Au moment où se poursuit l’établissement des princes de l’Église dans la campagne romaine par la construction de somptueuses villas, le Concile de Trente (1545-1563) adopte une série de décrets qui entendent réaffirmer les dogmes catholiques et réformer les mœurs du clergé, critiqués par les protestants. Puisque la villa est perçue au 16e siècle comme un lieu où le fidèle peut faire l’expérience d’une retraite spirituelle, ce mémoire souhaite lever le voile sur les pratiques dévotionnelles suburbaines post-tridentines. Pour ce faire, les cycles picturaux de trois chapelles de villas romaines dont la décoration a été réalisée à la suite de cet important concile sont examinés : la chapelle du palazzo Farnese à Caprarola, appartenant au cardinal Alessandro Farnese (1520-1589), la chapelle de la villa d’Este à Tivoli, construite pour le cardinal Ippolito II d’Este (1509-1572), et la chapelle de la villa Mondragone à Frascati, commanditée par le cardinal Marco Sittico Altemps (1533-1595) pour le pape Grégoire XIII (1502-1585). Il s’agit de vérifier l’impact des pratiques dévotionnelles sur le choix des décors dans ces lieux de culte privés. S’attarder à la perception du regardeur de l’époque et au rapport spirituel du public à l’image implique que nous analysions notre corpus à l’aide d’un cadre anthropologique. / The taste for countryside palaces among the Princes of the Church was already well established when the Council of Trent (1545-1563) moved to counter the protestant Reformation. This council asserted catholic dogmas and significantly reformed clerical mores. In this context, villas are seen as the perfect stage to realize spiritual ambitions. This thesis thus studies extra-urban devotional practices by examining three chapels in countryside palaces around Rome decorated after the Council of Trent: Cardinal Alessandro Farnese’s (1520-1589) chapel in his villa at Caprarola; the Villa d’Este chapel at Tivoli built for Cardinal Ippolito II d’Este (1509-1572); and the Villa Mondragone chapel at Frascati, ordered by Cardinal Marco Sittico Altemps (1533-1595) for Pope Gregory XIII (1502-1585). We seek to examine the influence of contemporary devotional practices on the iconographic cycles in the private sphere. The public’s perception and spiritual response to the frescoes will be probed through an anthropological approach to images.

À l’aube de la Contre-Réforme, on exigea des prélats de vivre plus sobrement et de tempérer leur passion pour l’art et l’architecture. Malgré cela, de nombreux palais furent construits, rénovés et décorés avec faste. Le rôle des palais et de leurs décors dans la mise en scène du pouvoir a été bien démontré, mais peu d’attention a été portée à la fonction dévotionnelle de ces demeures, pourtant destinées aux plus hauts membres du clergé. Cette thèse de doctorat propose la première synthèse des pratiques de dévotion privée des cardinaux à Rome entre 1550 et 1610 à partir de l’étude du mécénat de leurs palais. L’analyse des chapelles domestiques et des studioli des palais Salviati alla Lungara, Altemps, Farnese à Caprarola, del Drago à Bolsena et de la villa d’Este à Tivoli montre l’importante préoccupation des cardinaux pour leur Salut et le rôle de l’art pour susciter, au sein de la demeure, une méditation sotériologique. Ces observations permettent de suggérer que ces exercices se déroulaient non seulement dans les chapelles, mais aussi dans des pièces traditionnellement identifiées comme des studioli. Nous proposons plutôt de les désigner comme des ermitages ou romitori et de les considérer comme des lieux tout aussi importants que les chapelles dans l’élaboration de la piété domestique des cardinaux post-tridentins. À travers les thèmes de la Passion du Christ, de la vie de la Vierge ou des vertus cardinales et théologales, les fresques qui ornent ces espaces furent utilisées comme des outils de contemplation spirituelle du mystère de la Rédemption. L’inclusion de copies d’images miraculeuses ou d’« objets de substitution », au sens qu’ont donné à cette expression Alexander Nagel et Christopher Wood (2010), garantissait en outre aux cardinaux la vie éternelle en échange des prières effectuées dans les pièces où les icônes étaient exposées. Cette admission au paradis était également mise en scène par le déplacement physique ou métaphorique du cardinal dans les logge peintes de verdure ou les jardins des palais. Plus qu’une simple analyse des œuvres et des pièces singulières, cette thèse établit des relations entre les différents espaces des palais, de manière à montrer que le comportement dévotionnel privé des cardinaux dans la Rome de la Contre-Réforme était envisagé comme un parcours spirituel, dans lequel l’art occupait un rôle fondamental. / At the dawn of Counter-Reformation, prelates of the Roman Church were required to live more simply and to moderate their enthusiasm for art and architecture. Nonetheless, many palaces were built, renovated and decorated with pomp by these same prelates. The role of art and architecture in staging the power has been well demonstrated, but less has been said about the devotional function of houses owned by important clergymen. This thesis proposes the first synthetic study of cardinals’ private devotional practices in Rome between 1550 and 1610 by looking at the patronage of their palaces. The analysis of the domestic chapels and studioli of the Salviati alla Lungara and Altemps palaces in Rome, the Farnese palace in Caprarola, the Del Drago palace in Bolsena, and the Villa d’Este in Tivoli demonstrates the important concern of the cardinals for their salvation and the role of art to arouse soteriological meditation within their domestic spaces. This careful examination allows us to propose that these devotional practices were carried out not only in the chapels, but also in rooms traditionally identified as studioli. Rather, we propose to designate them as hermitages or romitori, and to attach to them the same importance as the chapels in the daily piety of the post-Tridentine cardinals. The frescoes decorating these devotional spaces depicted the themes of the Passion of Christ, the life of the Virgin and other biblical figures, and of the cardinal and theological virtues, serving as tools for spiritual contemplation of the mystery of Redemption. The inclusion of copies of miraculous images or “substitute objects”, as proposed by Alexander Nagel and Christopher Wood (2010), further guaranteed the cardinals eternal life thanks to the prayers carried out in the spaces where the icons were exhibited. This admission to paradise was also occasionally staged by the physical or metaphorical movement of the cardinal towards the logge painted with greenery or the palace’s gardens. Thus, more than a simple analysis of singular works or rooms, this thesis establishes a relationship between the spaces of the palaces to show that the cardinal domestic devotional behavior was then viewed and organized as a spiritual journey, in which art played a fundamental role.

While scholarship often focuses on how early modern Italians used images in their devotions, particularly in the post-Tridentine era, little attention has been placed upon how laypeople engaged with devotional text during times of prayer and in their everyday lives. Studies of early modern devotional texts have explored their literary content, investigated their censorship by the Church, or concentrated upon an elite readership. This thesis, instead, investigates how ordinary devotees interacted with holy words in their material form, which I have termed ‘material prayers’. Since this thesis developed under the aegis of the interdisciplinary research project, Domestic Devotions: The Place of Piety in the Italian Renaissance Home, 1400-1600, it focuses primarily on engagement with these material prayers in domestic spaces. Using an interdisciplinary approach drawing from material culture studies, literary history, social and cultural history, and art history, it brings together objects, images and archival sources to illuminate how devotees from across the socio-economic and literacy spectrums accessed and employed devotional text in their prayers and daily life. From holy words, Biblical excerpts, and prayers to textual symbols like the Sacred Monogram of the Name of Jesus, this thesis explores how and why these material prayers were employed for spiritual, apotropaic and intercessory purposes. It analyses material prayers not only in traditional textual formats (printed books and manuscripts), but also those that were printed on single-sheets of paper, inscribed on jewellery, or etched into the structure of the home. To convey how devotees engaged with and relied upon these material prayers, it considers a variety of inscribed objects, including those sanctioned by the Church as well as those which might be questioned or deemed ‘superstitious’ by ecclesiastical authorities. Sermons, Inquisition trial records, and other archival documents have been consulted to further illuminate the material evidence. The first part of the thesis, ‘On the Body’, considers the how devotees came into personal contact with texts by wearing prayers on their bodies. It examines a range of objects including prayers with protective properties, known as brevi, that were meant to be sealed in a pouch and worn around the neck, and more luxurious items of physical adornment inscribed with devotional and apotropaic text, such as necklaces and rings. The second part of the thesis enters the home to explore how the spaces people inhabited and the objects that populated their homes were decorated with material prayers. ‘In the Home’ begins with texts inscribed over the entryways of early modern Italian homes, and then considers how devotees decorated their walls with holy words and how the objects of devotion and household life were imbued with religious significance through the addition of pious inscriptions. By analysing these personal objects and the textual domestic sphere, this thesis argues that these material prayers cut across socio-economic classes, genders, and ages to embody quotidian moments of domestic devotion as well as moments of fear, anxiety and change.