bepaal wat hoogstens 1
carrousselsiklus meer as die ondergrens het. Hierdie oplossings kan dinamies gebruik word en
kan dus net so in die praktyk aangewend word. Vinniger oplossingstegnieke is egter nodig indien
die VVTP opgelos moet word. Twee metaheuristiese metodes word dus voorgestel waarmee
oplossings vir die VBP vinniger bepaal kan word.
'n Mierkolonie benadering is ontwikkel om die VVTP op te los. Verder is vier variasies van 'n
hi erargiese groeperingsalgoritme ontwikkel om voorraadeenhede saam te groepeer op 'n uitsoeklyn.
Drie metaheuristieke is aangewend om hierdie groepe in volgorde te rangskik. Al hierdie
benaderings vaar beter as bekende metodes om voorraadeenhede op 'n carroussel te rankskik.
Om die geldigheid van die aannames en die praktiese uitvoerbaarheid van die oplossings te toets,
is 'n agent gebaseerde simulasie model gebou. Daar is bevind dat al die voorgestelde oplossings
prakties implementeerbaar is en dat al die metodes verbeter op die huidige werkswyse in Pep.
Verder kon vasgestel word die VBP belangriker as die VVTP vir Pep is omdat veel kleiner
potensiele besparings met die VVTP moontlik is as met die VBP.
|
10 |
Decision support with respect to facility location and fleet composition for FoodBank Cape TownLanz, Ernest John 03 1900 (has links)
Thesis (MComm)--Stellenbosch University, 2013. / ENGLISH ABSTRACT: FoodBank South Africa is an non-profit organisation formed to establish a national network of
community foodbanks in urban and rural areas of South Africa, with all participants working
towards the common goal of eliminating hunger and food insecurity. FoodBank Cape Town
was the first of these community foodbanks launched in South Africa on 2 March 2009. The
operations of FoodBank Cape Town include sourcing food and redistributing it to agencies
(social services organisations running feeding programmes). Currently the majority of the food
is sourced from the retail sector and then redistributed to approximately two hundred agencies.
The logistics involved in both sourcing and distributing food are vital to the efficient functioning
of FoodBank Cape Town. Since the costs associated with these logistics operations are very high,
streamlining these operations has been identified as a priority area for efficiency improvement.
The focus in this thesis is on the distribution logistics involved, specifically focussing on a facility
location problem according to which FoodBank Cape Town can establish local distribution depots
to which it delivers food and from which the agencies collect food assigned to them.
A mixed-integer programming model is formulated for the above facility location problem and
small test instances of the problem are solved using different exact and approximate solution
methods in order to identify a suitable solution methodology for the full (large-scale) FoodBank
Cape Town facility location problem. The full facility location problem is solved approximately
by means of a meta-heuristic solution method in the more highly constrained instances, while
an exact method is selected for solving the lesser constrained instances. The problem is first
solved based on the distances between the warehouse and the depots as well as the distances
between the agencies and the depots, for the twenty four instances where 17 to 40 depots are
located. The model is then developed further to incorporate the cost of distribution. This
cost-based facility location model is solved with a view to minimise the cost of food distribution
from the warehouse to the depots and the cost of food distribution incurred by each agency
to collect food from its assigned depot. A basic vehicle routing technique is applied to the
cost-based facility location solution and the associated costs of the distribution are updated.
This cost-based solution updating process is performed iteratively until the solution converges.
Since the cost of food distribution depends on the vehicle fleet composition used, a vehicle fleet
composition comparison of possible FoodBank Cape Town vehicles is performed to determine
the most desirable vehicle fleet composition to be used for the distribution of food to depots.
The results of the FoodBank Cape Town facility location problem and vehicle fleet composition
comparison are presented and recommendations are made to FoodBank Cape Town regarding
the preferred number of depots, the location of these depots and the preferred vehicle fleet
composition. / AFRIKAANSE OPSOMMING: FoodBank South Africa is ’n nie-winsgewende organisasie wat ten doel het om ’n nasionale
netwerk van gemeenskapsvoedselbanke in stedelike en landelike gebiede van Suid-Afrika op die
been te bring, waarin al die deelnemers die gemeenskaplike doel nastreef om honger en voedselonsekerheid
te elimineer. Foodbank Cape Town was die eerste van hierdie gemeenskapsvoedselbanke
in Suid-Afrika en is op 2 Maart 2009 gestig. Die take van Foodbank Cape Town sluit
in die versameling van voedsel en die verspreiding daarvan aan agentskappe (gemeenskapsorganisasies
wat voedingsprogramme bestuur). Die oorgrote meerderheid voedsel is tans uit die
kleinhandelsektor afkomstig en word aan ongeveer tweehonderd agentskappe versprei.
Die logistiek wat met hierdie versamelings- en verspreidingsprosesse gepaard gaan, is sentraal tot
die doeltreffende funksionering van FoodBank Cape Town. Aangesien die kostes verbonde aan
hierdie logistieke prosesse baie hoog is, is hierdie aktiwiteite as ’n prioriteitsarea vir verbetering
geidentifiseer. Die fokus in hierdie tesis val op die logistiek verbonde aan die verspreiding van
voedsel deur FoodBank Cape Town, en meer spesifiek op die probleem van die plasing van ’n
aantal lokale verspreidingsdepots waar FoodBank Cape Town voedsel kan aflewer en waar die
agentskappe dan voedsel wat aan hulle toegeken is, kan gaan afhaal.
’n Gemengde heeltallige-programmeringsmodel word vir die bogenoemde plasingsprobleem geformuleer
en klein gevalle van die model word deur middel van beide eksakte en benadere oplossingstegnieke
opgelos om sodoende ’n geskikte oplossingsmetode vir die volle (grootskaalse) Food-
Bank Cape Town plasingsmodel te identifiseer. Die volle plasingsmodel word aan die hand
van ’n metaheuristiese oplossingstegniek benaderd opgelos vir hoogsbeperkte gevalle van die
model, terwyl minder beperkte gevalle van die model eksak opgelos word. Die plasingsmodel
word eers met die oog op die minimering van afstande tussen die pakhuis en verspreidingsdepots
sowel as tussen die verspreidingsdepots en agentskappe vir die vier-en-twintig gevalle van
die plasing van 17 tot 40 verspreidingsdepots opgelos. Die model word dan verder ontwikkel
om ook die koste van die verspreiding van voedsel in ag te neem. Die koste-gebaseerde plasingsmodel
word opgelos met die doel om die voedselbankkoste van voedselverspreiding vanaf
die pakhuis na die lokale verspreidingsdepots sowel as die agentskapkoste van die afhaal van
voedsel vanaf verspreidingsdepots te minimeer. ’n Basiese voertuigroeteringstegniek word op
die koste-gebaseerde plasingsmodel toegepas en die verspreidingskoste word dienooreenkomstig
aangepas. Hierdie aanpassingsproses van die koste-gebaseerde oplossing word herhaal totdat die
oplossing konvergeer. Aangesien die koste van voedselverspreiding afhang van die voertuigvlootsamestelling,
word ’n vergelyking tussen moontlike vlootsamestellings vir FoodBank Cape Town
getref om die mees geskikte samestelling van voertuie vir die verspreiding van voedsel te vind.
Die resultate van die FoodBank Cape Town verspreidingsdepot-plasingsprobleem en vlootsamestellingsvergelyking
word aangebied en ’n aanbeveling word aan FoodBank Cape Town gemaak
in terme van ’n geskikte aantal verspreidingsdepots, waar hierdie depots geleë behoort te wees,
en ’n geskikte voertuigvlootsamestelling vir die verspreiding van voedsel.
|
Page generated in 0.2127 seconds